Lesson 6/7/8 Flashcards
(89 cards)
What is the concept of international treaty?
An international treaty is a legally binding agreement which creates reciprocal rights and obligations between international legal persons, recognised as having treaty-making
capacity
Main feature of international treaties:
i. At least between 2 parties (States or international organizations)
ii. Concordant agreement of wills
iii. Typically written (but there is debate on oral treaties)
iv. Establishing rights and obligations governed by international law
■ These rules are found in the Vienna Convention
v. Single instrument or two or more related instruments
vi. what ever its designation (Doesn’t need to be called “treaty” - can be called a convention, pact, agreement, etc.)
Definition of a treaty is found in which article of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties?
- Agreement of concordant wills
- Written
- Between two or more States (bilateral / multilateral)
- Establishing rights and obligations governed by int’l law
- Single instrument or two or more related instruments
- Whatever its denomination –> substance over form
Examples of unique treaties
Maritime delimitation and territorial questions between Qatar and
Bahrain (Qatar v. Bahrain), [2001] ICJ Rep 40 = joint communique (treaty)
Aegean Sea continental shelf case (Greece v. Turkey), [1978] ICJ Rep 3
- minutes of a meeting (treaty)
Types of International Treaties (Classifications)
A) by number of parties (bilateral vs multilateral)
B) by subject (i.e., b/w states or b/w states and ios)
C) by object of the treaty (e.g., trade, environment, human rights, cultural, political)
D) by the duration of the treaty (determined duration or undetermined duration)
E) By openness of the treaty (open to all, closed to original states, semi0closed)
F) Scope of the treaty (contract law, law-making, constituting IOs)
The Codification of the Law of Treaties?
Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties (1969)
What are the Basic Principles of VCLT?
(1) Free Consent
(2) Good Faith & Pacta Sent Servanda
What is representative of consent?
(1) Relative character of int´l treaty law: States are only obliged by treaty rules to which they give explicit consent
(2) Reciprocal character of int’l treaty-based obligations: States are only obliged by a rule vis-a-vis other States that also consent to that same rule (= contract-like)
(3) Dispositive character of int´l treaty norms: treaty rules can be modified by the consent of States
(4) Particular character of int´l treaty law: many rules only apply to States that gave consent, creating a “particular” set of obligations aplicable only inter partes
What is state consent?
expression of the State’s free will
What limits the relevance of State consent?
peremptory norms
What are the stages of consent in conclusion of international treaties? (4 stages)
(1) Negotiation
(2) Adoption of the text (Art. 9 VCLT)
(3) Authentication of the text (Art. 10 VCLT)
4. Expression of consent (Art. II(i) ff VCLT)
Art. 9 VCLT
Adoption of the text
Art. 10 VCLT
Authentication of the text
Art. II(i) ff VCLT
Expression of consent
Why is good faith relevant?
(1) It constitutes the basis of all legal relations
(2) One of the most prominent general principles of law,
(Art 38 ICJ Statute)
(3) It governs the creation and performance of legal obligations, whatever their source, in all legal systems
(4) UN Charter requires all Members to fulfill their Charter obligations in good faith à similar ethos in
Art 26 VCLT regarding Treaty obligations at large
(5) Importance emphasized by ICJ several times, e.g.
Gabčíkovo-Nagymaros (Hungary/Slovakia) [1997] ICJ Rep 7
When has the ICJ emphasized the importance of good faith?
Gabčíkovo-Nagymaros (Hungary/Slovakia) [1997] ICJ Rep 7
Which International Law Subjects have Treaty Making Power?
(1) States
(2) International Organizations
Article 6 VCLT
gives States the capacity to conclude treaties
Who within the State can conclude treaties?
(1) People with full power
(2) Other People by virtue of their function, if so authorized)
Art. 7(1) VCLT
People with full power can conclude international treaties
Art. 7(2) VCLT
People, who by virtue of their function, if so authorized, can conclude treaties
Which Articles of the Spanish Constitution Provide the Framework for the Conclusion of Treaties?
Art. 149.1.3 CE: the State has exclusive competence in matters of “International Relations”
Art. 97 CE: the government directs foreign policy
Art. 63.2, 93 96 CE : procedure for concluding international treaties at the domestic level
What is an International Treaty?
(1) written agreement between a State and other IL subjects
(2) governed by IL
What is an International Administrative Agreement?
(1) not an international treaty, but covered by IL
(2) by organs, organisms and entities of a subject of IL
(3) has a technical nature that executes or concretizes a treaty