Phytoestrogens Flashcards
What are phytoestrogens?
- Type of phytochemical
- Non-steroidal plant compound that is able to exert estrogenic effects
- Similar in structure to endogenous (eg. estradiol) and synthetic estrogens
What are the major classes of phytoestrogens?
- Isoflavones
- Received the most attention
- Found in highest concentrations in SOYBEANS, legumes, and clover
- Also a type of flavonoid (has the 3 ring structure) - Lignans
- Coumestans
What are the forms of isoflavones found in soy? Which form is absorbable?
- Glycoside forms: found in this form in the plant for polarity and storage, need to get rid of carb moiety to absorb it
- Genistin
- Daidzin
- Glycitin - Aglycone forms: fermented foods contain some
- Genistein
- Daidzein
- Glycitein
What isoflavones are found in clover?
- Formonoetin (precursor to daidzein)
- Biochanin A (precursor to genistein)
Discuss isoflavone intakes around the world, and in regards to quantifying it.
- Asian intakes are much higher (decreasing due to Westernization)
- Need to standardize whether “isoflavone intake” refers to glycoside or aglycone
- Glycosides weigh heavier due to carb moiety ⟶ overestimate isoflavone intake
- Has own completed database (USDA and Iowa State University joint effort)
- Increases accuracy of intake estimates from dietary assessments
- Relates intake to disease risk by comparing intakes to biomarker of disease
How are isoflavones absorbed?
- Precursors are converted to isoflavones in the intestine (before absorption)
- Intestinal bacteria produce enzymes that convert glycosides to aglycones
- Therefore, if doing a study, consider ANTIBIOTICS (introduce variability in soy bioavailability) and PROBIOTICS
- Aglycones can be absorbed or further metabolized to metabolites (which are then absorbed)
- Genistein ⟶ p-ethyl phenol (metabolites)
- Daidzein ⟶ equol + ODMA (metabolites)
What is equol and its effects? What are the implications?
- Metabolite of daidzein
- Only 30-40% of people produce/excrete equol
1) Most potent of isoflavones; binds to estrogen receptor with higher affinity
2) Longer half life; stays in circulation longer
3) Inversely associated with breast cancer risk
Distinguishing people from producers to non-producers can explain variance in reported data on health benefits of soy
What does historical data say about isoflavones and hormonal effects?
Clover Disease ⟶ fertility problems in sheep in Australia due to high intake of clover (formononetin); all sheep produce equol
Captive cheetahs fed high amounts of genistin and daidzin; linked to liver disease
California quails had infertility (protective mechanism) in the dry months due to higher phytoestrogen content of their forage
What do human studies say about isoflavones and hormonal effects?
- No reports of ferility problems associated with isoflavones
- Reports of [anti-]hormonal effects; magnitude not shown to interfere with fertility but related to risk of hormone-dependent diseases
- One study concluded isoflavones do NOT have feminizing effects on men at high levels
How does isoflavone exert its hormonal effects?
- Isoflavones can bind to estrogen receptor due to structural similarities
- Potency is 1/1000 the potency of endogenous estrogen (estradiol)
- Quantity in blood is 1000x more (nano or low micro compared to pico) so still biologically relevant
- Exerts estrogenic OR anti-estrogenic effects, depending on concentration of endogenous estrogen
What is the net estrogen effect in premenopausal women? Why?
High endogenous estrogens:
- Isoflavones compete with endogenous estrogens for estrogen receptor
- Because isoflavones are weaker than estrogen ⟶ net anti-estrogenic effect
What is the net estrogen effect in postmenopausal women not on HRT? Why?
Low endogenous estrogens:
- Isoflavones have no competition for estrogen receptor (no ovarian estrogen production)
- Net estrogenic effect
What are the 5 areas of health effects that isoflavones are being researched for?
- Cancer
- Hormone-dependent (breast, prostate) - CVD
- Estrogen is protective for the heart - Osteoporosis
- Menopausal symptoms
- Cognitive function
Discuss the evidence and research surrounding isoflavones and breast cancer.
1) Beyond blood and urine, isoflavones are bioavailable and can reach the breast tissue
- Bioavailability must be established before studies can be done
2) Reduction of breast cancer risk due to anti-estrogenic effect
- Epidemiological studies show inverse relationship between risk and dietary intake, urinary excretion, and blood concentrations of isoflavones
- Asian populations have lower rates of hormone-dependent cancers
What is the age/timing of exposure hypothesis? Discuss the relevant study and its implication.
- AGE/TIMING OF EXPOSURE is hypothesis that may explain inconsistencies among isoflavone and cancer studies done in adults:
- Many early life events that contribute toward breast cancer risk
- Rat study evaluated effect of genistein consumption on the number of tumours following DMBA (chemical) induced breast cancer
- Found that rats who were exposed to genistein pre-puberty AND adulthood had lowest numbers of tumours
- Second best was rats who were exposed during prepuberty only
- Being exposed in adulthood or prenatally was the same as no exposure
- Implies that interventions done in adulthood may have no effect