leases, mortgages, co-ownership Flashcards
(82 cards)
π‘ What are the three essential features of a lease?
1) Exclusive possession, 2) Certainty of term, 3) Intention to create legal relations.
leases + licences
π‘ What is exclusive possession?
The right to exclude all others, including the landlord, from the premises.
leases + licences
π‘ Can a lease be created verbally?
Yes, if for β€ 3 years and takes effect in possession (LPA 1925 s.54(2)).
leases + licences
π‘ What is a licence?
A personal permission to occupy land, not creating proprietary rights.
leases + licences
π‘ How do courts distinguish between lease and licence?
By substance: exclusive possession + term = lease, regardless of label.
leases + licences
π Street v Mountford [1985]
- Exclusive possession = lease. Labels and forms do not determine legal nature.
- facts: landlord claimed the occupier had a licence not a lease to avoid tenant protection
π Aslan v Murphy [1990]
- Sham clauses (e.g., landlord keeping key) donβt prevent exclusive possession.
- agreement stated βoccuier could use room part of the dayβ and landlord retained a key
leases + licences
π Antoniades v Villiers [1990]
- courts cpnsider substance over form and any sham clause inserted to exclude possession is excluded
- couple signed two identical documents labelled licences
leases + licences
π AG Securities v Vaughan [1990]
- Different agreements = no unity = licence, not joint tenancy.
- four occupants signed different agreements at different times
leases + licences
π Bruton v London & Quadrant Housing Trust [2000]
- Lease can exist even if landlord has only a licence, provided exclusive possession is granted.
- Bruton was granted exclusive possession by a trust that only had a licence
leases + licences
π Prudential Assurance v London Residuary Body [1992]
- Uncertain term = invalid lease.
- facts: a lease was granted βuntil needed for road wideningβ which granted an uncertain end date
leases + licences
π Mexfield v Berrisford [2011]
Lease for uncertain term treated as lease for life = converted to 90 years under LPA.
leases + licences
π‘ What is the rule from Prudential?
A lease must have a fixed or determinable term to be valid.
leases + licences
π‘ What does Mexfield v Berrisford allow?
Converts uncertain periodic tenancies into 90-year leases if parties are individuals.
leases + licences
π‘ How is a lease of >3 years created?
By deed (LP(MP)A 1989 s.1) and registered (LRA 2002 s.27).
leases + licences
π LPA 1925 s.54(2)
Short leases (β€3 years) can be created orally if in possession and at market rent.
leases + licences
π LP(MP)A 1989 s.1
A lease by deed must be signed, witnessed, and indicate it is a deed.
leases + licences
π LRA 2002 s.27(2)(b)
Legal leases over 7 years must be registered to take effect at law.
leases + licences
π‘ Can multiple people hold a lease together?
Yes, if they have unity of time, title, interest and possession.
leases + licences
π‘ What are the unities needed for joint tenancy?
Time, Title, Interest, Possession.
Co-ownership and trust
π‘ Can two people with separate agreements hold a joint lease?
No, must be one agreement with unities (AG Securities v Vaughan).
Co-ownership and trust
π‘ What is a periodic tenancy?
Tenancy that renews automatically (e.g., month-to-month), can be implied by conduct.
Co-ownership and trust
π Southward Housing v Walker [2015]
Lease of uncertain term for social housing not converted under Mexfield.
π‘ Can a licence become a lease?
Yes, if elements of lease (esp. exclusive possession) are satisfied.