Midterm Flashcards
What was the reason for the creation of the Constitution?
Plan to bring about commercial and political stability
What was equality from the constitution aimed at?
Means of balancing power among various states, NOT individuals
Individual states=
citizens
What was the operative element under the constitution?
States, not citizens
What was the primary moving force behind uniform action within the confederacy?
- Fear, but it was weak when individual state interests were at stake
- Only lead to trust when there was collective security as an agreement
Shay’s Rebellion (1786-87)
Caused by lack of money after Revolution, citizens rebelled but it was put down (federal gov couldn’t afford troops)
Annapolis Convention (1786)
Discussed the creation of a system for the uniform regulation of commerce, sparked by “Virginia Acts”- imposed tariffs, no agreement reached
Constitutional Convention (1787)
Follow-up to Annapolis Convention, all but Rhode Island showed up, result of Constitution
Structure of Constitution
-Bicameral Legislature (Senate and HOP)
-National Chief Executive
-National Judicial branch
Does not rule by prohibition
Bicameral Legislature
Provided protection for small states
National Chief Executive
Provided national direction
National Judicial branch
Creation of a strong Federal government mandated the need a Judicial branch to enforce Federal Law
Exceptions to ruling by prohibition in Constitution
- Coinage of currency by states
- Prohibition against state bankruptcy legislation, impaired contractual obligations
Exceptions to protect individual rights
- Protection against suspending habeas corpus
- Protection of those charge with treason
- Guarantee of a jury trial in civil cases
Why was there no Bill of Rights?
- Not needed
- States had their own
- -Federalists argued that inclusion of some rights would disparage those which were not included
Where did the power come from that was redirected by Constitution?
Power that was claimed when US served relationship with England, power predates DOI
Proof from Lincoln and ability to abolish slavery
American sovereignty was founded upon principles in DOI, Constitution was NOT the source of power (*pre-existing right and existence of power before Const.)
Proof of 9th and 10th amendments: Habeas Corpus
Constitution does not create the right of habeas corpus, only suspended in cases of rebellion or invasion of public safety, it is a continuation of pre-existing right
9th amendment
There are rights that may exist outside of ones explicitly stated, but that does not mean they can be violated if not listed
10th amendment
Powers not delegated to US by Constitution, nor prohibited by it to States, are reserved to the States or people
14 amendment
No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the US
Natural Law
Gave the court the inherent power to refuse to follow an illegal law or a “disobedient act”
3 basic sources of rights
- Direct rule or edict
- By interpretation of an organic instrument
- Religion or social custom
Locke’s views
Natural state was not one of violence, could be a natural peace–> Natural Law
Hobbs’ views
Natural state would lead to “war of all against all”, Lord of the Flies
What did Locke create concepts for? (3)
- Property (what man changed became his)
- Money
- Liberty (child is property of parent until old enough)
According to Locke, what 3 things are all men entitled to?
- Lives
- Liverties
- Estates
=property
William Blackstone
- His writings became more popular in America than England
- Infatuated with property
- Took Locke’s views too far and said that “Rights”=property
Paradigm of “Rights”
Seen as property dominated (ex: Dred Scott)
Fundamental Rights
Deemed so essential that the proponent of any diminution must surpass an examination known as “strict scrutiny”, called for in Constitution or Bill of Rights
3 additional fundamental rights
- Freedom to travel
- Freedom to marry
- Right to privacy
All found to be “Rights” (under 9th amend.)
Obergefell v. Hodges (2015)
- We may yet see another basis of “Rights” creation, ***“Rights” before have been tied to either property or pre-existing “Fundamental Right”
- Approval for same sex marriage
Douglas’ Penumbra
Right of privacy older than Bill of Rights that protected intimate relation of husband and wife
Same-sex marriage
Found to be a “fundamental right”, major difference because not under Constitution, new right with no historical basis
Effect of Obergefell
Could lead to a credible claim that other lifestyle choices with a longer history should be afforded similar “Fundamental Rights” protection (ex: cocaine)
What is the first formal charge in a case?
Felony complaint, filed in local criminal court, signed by police officer
Arraignment
Criminal taken to local criminal court, judge “arraigns” criminal, become Defendant, purpose is to formally charge them and inform of rights
Public defender
Provided for criminal if they cannot afford an attorney, given during an arraignment
Preliminary hearing
Purpose is to determine if there is “reasonable cause” to hold defendant for action of Grand Jury, prosecution presents witnesses
Order of preliminary hearing
- DA calls county pathologist to testify how murder was committed
- Killer’s lawyer cross-examines pathologist
- DA calls arresting officer to testify
- Defense attorney cross-examines him
- Continue process with other witnesses
Grand Jury
Purpose is to investigate felonies, consists of 16-23 people, presented proof from District Attorney, *difference is that witnesses are not cross-examined, no judge present
When is the only time the defense lawyer is permitted in the Grand Jury?
When the defendant is testifying
How many votes from the Grand Jury are required to indict?
12 yes votes
Motions
Written requests asking the Court to do something in the case, must be in writing and done no more than 45 days after arraignment
Most common motion requests (3)
- Suppression of evidence
- Suppression of statements
- Dismissal of the charge
Pre-Trial Hearings
Result of motions (ex: Huntley, Wade, Mapp, Ingle), run like prelim hearings, *burden is on DA to est. legality in first instance
The trial
Begins with Jury selection, lawyers (starting with District Attorney) questions jurors
2 major types of challenges in trial
- Challenges for cause
2. Preemptory challenges
How to perfect an appeal (3)
- File an appellate brief
- The State then files a brief
- The appeal is then argued
4th amendment
Prohibits unreasonable searches and seizures, capstone of first 3 amendments about privacy, requires that warrant particularly describes the person or place to be searched
What are some words of limitations that limit the SCOPE of the 4th amendment?
- “unreasonable searches and seizures”
- “papers, houses, persons, and effects”
What are some words of limitations that limit the POWER of the Federal Government to withdraw the freedom from the 4th amendment?
- “probably cause”
- “particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized”
Important of the word “AND” in regards to protection
- Prevented “unreasonable searches and seizures”
- Prevented searches and seizures authorized by warrants issued upon less than probable cause
=broadened ability to search/arrest, created warrantless search and arrest
Warrantless
Must not be “unreasonable”; interpreted to mean probable cause
By warrant
Must have probable cause
Importance of Boyd v US (1886)
Origin of the ***exclusionary rule- search was unreasonable and evidence should have been excluded at trial
Why did Weeks only controvert the Federal Government?
Pre-Mapp, the 4th amendment had no effect upon State searches
Silver Platter Doctrine
Said that federal court could introduce illegally state-seized evidence, as long as federal officers had played no role in obtaining it. Declared unconstitutional in 1960 (Elkins v US)
Selective incorporation
Relies on the Due Process Clause, incorporates only those elements deemed to fall within “due process”
Full incorporation
Relies upon the Privileges and Immunities Clause, deemed to incorporate the entire body of the Bill of Rights