Intl P&G Flashcards
(37 cards)
Name 3 plurality-majority voting systems
- First-Past-The-Post/Simple plurality
- Second Ballot
- Alternative vote
Outline FPTP voting systems
Uses single member districts and candidate-centred voting.
The candidate with most votes (a simple plurality) wins the seat no matter how many candidates and how small the winning margin.
eg: Canada, India, UK, USA
Outline second ballot voting systems
Tries to avoid the disproportionality problem of FPTP systems by requiring the winning candidate to get an absolute majority of the votes (i.e. 50 per cent + 1) in the first round – or if not, a second run-off ballot is held between the two strongest candidates
Eg: France
Define alternative voting
Voters mark their first and subsequent preferences among the candidates for their own constituency. If no candidate receives an absolute majority of first- preference votes on the first count, the candidate with the smallest number of first-choice votes is eliminated, but their second-choice votes are redistributed among the remaining candidates.
Eg: Australia
List 3 proportional voting systems
- List PR system
- Single transferable vote (STV)
- Mixed-member proportional (MMP)
Define List PR system voting
Parties rank their candidates in order of preference, and they are elected in proportion to the number of votes for that party, starting from the top of the list
Eg: Netherlands (lower house), Brazil (lower house)
What is the STV system?
Voters rank candidates according to their order of preference, and elected candidates must either get a specified number of first preferences or else the second preferences are taken into account.
Eg: Australia, Ireland
What is mixed-member proportional voting?
Runs two voting systems at the same time. Plurality-majority districts are used to keep the link between representatives and constituencies, but a list PR system is added for a certain number of additional seats (usually 50%) in order to compensate for any disproportionality that arises from the plurality-majority system.
In Germany, half the additional seats are allotted at district and half at national level, and citizens have two votes, one for their district and one for the national list
Define parallel systems
Like the MMP systems these use the plurality-majority system with a PR system but, unlike MMP, the PR system does not compensate for disproportionality resulting from the plurality-majority system
Eg: Korea, Japan
What is single non-transferable vote?
The SNTV system combines multi-member constituencies with simple majority vote counting, and one vote for each elector.
Eg: Taiwan
What are single-member districts?
One elected representative for each constituency
What are multi-member districts?
Constituencies with two or more elected representatives for each area.
What is an electoral threshhold?
A minimum percentage of the poll required to be elected (to discourage small parties).
What system factors play into voter turnout?
- Importance of election (National election turnout higher than local/presidential and parliamentary elections)
- Democratic systems (Democratic countries have higher turnout)
- Kinds of electoral systems (PR have higher turnout)
- Close, competitive elections
- Frequency election (lower frequency - higher turnout)
- Founding elections (the first democratic elections after authoritarian rule)
What are the main theories of voting?
- sociological/political approaches
- psychological/social approaches
- rational-choice/economic approaches.
What are some of the sociological voting approaches?
The Columbia school:
people vote according to their membership of social groups, and that social groups vote for the party that best serves their interests. Eg: class, religion, race, language, urban–rural differences and sometimes gender, generation and occupation
What are some of the psychological voting approaches?
The Michigan school:
concentrates on individual characteristics, particularly the role of party identification (party ID). This is a relatively stable and enduring feature that individuals acquire as a result of childhood and adult socialization.
‘the funnel of causality’: all the variables affecting voting behaviour are organised according to the theoretical order of their influence.
At the ‘wide end’: most general constraints on voting, such as social background and socialisation.
At the narrowest point: circumstances of particular elections, including attitudes towards party policies, candidates and election issues.
Presidential Systems
Definition: A directly elected executive, with a limited term of office and a general responsibility for the affairs of state e.g. US, Latin America, Africa
the execution of policy: prez appoints cabinet, not allowed to be a member of the legislative
legislative branch: prez initiates legislation but depend on legislature to pass it into law, thus a need for cooperation
fixed tenure:presidents are elected for a fixed term
Parliamentary Systems
definition: have
1. a directly elected legislative body
2. fused executive and legislative institutions
3. a collective executive that emerges from the legislature and is responsible to it (prime minister/chancellor/premier = cabinet/council)
4. a separation of head of state and head of government
prime minister is only the first among equals, all cabinet members share responsibility
party with most support in parliament becomes the prime minister
cabinet chosen by prime minister from members of parliament
executive has collective responsibility for the government (decisions and policies of the cabinet or council are binding on all members who must support them in public)
Semi-Prez System
definition: government consists of a directly elected president, who is accountable to the electorate, and a prime minister, who is appointed by the president from the elected legislature. The president and prime minister share executive power. E.g. France
● the president can appoint the prime minister, dissolve parliament and referendum and call an emergency
● the prime minister appoints a cabinet from the assembly
● attraction for ex-communist democracies: strong public figure and his help to overcome extreme party fragmentation
Juan Linz Pros&Cons of Presidential Systems
Pros:
are strong because they are directly elected and have popular support
can rise above the petty in-fighting of parties and factions and speak for their country and its people.
is a single person who takes all the power of the presidential office.
Cons:
presidents are normally bound by all sorts of constitutional provisions that limit their power:
- must have legislative support for actions, decisions and appointments;
- have to deal with the independence of the courts; and they sometimes face a highly fragmented, undisciplined and ineffective party system that makes it difficult to shape and implement a policy
- do not always have the support of the majority in the assembly, may be unable to implement their policies.
immobilism
presidents have a fixed term of office, which means it can be difficult to remove an unpopular president, but also means a sharp break in policies when a new one is elected
The European Union: federation or confederation?
○ Hybrid of federal and confederal features
○ Federal features: Commission, ECJ, pooled sovereignty on some matters
○ Confederal features: MS want to keep sovereignty
Federal states
middle-level territorial units of government that have a guaranteed status in the constitution → some
independence and autonomy
Cooperative federalism: federal states and state share power and cooperate closely. Eg: GER, SWI
Dual federalism: clear separation of function, powers, and spheres of influence. Eg: AUS, USA
Unitary states
the central government is the only sovereign body. It does not share constitutional authority with any sub-central units of government.
Central government has the formal power to reform or abolish units of sub-central government at will, and can add or take away from its powers and duties as it sees fit.
Eg: most of the old and new democracies of west, central and east Europe as well as Chile, Costa Rica, the Dominican Republic, Israel, Jamaica, Japan, Mali, Namibia, New Zealand, South Korea and Uruguay.