Mildenhall Flashcards

(174 cards)

1
Q

What is risk?

A

Effect of uncertainty on objectives
effect is a deviation from what is expected
caused by events which have consequences

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

What does it mean for a risk to be time-separable?

A

If a measure of the magnitude of the risk of an amount at a future time can be expressed as the product of (1) the magnitude of the risk if immediately due (2) a discount factor

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

What are some types of risk?

A

Asset
catastrophe
underwriting
reserve
operational
strategic
reputational
compliance
credit
market

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

What is systemic risk?

A

affects a financial system consisting of many interacting agents or firms
occurs when event causes a chain reaction
SIFIs generate systemic risk (too big to fail companies)
P&C insurers not usually SIFIs, but AIG (life) was in β€˜08
interaction of rating plans is a source of systemic risk for insurers (combo of adverse selection and the winners curse)
cats are SYSTEMATIC, not systemic.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

What’s the difference between objective and subjective probabilities?

A

Objective: amenable to precise determination (repeated obs), applies LLN, CLT, bayesian stats to make precise predictions about samples
Subjective: provide a way of representing a degree of belief (applied to nonrepeatable events: election, horse race, economic outcome)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

What is another term for process risk?

A

Aleatoric uncertainty
Epistemic refers moreso to model risk (knowledge gap)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

What is the explicit representation of risk outcomes?

A

represent outcomes with a unique identifier such as pol num, VIN, date and time of loss, GPS location of accident
an element x of sample space
strength = enables outcomes to be linked across a book of business (model dependence risk)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

What is the implicit representation of risk outcomes?

A

identifies an outcome with its value
easy to understand, hard to aggregate
cant distinguish between implicit events with the same loss outcome

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

What is the dual implicit representation of risk outcomes?

A

if we only care about the rank of the outcomes
identify outcome X = x with its nonexceedence probability F(x)
or we can identify with exceedence probability S(x)
disadv: relative to an often unspecified reference portfolio
e.g. bond default probability groups

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

What is a risk measure?

A

a real-valued functional on a set of random variables that quantifies a risk preference
risk measure conducts a β€œtaste-test” so to speak
given two, which is preferred? (lower risk)
examples: NAICs RBC or a rating plan
numerical representation of risk preferences

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

What is a risk preference?

A

Something that models the way we compare risks and decide between them
defined on a set of loss RVs S
X >= Y if X is preferred to Y if X>=Y and Y>= X we are neutral

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

What three properties should a risk preference for insurance outcomes have?

A

Complete => for any pair of prospects either X>=Y, Y>=X or both
Transitive if X>= Y and Y>=Z then X>=Z
Monotonic if X <= Y in all outcomes then X >= Y

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

What three characteristics of a random variable do risk measures capture?

A

(1) Volume => smaller risks are preferred
(2) Volatility => less volatility is preferred
(3) Tail => lower likelihood of extreme outcomes is preferred (one-sided)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

What is a capital risk measure?

A

determines assets needed to back an existing or hypothetical portfolio at a given level of confidence
used by company to determine economic vapital
regulator to determine MCR

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

What is a pricing risk measure?

A

determines expected profit insureds need to pay in total to make it worthwhile for investors to bear the portfolios risk
aka premium calculation principles (pcps)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

What form of a risk measure is known as dual utility theory?

A

Adjusting probabilities by the rank of their loss but don’t change the loss
leads to spectral risk measures g: [0,1] => [0,1] must satisfy g(0) = 0 and g(1) = 1

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

What does the law invariance property refer to?

A

The risk measure relies solely on the distribution function F(x).

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

What are the advantages of VaR?

A

Simple to explain
estimated robustly
always finite
widely used by regulators, rating agencies, and companies in internal risk assessment

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

How is PML different from MFL

A

PML refers to the largest loss in a building likely to suffer from a single fire if critical protection systems function as expected
MFL is if the protection systems all fail

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

adjusted probability formula for occurrence PMLs

A

1 + ln(p) / lambda

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

Aggregate VaR adjusted probability

A

1 - (1-p) / lambda

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

Formula to approximate sum of VaRs

A

when Xo is thin-tailed
when X1 is an independent thick-tailed
Var(Xo + X1) β‰ˆ E[Xo] + Var(X1)
better as p gets higher.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

When is a distribution thin-tailed?

A

When it’s bounded or has a log concave density
aka superexponential

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

What are three ways VaR can fail to be subadditive?

A

With a highly asymmetric dependence structure
when the marginals are heavily skewed
when the marginals are very thick-tailed

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
What's the worst pairing of X1 and X2 in terms of subadditivity?
not the comonotonic pairing given 10,000 pairs, we want the 100th largest to be maximized for 0.99 VaR crossed pairing is the solution: 1st with 100th, 2nd with 99th... etc works for any 2 nontrivial marginals values below p var DONT matter creates risk ONLY at p.
26
How can VaR subadditivity fail for skewed marginals?
Suppose 2 iid exponentials with mean 1. X1 + X2 ~ Gamma(alpha = 2) Var xi = 1.204 varsum = 2.439 subadditive for p < 0.7.
27
Whats the formula for a normal distributions TVaR?
mu + [sigma * phi(zp)] / (1 - p) phi = [e^-(z^2/2)] / sqrt(2pi)
28
Whats the formula for a lognormal distributions TVaR?
[E[X] * dist_func(sigma - zp)] / (1-p)
29
TVaR for variables with density c(a) x^a g(x)
g(x) doesn't involve powers of x alone or a = c(a) / c(a+1) * [1 - F(q(p): a+ 1)] / [1 - F(q(p): a] examples: gamma, generalized beta
30
What is PELVE?
Probability equivalent level of VaR and TVaR constant c such that TVaR(1 - c*epsilon) = VaR(1 - epsilon) for small epsilon c usually > 2.5
31
What are the formulas for the upper and lower CTE?
LOWER: 𝖒𝖳𝖀𝑝(𝑋) ∢= 𝖀[𝑋 ∣ 𝑋 β‰₯ 𝖡𝖺𝖱𝑝(𝑋)] UPPER: 𝖀[𝑋 ∣ 𝑋 β‰₯ π‘ž+(𝑝)]
32
What is the formulas for the WCE?
Worst conditional expectation, aka highest E[X] over a subset of the sample space with at least probability 1- p 𝖢𝖒𝖀𝑝(𝑋) ∢= sup {𝖀[𝑋 ∣ 𝐴] ∣ 𝖯𝗋(𝐴) > 1βˆ’π‘}
33
When will WCE, CTE, and TVaR not all be the same?
For discrete distributions when p coincides with a mass point
34
Whats the equality for WCE, CTE, TVaR, and VaR?
𝖡𝖺𝖱𝑝(𝑋)≀𝖒𝖳𝖀𝑝(𝑋)≀𝖢𝖒𝖀𝑝(𝑋)≀𝖳𝖡𝖺𝖱𝑝(𝑋)
35
What optimization problem do TVaR and VaR solve?
𝖳𝖡𝖺𝖱𝑝(𝑋) = minπ‘₯ {π‘₯ +(1βˆ’π‘)βˆ’1𝖀[(𝑋 βˆ’π‘₯)+]} 𝖡𝖺𝖱𝑝(𝑋) = argminπ‘₯ {π‘₯ +(1βˆ’π‘)βˆ’1𝖀[(𝑋 βˆ’π‘₯)+]}. TVaR balances the cost of providing capital against the cost of a shortfall
36
What is the formula relating expected policyholder deficit and TVaR?
𝖀[(π‘‹βˆ’π‘Ž)+]=(1βˆ’πΉ(π‘Ž))(𝖳𝖡𝖺𝖱𝐹(π‘Ž)(𝑋)βˆ’π‘Ž). 𝖳𝖡𝖺𝖱𝑝(𝑋) = 𝖡𝖺𝖱𝑝(𝑋)+ 𝖀[(𝑋 βˆ’π–΅π–Ίπ–±π‘(𝑋))+] / (1- p)
37
What is the Lloyd's definition of a realistic disaster scenario (RDS)?
An insurance event that is potentially disastrous but plausible Events: E1.... EN
38
What is the formula for a conditional probability scenario?
π–°π‘˜(𝐴) ∢= 𝖯(π΄βˆ©π΅π‘˜) / 𝖯(π΅π‘˜) π΅π‘˜ ∢= 𝐡(πΈπ‘˜) to be the set of all sample points where the insurance event πΈπ‘˜ occurs, i.e., those with the value 1 in the π‘˜th place.
39
Coherent risk measure form:
πœŒπ‘(𝑋) ∢= max{πΈπ–°πŸ£[𝑋],…,𝐸𝖰𝗋[𝑋]}
40
What are the two types of uncertainty associated with P?
1. Statistical uncertainty: 𝖯 is an estimate subject to the usual problems of estimation risk 2. Information uncertainty: 𝖯 is based on a limited and filtered subset of ambiguous information
41
What are generalized (non-conditional) probability scenarios?
Scenarios such as insureds being systematically misclassified, adverse selection, parameter error, take the expected losses of all and compute the maximum E[X]
42
What are some advantages of the risk measure pc (allows generalized probability scenarios)?
● is intuitive and easy to communicate, ● can be used for capital and pricing, ● has properties as a risk measure that are aligned with rational risk preferences, and ● any measure with those properties is a πœŒπ‘ for some set of probability scenarios.
43
Translation invariance
p(X+c) = p(X) + c requires p to be in monetary units VaR, TVaR and a scenario loss at TI sd, variance, and higher order central moments aren't TI
44
Normalized property of a risk measure
p(0) = 0 risk of an outcome with no gain or loss is zero a risk is preferred to doing nothing if p(X) <= 0 (aka "acceptable")
45
Monotone property
If X<=Y for all outcomes then X >= Y (preferred over Y) all pc risk measures are monotone sd is not monotone.
46
What is the no ripoff property?
if X <= c then p(X) <= c
47
Positive loading property
p(X) >= E[X] not all pc have this property, generally larger Q means more likely it does
48
Monetary risk measures
satisify MON and TI
49
Positive homogeneous
p(lambda X) = lambda * p(X) scale invariance PH implies NORM since p(0) = p(0 x X) = 0 * p(X)
50
Lipschitz Continuous property
the difference in risk between random variables X and Y is at most the maximum of their outcome differences |p(x) - p(y)| <= MAX(|X - Y|)
51
Subadditive property
𝜌(𝑋+π‘Œ) ≀ 𝜌(𝑋)+𝜌(π‘Œ) the risk of the pool is less than or equal to the sum of its parts mergers do not increase risk implies p(0) >= 0
52
Sublinear property
PH and SA hold. sublinear pricing risk measures have a positive bid-ask spread ask price = p(X) bid price = -p(-X)
53
Comonotonic property
X and Y are COMON if X = g(Z) and Y = h(Z) for increasing functions g and h and a common variable Z different excess layers of a risk Z are comonotonic
54
Comonotonic additive property
p(X+Y) = p(X) + p(Y) if X and Y are comonotonic
55
Independent additive property
p(X+Y) = p(X) + p(Y) if X and Y are independent Variance is an example
56
Where is law invariance not appropriate?
for some pricing applications, certain risks may have the same distribution but one is definitely more risky (florida hurricane risk vs auto liability) CAPM is not LI. same return distribution but correlation to the market is what matters.
57
Coherence requirements
monotone translation invariant positive homogeneous subadditive
58
Spectral risk measure requirements
coherent law invariant comonotonic additive
59
What is a compound risk measure?
a combination of a pricing risk measure (p) and a capital risk measure (a) p(x) = p(X ^ a(x))
60
What are some issues with the expected utility representation when applied to firms?
firms dont have diminishing marginal utility of wealth firm preferences aren't relative to a wealth level utility theory combines attitudes to wealth and risk not linear and thus expected utility isnt a monetary risk measure based on combination through mixing, not pooling, counter to insurance
61
What is an event in insurance?
a set of circumstances likely to result in insurance losses occurrence of a hurricane traffic jam
62
What is the ad hoc method for selecting a risk measure?
start with a seemingly reasonable risk measure and rationalize it by establishing it has properties desired (or argue against it) e.g. constant underwriting margin
63
What is the economic method for selecting a risk measure?
use a rigorous economic theory to select a risk measure set up and solve an optimization problem (utility-based approaches)
64
What is the characterization method for selecting a risk measure?
start with a list of desirable properties and then determine which risk measures have those characteristics
65
What are the most important properties of a risk measure?
Monotone and TI (intuitive) ability to be allocated diversification must be reflected Backtesting (consistent with observations) Explainable (sell to users) Elicitability (estimated via regression-like techniques) Robustness / continuity theoretic soundness and consistency MAD BEER (T)
66
What are 5 desirable characteristics of risk margins?
1.The less that is known about the current estimate and its trend, the higher the risk margins should be. 2. Risks with low frequency and high severity have higher risk margins than risks with high frequency and low severity. 3. For similar risks, contracts that persist over a longer time-frame have higher risk margins than those of shorter duration. 4. Risks with a wide probability distribution have higher risk margins than risks with a narrower distribution. 5. To the extent that emerging experience reduces uncertainty, risk margins decrease, and vice versa.
67
What are the 8 gradations of tail-thickness?
(1) No mean. VaR is not subadditive. LLN doesn't apply. Impossible to insure. (2) Mean no variance: LLN applies by CLT doesnt (3) mean and var finitely many moments: LLN and CLT apply (4) all moments, sub exponential: decays slower than exponential e^kx * S(x) => inf for all k>0 (5) exponential tail (dividing line between thick and thin) (6) super exponential : thin-tailed e^kx*S(x) => 0 for all k > 0 (7) log concave density: proportional to -x^2 (sample averages tightly clustered around the sample mean) (8) bounded.
68
What is the intended purpose and the intended user of a model?
Intended purpose: The goal or question, whether generalized or specific, addressed by the model within the context of the assignment. Intended User: Any person whom the actuary identifies as able to rely on the model output.
69
What are some intended purposes of risk measures?
Individual risk pricing: quoting and evaluation of market pricing classification rate making: setting profit margins and allocating cost of capital portfolio management: reinsurance purchase, ORSA, Capital: determine risk capital or evaluating held capital
70
What should be considered in selecting a PCP?
Explainable: reasonable, transparent, and explainable basis Estimable: from market prices Computable Robust Allocation Optimal Diversification Law Invariant Theoretically sound: consistent with economic, financial theory, and behavioral considerations
71
What should be considered in selecting a capital risk measure, that is in addition to selecting a PCP?
Robustness to regulatory arbitrage: balance complexity against data available Simplicity and explainability (to regulators) Standardization and reliance on public data enables comparison Backtesting (was the portfolio managed to a risk measure tolerance?) Optimization against a regulatory standard
72
Semivariance risk measure
𝖀[𝑋]+𝑐𝖀[(π‘‹βˆ’π–€π‘‹) ^ 21𝑋>𝖀[𝑋]]
73
Dutch risk measure
𝖀𝑋+πœ†β€–(π‘‹βˆ’π–€π‘‹)+β€–1
74
Higher order semideviation risk measure
𝖀𝑋+𝑐‖(π‘‹βˆ’π–€π‘‹)+β€– can also be from target tau (replace E[X] with tau)
75
Esscher transform risk measure
𝖀[π‘‹π‘’β„Žπ‘‹]βˆ•π–€[π‘’β„Žπ‘‹]
76
Absolute semideviation risk measure
𝖀[(π‘‹βˆ’π–€π‘‹)+]=β€–(π‘‹βˆ’π–€π‘‹)+β€–1
77
Zero utility risk measure
Solve E[u(R - X)] = 0 for R
78
What are three sources of demand for an insurance contract?
(1) Risk transfer: Pool their risk with other insureds and reap the benefits of diversification (2) Satisfying demand: satisfies certain statutory, regulatory, or contractual requirements in order for the insured to carry out an activity such as driving (3) Risk financing: seeks to finance uncertain future contingencies in an efficient manner (driven by accounting, regulation, and tax law) can make expenses tax deductible by making them an insurance deductible (e.g. SIRs, retro-pols, large ded)
79
What services do insurance companies provide?
sales, marketing, risk surveys, loss control, customer billing and support, underwriting and pricing, claims adjusting, risk bearing, and investment management services
80
What are the two critical functions of managing a risk pool?
(1) Controlling access to the pool through underwriting and pricing (2) Ensures the pool remains solvent by funding risk-bearing assets through the sale of liabilities
81
What are some examples of insurance services provided by non-insurers?
Customer functions can be handled by a direct writer, or independent agents and brokers MGUs can manage a risk pool themselves reinsurance and sidecar arrangements can provide capital services third party claims adjustment asset management services
82
Why don't insureds just work directly with investors, instead of using insurers?
underwriting is costly and requires an accumulation of private loss data insurer capital is costly and risk pools allow it to be used more efficiently long-lived risk pools signal competence, thus lowering the cost of capital
83
What is parametric insurance and basis risk?
pay losses based on an explicit event outcome defined by an objective physical description easy to UW (doesn't depend on the insured characteristics) hard to ensure insured actually has a loss when claim is triggered basis risk: mismatch between subject loss and insurance recovery
84
In insurance contracts, what is a dual-trigger basis?
objective event occurs AND it causes an economic loss to the insured indemnty payment is a function of the subject loss
85
What conditions must an indemnity function f and subject loss L satisfy?
(1) f(L) <= L (2) f(L) >= 0 (3) f(L) is monotonic (4) L - f(L) is monotonic (5) f is continuous
86
What's an example of a policy condition that doesn't satisfy the conditions of an indemnity function?
A franchise or diminishing deductible. Has jumps.
87
What is a fixing date established by a receiver in an insurer insolvenct?
Deadline for filing claims against its assets
88
What is the pecking order in an insurer insolvency according to the NAIC Receivership Model Act?
Class 1 = Admin expenses Class 2 = Guarantee association expenses Class 3 = insurance claims and UEP Class 4 = mortgate & financial guaranty claims and all other forms of insurance class 5 = federal government claims class 6 = debts due to employees class 7 = claims of other unsecured creditors including claims under reinsurance deals class 8 = claims of local governments class 11 = surplus notes, capital notes class 13 = shareholders
89
How is capital different from equity?
Capital is assets net of all policyholder liabilities (loss reserves and UEP reserves) Equity is the value of the owners residual interest in the firm assets net of all liabilities owed except the owners
90
What does the price to book ratio compare?
Ratio of equitys market value to its accounting (book) value for publicly traded companies (stock insurers, not mutual insurers)
91
What is common equity?
by law all stock companies must include a lowest priority ownership interest called common shareholders they bear the ultimate risk and receive the benefit of success governance rights and appoint the BOD and management can be paid dividends but not guaranteed franchise value is an important component of equity
92
three components of common equities accounting value
(1) capital stock: par value of shares issued (2) additional paid-in capital: stock price excess over par (3) retained earnings: cumulative
93
How does mutual insurer ownership work?
owned by policyholders who have a noncertificated ownership interest collectively own the equity but dont have transfersble share certificates and can only own collectively, not individually (cant sell their interests)
94
What is preferred equity?
blends characteristics of debt and equity. sits above common equity and below debt. pays a dividend but can be suspended without triggering default debt can trigger default.
95
What are 6 reasons why insurer capital is expensive?
(1) Principal - agent problem: investor and management interest misalignment (insurance is obaque and tough to monitor management) (2) no independent validation of insurance pricing (cat risk is an exception) (3) requires long-term commitment to a cyclical business (4) returns are left-skewed. (5) regulatory minimum capital standards can force an insurer into supervision before its technically insolvent which can restrict dividend payments (6) double taxation (corporate taxes and dividends are taxed)
96
What are the benefits of cat bonds over equity for an insurer to raise capital?
(1) no market risk (2) diversifying, zero-beta asset class (not tied to financial market) (3) investors can validate loss costs and quantify risk potential independently (4) limited adverse selection (pricing based on detailed exposure data) (5) no principal-agent issues since cash flows are contractually defined (6) taxes: usually written in tax-free jurisdictions (7) no regulation: written in lightly regulated jurisdictions (8) limited tenor: 3-5 yr terms
97
What is the weighted average cost of capital (WACC)?
all non-equity capital has an explicit cost combine all forms of capital by sumproduct the weights and costs cost of equity capital can come from an academic study or a peer study considering historical returns, volatility and P/B ratios reinsurance cost = ceded premium - expected recoveries and lost investment income debt and reinsurance expenses are tax deductible equity largely drives the WACC.
98
What are two important theories of capital structure?
(1) Trade-off theory: argues debt and equity mix trades off the costs and benefits of each (notably expense of equity vs right of debt holders to force bankruptcy) (2) Pecking order theory: informational asymmetries b/w mgmt and owners makes equity more expensive, favoring retained earnings
99
What are the three valuation standards insurers are subject to?
(1) Statutory or regulatory standards (US NAIC, EU Solvency II) (2) Financial reporting (GAAP, IFRS) (3) Rating agencies (S&P, AM Best)
100
What are two considerations in adjusting accounting to reflect true economics?
(1) Accounting conventions have real-world consequences (company default based on its accounts, regulators can take over an insurer as a conservator when accounts breach a certain threshold) (2) markets can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent (models assume unlimited financing for insurers)
101
What is the general structure of the EUs solvency II?
considers assets, liabilities, and own funds market valuation of assets and liabilities = best estimate + risk margin MCR = below which entity withdraws from the market SCR = estimated via standard formula, internal model, or both Free assets = amounts in excess of SCR one year stability criterion. 99.5% VaR
102
Describe NAIC Statutory accounting.
liquidation basis accounting regulators evaluate balance sheet to see if funds exist to pay current and future policyholder benefits non-admitted assets (non-liquid) are subtracted from assets liabilities are booked on a net basis
103
Describe GAAP
follows SAP for loss reserves, booked at mgmt best estimate on a nominal basis however, gross of reinsurance with reins recoverable as an asset allows acquisition expense to be deferred, unlike SAP
104
Describe IFRS
More market oriented than GAAP. loss reserves are valued on a discounted basis including a risk adjustment profits are earned over the payout period of reserves
105
What is the fundamental theorem of risk theory?
An insurer charging the expected loss rate is guaranteed to fail in a finite length of time regardless of the starting surplus
106
Exponential PCP formula
P = log(E[e^(pi*X)]) / pi zero-utility for exponential function u(x) = (1 - e^(-pi * x)) / pi reminder: P solves E[u(P-X)] = 0
107
Ferrari formula for total ROE decomposition
Income / Equity = U/P * P / Q + I / a * a / Q UW margin x UW leverage + Investment return * Investment leverage
108
Alternate ferrari total ROE formula
a = Q + R (policyholder funds R) TR = I / a + R / Q * (I / a + U / R)
109
What are the assumptions of the CAPM and BS models?
financial markets are complete, competitive, perfect, and arbitrage-free with pricing determined in general equilibrium competitive: many sellers and buyers and undifferentiated products perfect: no information or transaction costs, no bid-ask spread, ability to borrow or lend at the risk-free rate, no short-sale restrictions, no taxes complete: in a complete market there exist enough securities to replicate any set of future period cash flows by trading (replicating portfolio)
110
What is an arrow-Debreu security?
Pays 1 in a single future state w and 0 in all othe rstates any security can be built from a set of arrow-debreu securities
111
Whats the difference between a fundamental and a redundant security?
redundant: securities that can be determined from the value of other securities (options) non-redundant: fundamental (companys common stock)
112
Arbitrage
opportunity for gain with no possible loss No arbitrage implies pricing operator p is linear p(aX + bY) = ap(X) + bp(Y) securites X,Y constants a,b implies no bid-ask spread
113
What does general equilibrium mean?
the market clears and supply equals demand no actor has incentive to trade to improve their position and all agree products are fairly priced
114
What does the fundamental theorem of asset pricing say?
The following are equivalent: (1) Absence of arbitrage (2) existence of an optimal demand for some agent who prefers more to less (3) existence of positive linear pricing rule
115
What are the two broad classes of general equilibrium models?
(1) Classical: price fundamental securites like stocks or insurance policies; price based on supply and demand and rely on diversification and pooling (CAPM) (2) Derivative: price redundant securities like stock options, rely on replicating portfolios, dont rely on diversification or pooling (Black-Scholes)
116
What does the myers-cohn premium condition state?
A premium is fair if whenever a policy is issued the resulting equity value equals the equity invested in support of that policy if not satisified, not in equilibrium since investors have an incentive to write more or less insurance fair iff P = D (market value of liability, accounting liability + margin) company is indifferent as to whether a policy is written
117
What are three important principles of DCF analysis?
(1) Value additivity: each policy evaluated stand-alone (prospective business separate from reserves) (2) Accounting is relevant only to the extent it impacts cash flows (3) Insurance is prone to double-counting and a good way to avoid it is to pick either the insured's or the insurers perspective
118
DCF ROE Formula
R = risk free rate + L / Q * (Rf - RL) / (1 + RL) * (1 - tax rate)
119
CAPM formula for insurance
Rq = -k * rfr + beta_l * (market return - rfr) k is funds generating coefficient (unit of premium generates more than one unit of assets due to loss reserves) a = kP + Q beta_l: correlation of underwriting returns with market returns
120
IRR Model Premium
P = L / (1 + rf) + phi*D * (tau * rf + (rs - rf)) / (1+rf)(1 - tau) phi = constant capital to reserves ratio D = market value of liabilities tau = tax rate rf = risk free rate rs = cost of capital
121
portfolio CCOC pricing
simplified DCF model with no taxes Premium = loss cost + cost of capital cost of capital = target ROE x capital constant coc is realistic if all capital is common equity usually use economic capital (aka risk capital) one year VaR P(a) = (E[X] + i*a) / (1 + i) official: P_a(X) = (E[X ^ a(X)] + i*a(X)) / (1+i) = v*E[X ^ a(X)] + delta * a(X) v = 1/(1+i) risk discount factor delta = i / (1+i) risk discount rate aka P(a) = v TVaR(0)(X^a) + delta * TVaR(1)(X^a) TVaR(0) = mean TVaR(1) = maximum risk neutral v percent of time, expect the worst delta percent
122
What are three key kinds of frictional costs?
(1) Agency and informational costs: managers behave opportunistically, or insurers fail to control adverse selection (2) Double taxation of investment returns (3) regulation that allows insurer assets to be seized or temporarily controlled by a regulator if it fails minimum capital standards, and limit dividends frictional costs vary with geography and corporate legal form and level of capitalization
123
What is the insurance analog of an Arrow-Debreu security?
A bernoulli layer, where 1 is paid if X breaches the attachment point a.
124
What is the total pricing problem?
How do we split the asset funding between policyholder premium and investor capital
125
total residual value formula
f(a) = a - s(a) aka assets - losses (shared liability) insureds and investors have this shared liability to fund the assets in excess of the expected loss
126
average return formula
i(a) = expected margin / investment M(A) / Q(A) [P(A) - S(A)] / [a - P(A)]
127
formulas for the risk discount rate and the risk discount factor
delta(a) = M(A) / [a - S(A)] v(a) = Q(A) / [a - S(A)]
128
dual functions equivalence
g(s) = 1 - h(1 - s) g(s) + h(1-s) = 1 s = probability of insured loss 1 - s = probability of investor profit P(a) = g(S(a)) Q(a) = h(F(a))
129
What are the three properties of a distortion function?
function g: [0,1] => [0,1] (1) g(0) = 0, g(1) = 1 (2) g is increasing (3) g(s) >= s for all s
130
What does it mean for a function to be concave vs convex?
Concave functions are umbrella shaped if we draw a line between two points, the curve lies above g(ws1 + (1-w)s2) >= wg(s1) + (1-w)g(s2) If g is concave then -g is convex flip the inequality if we draw a line between two points, the curve lies below
131
What are some useful properties of a concave distortion function g?
(1) g is continuous everywhere except maybe at s = 0 (2) g is differentiable everywhere except at most countably infinite points (kinks) (3) g'(s) >= 0 where g' exists (4) left and right-hand derivatives of g exist everywhere on (0,1) (5) g is second-order differentiable almost everywhere (6) g is concave, thus g''(s) <= 0 where g''(s) exists (7) if g is differentiable then it is concave iff g' is decreasing
132
weighted average of VaRs SRM formula
pg(X) = integral(0 to 1) q(p) * spectral weight function(p) dp spectral weight function = g'(1-p) >= 0 q(p) = VaRp(X)
133
When is a pg translation invariant?
iif g(1) - g(0) = 1 if g is not continuous then g(1) = 1
134
What are the 6 ways to represent an SRM?
(1) P is coherent, comonotonic additive, and law invariant (2) P equals a spectral risk measure pg for a concave distortion function g (3) P(X) = g(0+) * sup(X) + integral(0 to 1) VaRp(X)phi(p) dp weighted average of VaRs (4) P(X) = g(0+) * sup(X) + integral(0 to 1) TVaRp(X)*(1-p)*phi'(dp) + sum(j) TVaRpj (X)(1-pj)Delta(j) (5) πœŒπ‘”(𝑋) = sup{𝖀[𝑋𝑍] ∣ 𝑍 β‰₯ 0,𝖀[𝑍] = 1,βˆ«π‘žπ‘(1 βˆ’π‘‘)𝑑𝑑 ≀ 𝑔(𝑠) for all 𝑠 ∈ (0,1)} (6) πœŒπ‘”(𝑋) = sup{𝖀𝖰[𝑋] ∣ 𝖰(𝐴) ≀ 𝑔(𝖯(𝐴)) for all events 𝐴}.
135
What is the process for simulating from a distortion function?
(1) Simulate uniform random variables ui (2) transform to gi = inverse(g) (ui) (3) apply inversion method to gi to simulate s inverse (gi) e.g. g(s) = s^ b | b < 1 gi = ui ^ (1/b) b = 0.5, u = 0.1 transformed to 0.1^2 = 0.01 90th percentile to 99th
136
What are the 7 steps in evaluating an srm on a discrete random variable?
(1) Pad the input by adding a zero outcome with probability zero if it doesnt exist already (2) sort the outcome ascending (3) group by xj and sum the corresponding pj (all xj need to be distinct) (4) decumulate probabilities to get S(X) (5) distort the survival function g(S(X)) (6) difference g(Sj) to compute risk adjusted probabilities (7) sumproduct to get pg(X) = sum Xj * delta g(Sj)
137
what is the bi-TVaR SRM?
weighted average of 2 TVaRs 0 <= p0 <= p1 <= 1 and 0<=w<=1 biTVaR = (1-w)TVaR(p0) + wTVaR(p1) when a TVaR equals this, we call it the bi-TVaR associated with p* TVaR
138
whats the VaR weight function for a bi-TVaR SRM?
g'(s) = (1-w) / (1 - p0) * 1[0, 1 - p0)(s) + w/(1-p1) * 1[0, 1 - p1)(s)
139
When does the bi-TVaR equal the CCOC distortion function?
when p0 = 0 and p1 = 1
140
what is the piecewise linear distortion?
an empirical distortion defined as the concave envelope of a set of points {(𝑠𝑗,𝑔𝑗)} βˆͺ {(0,0),(1,1)}, where all 𝑠𝑗,𝑔𝑗 ∈ [0,1]. If the smallest 𝑠� is greater than zero the distortion function is continuous with finite slope at 𝑠 = 0. If there is a(𝑠𝑗 = 0,𝑔𝑗 > 0)itistreatedasalimitfromtheright.Ifthelargest𝑠𝑗 < 1withcorresponding 𝑔𝑗 < 1thedistortion has slope 0 < 𝑔′ ≀ 1 at 𝑠 = 1; otherwise it has slope 0.
141
Describe the proportional hazard
g(s) = s^a for 0
142
Describe the dual moment transform
g(s) = 1 - (1-s)^m m >= 1 larger m = greater risk aversion interpretation of applying powers to probabilities and not outcomes pg(X) = E[max(x1, ... xm)] aka MAXVAR
143
Describe the wang transform
g(s) = norm.dist(norm.dist.inv(s) + lambda) lambda > 0 larger lambda = greater risk aversion operates on normal variables like an esscher transform alters the mean, doesnt touch the sd
144
How can an actuary justify the use of a pricing distortion function?
at a minimum, must be defensible should be simple, transparent, evidently fair, objective, data-based and precedented four principal concerns of audience: 1. What is it; how does it work? 2. Why is this the best? 3. Who else uses it? 4. What can it do for me?
145
What is the apparent pricing paradox?
for any distortion function theres a point such that for all x lower than it g'(s(x)) <= 1 and all above g'(s(x)) > 1 meaning left-tail probs decrease and right-tail probs increase say an insurance policy pays out one dollar if below p and nothing if above p (clearly using the distortion the policy would be priced below E[X]) TVaR distortion is an extreme example of this because all probs below the threshold are 0.
146
What is the stand-alone resolution for the apparent pricing paradox?
highlights SRM don't define objective states and state prices (they are relative to risk being priced) basically just switch the order of events to make it make sense.
147
What is the portfolio resolution for the apparent pricing paradox?
we consider fair price for V as part of portfolio X a fixed premium direct insurance policy is a variable premium ceded reinsurance policy by swapping premium and loss paying for reinsurance is the same as writing a direct policy at a loss (ceded prem > ceded loss) thus policy V makes a reasonable reinsurance contract (ceded recovery in all states but only requires ceded premium in good states)
148
What is the fundamental equation underlying CCOC allocation?
Pi = li + delta(i) *(ai - li) unit premium = unit losses + unit discount rate * unit shared liability fixes the return, allocates assets => determines premium SRMs fix the return by layer and allocate premium to determine assets
149
What are two approaches to risk-adjust the target return and fix the capital?
risk-adjusted return on capital (RAROC): return varies with risk return on risk-adjusted capital (RORAC): return is constant when capital reflects risk
150
Why does allocation of capital only matter to the extent that it influences the insurers decisions?
this is because all units have access to the entire insurers capital when needed
151
Definition of an allocation of risk measure p
Given a functional p and a finite sum of RVs, an attribution of p is a functional taking the vector Xi to a vector of real numbers ai amount ai is the attribution of P(X) to unit i as part of X a(Xi: X) if sum of a = p(x) the attribution is additive and is called an allocation of p
152
What are three desirable properties of an allocation?
(1) Should work at any granularity (2) should be decomposable: the allocation to a sum of random variables equals the sum of their allocations (3) it should be computed using a single, consistent formula
153
Endogenous vs exogenous allocations
Endogenous: same risk measure is used to determine the total AND allocate it Exogenous: when the amount is stipulated by an external risk measure and allocated using an auxiliary measure (regulator or rating agency determines the capital)
154
Expected value allocation
ai = a(x) * E[Xi] / E[X] exogenous allocation using expected value as the auxiliary measure
155
Proportional allocation
ai = a(x) * a(xi) / sum a(xi) each unit evaluated on stand-alone basis and total is pro-rated to a(X) not influenced by dependence between Xi
156
Haircut allocation
exogenous version of the proportional allocation ai = a(x) * p(Xi) / sum p(Xi) not influenced by dependence between Xi
157
Equal risk allocation
endogenous solves Sum a(Xi, p*) = a(X) for p* ai = a(Xi, p*) when p = VaR each unit has the same probability of default replacing actual dependence structure with comonotonic (worst-case scenario) dependence
158
Merton-perold allocation
allocates to each unit the capital that is reducing by removing that unit from the portfolio not additive (usually less than total)
159
Marginal business euler gradient allocation
based on marginal change in capital given marginal change in unit i written endogenous allocation equals directional derivative of a at X in direction of unit i only suitable for performance measurement as growing lines with higher return to capital ALWAYS improves average return doesnt account for possibility change in portfolio => change in coc
160
What do the terms atomic and exact and core refer to in game theory?
Atomic: each player is either 100% in or out Fractional or fuzzy otherwise Exact: a game with a continuum of players Core: the set of allocations that keeps everyone happy (satisfies the no-undercut property)
161
Shapley allocation formula
ci = sum(all sets dont include i) |S|! * (n - |S| - 1)! / n ! c(S U {i}) - c(S)
162
What desirable properties does the shapley value have?
(1) its additive (in game theory its "efficient") (2) its symmetric, if two units i and j increase the cost of every S that contains neither i and j by the same amount they have the same cost (3) decomposable (linear) (4) homogeneous if c is (5) if c is subadditive no undercut property is met (6) allocates no capital to a constant risk (called null player)
163
Whats the major downside to the shapley allocation?
to allocate to n unit you need to compute 2^n marginal impacts if a unit is subdivided, then the allocations assigned to OTHER units changes typically, it is not decomposable
164
What is the aumann-shapley allocation?
generalized the shapley by allowing fractional participation and the euler allocation by dropping the positive homogeneous assumption a i = integral(0 to 1) partial derivative a with respect to xi (tx) dt computes average incremental capital as portfolio grows from zero, uniformly across units unique allocation satisfying linearity, decomposable, and either continuity or non-negativity when a is nondecreasing
165
comeasure allocations
p(X) = E[h(X) L(X)] h is an additive function co-measure E[h(Xi) L(X)] L is riskiness leverage function covariance = k 𝖀[(𝑋𝑖 βˆ’ 𝖀𝑋𝑖)(𝑋 βˆ’ 𝖀𝑋)] coTVaR average xi when X is greater than 1-p var coVaR E[xi | X = xp] Esscher: 𝖀[𝑋𝑖 π‘’π‘˜π‘‹]βˆ• 𝖀[π‘’π‘˜π‘‹].
166
kalkbrenner sd allocation
solve VaRp(X) = E[X] + pi(x) SD(X) for constant pi(x) and use the scaled covariance allocation E[xi] + pi(x) cov(xi, x) /sd(x) exogenous method (when risk measure for total capital is hard to allocate)
167
How should one select an allocation method?
an allocation should be fair (stakeholders consider the allocation reflective of reality and not unduly influenced by factors not germane to the problem intended to be solved) dont have too much focus on the tail vs the body when not rational can remedy this via a haircut allocation with a body-focused risk measure such as TVaR (0.75) be cognizant of professional actuarial standards recognize the scope of the larger task communication and persuasion sensitivity to stakeholder concerns simplicity, transparency, fairness, objectivity, and precedence
168
what payments are made to unit i above and below the asset level a being breached?
Xi | X <= a Xi * (a/X) | X > a
169
How is ex post equal priority different from ex ante equal priority?
ex post: shares in default are determined after claims are known ex ante: shares are set at the beginning of the period based on expected loss (not used in practice since it can result in payment in default greater than actual loss)
170
Whats a major downside of CCOC allocations?
Heavily biased towards tail risk SRMs can remedy this in reality, tail-risk is funded through cat bonds which are much cheaper
171
How many natural allocation sets will there be?
if multiple ties with k1, k2,.... equal rows there will be (k1!)*(k2!) .... alternatives
172
Formula for the Epanechnikov kernel (parabolic kernel)
K(u) = (1 - u^2) +
173
Layer margin by unit formula
M(i,j) = Beta(i,j)*g(Sj)) - a(i,j)*S(j) * [layer length] density * length [premium density - expected loss density] * layer length
174
Layer capital density formula
M(i,j) / M(j) * Q(j) layer margin / overall cost of capital