Midterm Exam #1 Flashcards
3 Major Agencies of Canadian CJS
- The Police: Enforcement and crime prevention
- The Courts: Adjunction and legal proceedings
- The Correctional System: Punishment and rehabilitation
CJS
Criminal Justice System
What is Crime?
Varied approaches exist due to the complexities of crime & societal norms
The 3 Primary Types of Definitions of Crime
- Legal Definitions
- Social Definitions
- Constructionist Definitions
Legal Definitions
2 commonly used legal definitions of crime
1. Crime occurs when a law is broken
2. A crime only takes place when a person has been deemed guilty of a crime and punished accordingly
Challenges with Legal Definitions
Not every individual violates the law is caught and punished
Many crimes are unprosecuted even if identified by authorities
Social Definitions
Defines crime as violation of social norms
Views crime as causing social injury or harm, it would be controlled
Constructionist Definitions
Some sociologists contest the existence and clarity of norms
Question the utility of approaches that neglect the reality that norms vary across time and place
Crime is the result of social interaction; negotiated process among the police and Crown prosecutors
A Negotiated Process
Criminal behavior isn’t always self-evident as one might expect
Key Observations (Remain and Leighton Criminologists):
Most Americans have admitted to engaging in crime, but there exists class and racial bias in the administration of crime
Only certain individuals are arrested/prosecuted, revealing the negotiated aspects of identifying crime
For example, if a corporate product leads to someone’s death, most of the time nobody’s held accountable - for some reason, define crime as something between individuals - when it comes to corporations, it gets muddied, and can pretty much only fine them
The 3 Main Objectives of Canadian criminal justice system
- Control Crime - maintain a level of crime
- Prevent Crime - is it possible to completely prevent crime? Need more pain to eliminate want to engage in crime
- Maintain Justice - Expected to deliver fair outcomes
What is Criminal Justice
An abstract and contentious concept
Many Canadians adhere to justice model of criminal justice
Justice Model of Criminal Justice
- Guilt, innocence, and the sentence should be administered fairly with available evidence
- Punishment should fit the crime
- Like cases should be treated alike and different cases differently - rather subjective
Core Values (Justice Model)
- Fair administration of guilt, innocence and sentencing
- Proportionate punishment for the crime
- Equal treatment of similar cases; differing treatment for dissimilar cases
Home Invasion vs Break and Enter
Home invasion - doesn’t matter if people are home
Break and enter - when nobody is home and theft occurs
2 Types of Law
Public law/criminal law - rules for individuals to abide by in society
Private law - relationships between individual actors (legal contracts)
OJ Simpson dealt with both
Criminal Code of Canada
Criminal law isn’t a static - its constantly changing (prostitution laws)
Is over 1,100 pages- has to be reviewed at least twice a year
Problems regarding it - McCann (2010) case might’ve resulted in mistrial given the judge used a provision that had been struck down
There are still laws restricting witchcraft, water skiing after dark and attending an immoral theatrical performance
Travis Vader gets life sentence for murdering an elderly couple - judge ended up lessening the charge, reduced sentence to manslaughter instead of second degree murder
Prostitution Laws
Were struck down in 2013 - selling sex isn’t illegal - however new legislation allows police to investigate advertising of sexual services, trafficking and purchasing of sexual services
Classifying Crime
2 general categories used to differentiate seriousness of crime
Mala prohibita: Behavior that’s prohibited by law
Mala in se: Behavior that’s immoral/evil
Criminal code differentiates between seriousness of crime specifically with reference to summary offences (misdemeanours) and indictable offences (felonies)
Who has the ability to determine what the charges should be?
The crown prosecutor
Police officers role is to investigate and get as much evidence
Summary Offences
Jail sentence of up to 2 years or 5,000$ fine
Indictable Offences
Can result in life imprisonment
Hybrid Offences/Dual Offences
Cases where crown prosecutor decides whether the case should be treated as a summary/indictable offence (sexual offences, break and entering)
Levels of Police
3 levels of police agencies in Canada: Municipal, provincial and federal
Most police work at municipal level
in 2015 - 68,700 police officers in Canada