Module 3 Flashcards
(18 cards)
Standard of Review
- The legal test used by an appellate or reviewing court to assess the correctness or reasonableness of a lower court or tribunal’s decision. It determines how much deference the higher court gives.
Correctness
- A non-deferential standard of review. The reviewing court can substitute its own opinion if it disagrees. Used when there is a legal question requiring a single right answer (e.g., constitutional interpretation).
Palpable and Overriding
- A highly deferential standard for reviewing factual findings. The error must be obvious and significant enough to affect the outcome. Used mostly in appeals of trial-level decisions.
- “Palpable” = the mistake is obvious.
“Overriding” = it matters enough to change the outcome.
High Deference
- The reviewing body gives great weight to the original decision. Applied when the original decision-maker has expertise or the law involves discretionary judgment.
- Means the reviewing court shows a lot of respect and trust in the original decision-maker.
Even if the court would’ve decided differently, it says:
Low Deference
- The reviewing body is less restrained and more willing to intervene. Used when the original decision involves important legal questions or lacks specialized expertise.
- Means the court is more willing to step in and change the decision.
It might think the issue is too important, too clear-cut, or outside the other body’s expertise.
Alternative Dispute Resolution
Negotiation
- Just the parties involved — no third party
- Informal and private
- Goal: reach a mutual agreement
- Can happen with or without lawyers
Mediation
- A neutral third party (mediator) helps the two sides talk and try to find a solution
- The mediator does not make decisions, just guides discussion
- Any outcome is voluntary and non-binding unless written into an agreement
Arbitration
- A neutral third party (arbitrator) listens to both sides and makes a binding decision
- More like a private court
- Can be faster and more flexible than a real trial
Summary Procedure
A simplified court process for handling small or straightforward cases quickly and cheaply.
Often used in small claims courts or minor civil disputes.
Discontinuance
- When a party formally ends their case or claim, either partially or entirely.
- Can happen before or during proceedings.
- Often done when a settlement is reached or continuing is pointless.
Standard of proof
- How convincing the evidence must be for a party to win:
- Criminal: Beyond a reasonable doubt
- Civil: Balance of probabilities (more likely than not)
Balance of Probabilities
- The standard of proof in most civil cases.
- Means that a party’s version of events is more likely true than not true (just over 50%).
Remedy
What a court orders to fix a wrong or enforce a right.
Types:
- Damages (money)
- Injunctions (stop/start doing something)
- Declarations (clarifying legal rights)
Enforcement Process
- Legal steps taken to make someone obey a judgment — like collecting money owed or transferring property.
- May involve garnishment, seizures, or sheriffs/civil enforcement agencies
Abandonment
- When a person gives up a legal claim, right, or property.
- Can also mean withdrawing from a case or failing to pursue a right, often resulting in loss of it.
Civil Enforcement Agency
- Authorized body (like sheriffs) that carries out court orders — e.g., seizing assets, evicting tenants, enforcing debts.
Garnishment
- A way for a creditor to collect money from a debtor by taking it from wages or a bank account, based on a court judgment.
- redirecting any payment to the judgement creditor
Judgement Proof
- A person who owes money but has no seizable assets or income.
- Even with a court order, creditors can’t collect — the judgment is unenforceable (at least for now).
Declaratory
- A court ruling that declares a legal relationship, right, or obligation without requiring action or awarding money.
Used to get clarity — like confirming someone owns land or interpreting a contract.
Injunction
A court order requiring a person to do something or stop doing something.