L12/13: Hypothesis Generation Clinical Reasoning in the Subjective Examination of the Lumbar Spine and Pelvis Flashcards
(133 cards)
Why do we use hypothesis generation instead of diagnosis?
- May change over time
- Can never be very sure
A ‘diagnosis’ is dynamic and evolving — an iterative process that accounts for multiple, changing perspectives.
With significant uncertainty and inability to accurately ‘diagnose’, the term ‘hypothesis generation’ is used to reflect our expectations of both ourselves and patients and facilitate a shift in culture
Should we be worried about Red Flags?
NO But we should be vigilant….. Very easy to pick up- just need to be cautious
Physiotherapists are autonomous, first contact practitioners Therefore we need to be able to identify those patients who need urgent medical review and act accordingly.
MSK vs non-MSK pain
- Need to know how to identify
- What are you going to do after identified
What is the most common and main red flag?
Lumbar fracture
What are 5 factors that are most helpful for identifying spinal fractures?
- age greater than 50 years (positive likelihood ratio negative likelihood ratio
- female gender
- history of major trauma
- pain and tenderness
- a co-occurring, distracting/painful injury
What are the 5 diagnostic prediction rules/risk factors for identifying spinal fractures?
- being female
- older than 70 years
- significant trauma
- Does not mean MVA or from height, can be elderly falling==> sudden onset, high load
- prolonged use of corticosteroids
Mid to lower_____ is more commonly fractured in the younger adults
thoracic
What are 5 red flags in back pain?
- Lumbar fracture
- Tumour
- Spinal cord compression
- Infection
- Abdominal Aneurysm
What do you do if you spot a lumbar fracture which is a red flag?
Refer for imaging X ray or MRI
What are 6 features of a tumour (red flag)?
- Constant Pain
- Age over 50
- History of Cancer
- Failure of improvement within 30 days
- Not in mechanical in nature –> sudden get BP
- Unexplained weight loss
- No relief with rest
Where is a tumour (red flag) most common in the back?
Thoracolumbar spine
What are 6 features of a spinal cord compression(red flag)?
- Leg weakness
- Limb numbness
- Ataxia
- Urinary retention
- Hyper-reflexia
- Clonus
What do you do if you spot a tumour which is a red flag?
Immediate medical referral and or refer for MRI
What do you do if you spot a spinal cord compression which is a red flag?
Immediate medical referral and or refer for MRI (CT and blood test)
What do you say to the patient if you spot a possible red flag?
You symptoms are a bit usual and don’t seem to be MSK related. I am just going to take the side of caution and would like to refer you to your GP to get some tests done.
What are 4 features of an infection (red flag)?
- Recent infection
- Concurrent immunosuppressive disorder
- Deep constant pain worsens with weight bearing
- Fever and swelling
What do you do if you spot an infection which is a red flag?
Immediate medical referral
What are 8 features of an abdominal aneurysm (red flag)?
- Presence of peripheral vascular disease or coronary artery disease
- Male, Age over 50, smoker, hypertension
- Family history
- Non-caucasian
- Abdominal girth > 100cm
- Palpable pulsatile abdominal mass (35-40% of cases)
- Unchanging ache, possible night pain
- Dissection – ripping/tearing sensation, pain ++ medical emergency
What do you do if you spot an abdominal aneursym which is a red flag?
Immediate medical referral to A&E
Which 2 red flags need Immediate medical referral to A&E?
- Abdominal aneurysm
- Cauda equina
What are yellow flags?
- Prognostic risk factors
- Hypothesis generation with a biopsychosocial approach INCLUDES identifying the presence of risk factors
What is the relationship between red flags, specific and non-specific LBP?

What are 6 attitudes and beliefs about back pain that are yellow flags?
- Belief that pain is harmful or disabling
- Belief that all pain must be abolished
- Expectation of increased or ‘permanent’ pain
- Catastrophising, thinking the worst
- Belief that pain is uncontrollable
- Passive attitude to rehabilitation “ I want you to fix my back”
What can you do about yellow flags in terms of the lower back?
Recognise this and do what we can to change beliefs
What are 6 yellow flags for LBP?
- Attitudes and beliefs about back pain
- Compensation issues
- Iatrogenic issues
- Emotion
- Family
- Work











