Mutation Detection Flashcards
How many rare diseases have been described, and how many people do they affect in the UK?
Approximately 7,000 rare diseases have been described, affecting about 1 in 17 of the UK population (approximately 3.5 million individuals
How many rare diseases are caused by highly penetrant single nucleotide variants (SNV), small indels, or CNVs?
5000
Relies on the identification of a disease causing germline variant
What is the primary challenge in interpreting whole exome and whole genome sequencing for inherited diseases?
Whittling down a list of candidate variants to identify the disease-causing one(s).
What guidelines are used for germline variant interpretation?
In 2015, the American College of Medical Genetics (ACMG) published guidelines to a series of criteria in Mendelian disorders.
In 2016, adopted by the Association for Clinical Genomic Science (ACGS): ACGS Best Practice Guidelines for Variant Classification in Rare Disease
What evidence is used to classify germline variants using ACGS?
Collate evidence from population data, computational data, functional data, segregation data, literature evidence, de novo data
Many software packages to aid interpretation (for example, Alamut, Congenica
What classification system does ACGS use?
ACMG/ACGS guidelines use a five-class system:
5: Pathogenic >99% probability of a variant being disease-causing
4: Likely pathogenic >90%
3: Uncertain significance
2: Likely benign <10%
1: Benign <0.1%
Each evidence relates to a criterion and is worth a specific number of points. evidence points for pathogenicity (Very Strong= 8, Strong= 4, Moderate= 2, Supporting= 1) or benignity (Strong= -4, Moderate= -2, Supporting= -1). Evidence point thresholds for the 5 classes are: ≥10 (Pathogenic), 6-9 (Likely Pathogenic), -1 to -5 (Likely Benign), ≤-6 (Benign)
What other germline interpretation guidelines are used?
Cancer specific: CanVig- adapts ACGS to be suitable for cancer predisposition genes
Disease specific e.g. BRCA, Lynch
What somatic variant interpretation guidelines are used?
Association for Molecular Pathology (AMP) Guidelines (Li et al 2017)
S-VIG also been developed but often not fully used in routine practice
What are the AMP guidelines?
4 tier system based on clinical actionability
Uses:
Population data e.g gnomAD
Functional data
Predictive data
Cancer hotspots e.g. cancer databases COSMIC, mycancergenome etc
Drug approval guidelines: NICE, CDF, NCCN
How does AMP guidelines classify variants?
Tier I, variants of strong clinical significance - made up of variants with level A & B evidence (clinically actionable)
Tier II, variants of potential clinical significance- made up of variants with level C &D evidence (clinically actionable)
Tier III, variants of unknown significance- evidence may be conflicting or absent- (VUS)
Tier IV, benign or likely benign variants- there is evidence a variant does not have any actionability
What is meant by a driver mutation?
Confer growth advantage on the cells carrying them and have been positively selected during the evolution of the cancer. Non-recurrent variants are unlikely to be drivers otherwise they would more than likely been seen previously
What is different about SVIG and AMP guidelines?
SVIG aims to help standardise somatic VI and bring in line with germline ACGS guidelines
Uses evidence based points system to help determine oncogenicity of result
Has a list of known hotspot variants that are oncogenic
Can only be used on SNVs, not suitable for structural or copy number variants
What variant nomenclature is used?
Human genome variation society (HGVS)
- Clinical reports should include sequence reference) to ensure unambiguous naming of the variant at the DNA level as well as provide coding and protein nomenclature
(e.g., “c.” for coding DNA sequence, “p.” for protein,
What are external bioinformatic databases?
External Bioinformatic Databases (DBs) can be described as databases which store biological data information. The data included in the databases/resources can be split into the main following areas:
- genome and sequence data (sequence alignment, variant databases, phylogenetic and splicing predictions)
- transcriptomics data (e.g. full length cDNAs or mRNAs),
- proteomics data (e.g. protein databases, protein structure, family and domain classification)
- other specialised databases (e.g. cancer and methylation databases).
What are primary and secondary databases?
Primary databases consist of experimentally derived data (e.g. nucleotide and protein sequences).
Secondary databases consist of data produced from the analysis of primary data. Secondary databases often include data from a combination of other databases (both primary and secondary databases) and other (e.g. literature).
Give some examples of genomic databases?
Primary
- EMBL (European Bioinformatics institute) (Europe)
- GenBank (National Centre for Biotechnology Information) (USA)
Secondary
OMIM (Online Mendelian Inheritance in Man)
RefSeq
Decipher
ClinVar
The cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA)
Cosmic
ClinGen
What is germline conversion rate?
Number of pathogenic variants of true germline origin× 100/total number of tumour-detected pathogenic variants
What are Cancer Susceptibility Genes?
A term used to describe a gene that may increase a person’s risk of developing some types of cancer if it has certain mutations.
When should variants identified in tumour be investigated for germline significance?
Increased tumour testing increase in detection of secondary/incidental findings – some of which are germline in origin but not feasible to carry out paired tumour/germline on all samples to confirm
ESMO Guidelines for Germline-focussed analysis of tumour-only sequencing
What genes should always be followed up for germline analysis after tumour testing?
ESMO guidelines identified 7 most actioonable genes which hava a high germline conversion factor: BRCA1/BRCA2/MLH1/MSH2/MSH6/PALB2/RET
What do the ESMO guidelines suggest about germline testing of tumour variants?
Four potential strategies for clinical labs. Intermediate/conservative suggested for UK/Europe
Permissive: germline follow-up for all 40 genes in all tumour types.
Intermediate-permissive: germline follow-up for all 23 MA-CSGs/HA-CSGs in all tumour types but germline follow-up only in ‘associated’ tumour types for 17 SA-CSGs.
Intermediate-conservative: germline follow-up in all tumour types for the 7 most actionable (MA-CSGs) but germline follow-up only in ‘associated’ tumour types for the other 33 HA-CSGs/SA-CSGs (highly actionable/standard actionable)
Conservative: germline follow-up only in ‘associated’ tumour types for all 40 genes.
What is an incidental finding?
defined incidental findings as “results that are not related to the indication for ordering the sequencing but that may nonetheless be of medical value or utility
Now referred to as secondary findings as incidental gives a sense of insignificance
Off target finding
What guidelines are used to determine when secondary/incidental findings be reported?
The ACMG published a minimum list of 59 genes to be reported as incidental or secondary findings
The ACMG subsequently established the Secondary Findings Maintenance Working Group to develop a process for curating and updating the list over time
What is required for individuals undergoing clinical genomic sequencing regarding secondary findings?
Informed consent and an option to opt-out of receiving secondary findings.