Poli 341: Foreign Policy in the Middle East Flashcards
(361 cards)
Studying the Middle East
What are the key two issues when studying the Middle East?
1) Various Middle Eastern issues are highly contentions aka they cause arguments
2) Is it appropriate to take an open political stance, aka Western instituions continously intervene in the Middle East and unbaised approach is impossible due to Western policies.
Studying the Middle East
What is the ethical issue of researching the Middle East?
1) Need to ensure that the issue or occurence is accurately depicted, as an inaccruate portrayal has significant consequences.
2) Ethical social science means trying to inform policy decisions with careful research.
Studying the Middle East
In what sense has studying the Middle East been unethical?
- The contracting for think tanks, the intelligence and the military. Aka academics are paid better to reinforce Western hegemony.
- Western scholars when interacting with local experts, activists and informants run the risk of putting these people in danger due to repressive govenrments.
Studying the Middle East
What are the two main portrayals of Islam in the West?
Said “Islam Through Western Eyes”(1980)
1) Westerners use the brutality of radical Islamist to make Islam appear as the violent “other”
or
2) Westerners objectify Islam by highlighting Islams contirbution to civilization, developemnt and democratic niceness.
Studying the Middle East
What is the common theme between the two Western portrayls of Islam?
- Both objectifiy Islam but one is in a negtaive way and in a positive way
- Islam is degraded to a mere object of study and not a subjective body.
Said “Islam Through Western Eyes”(1980)
Studying the Middle East
In what sense are the two protrayals of Islam two sides of the same coin?
Said “Islam Through Western Eyes”(1980)
- They rely on each other to exist.
- Since the Middle Ages, the West has always regarded Islam through the lens of the “passions, prejudice and political interests”
Studying the Middle East
What is Orientalism?
Said “Islam Through Western Eyes”(1980)
- It is an imaginative geogrphy that divides the world into two unequal parts:
1) The Civilized West
2) The large exotic, uncivilized other.
Studying the Middle East
What does Said argue in his book “Orientalism”?
- He argues that it is impossible that a “large ideologiclaly freightened generalization could cover all the rich and diverse partiuclarly of Islamic life”
Said “Orientalism”
Studying the Middle East
What is the oriental other according to Said?
Said “Orientalism”
- The Orient has a larger territory and population, and is therefore capable of greater power than the West.
- ## The Western colonial imaginary has situated Islam within the Oriental Other, objectifying it while also fearing it as a threat to Christianity.
Studying the Middle East
What is a key element of the oriental objectification?
Said “Orientalism”
- It has to do with threat, and how this threat influences various academic fields.
Studying the Middle East
How did 19th century colonialism impact the Middle East?
- France and England demarcated their occupations of the Islamic East which resulted in the Orient undergoing a significant technical modernization and development.
- Scholarship became much more elaborate and more funded because the Orient began interacting with Western project of imperial conquest.
Studying the Middle East
How did Napoleon contribute to current Western scholarship on the Middle East?
- During his 1798 conquest of Egypt, Napoleon brought with him “a sophisiticated group of scientists”
- He did not want to merely conquer the Middle East but wanted to understand them using methodology.
Studying the Middle East
What is meant by the Middle East has been objectified?
- The Middle East due to colonialism became familiar, accessible and representable, it could be seen, studied and managed.
- And seeing them and studying them accurately is contigent on the goal of the scholar.
Studying the Middle East
Why was France’s colonization of Algeria a key turning point for obectification?
- Hundreds of thousands Frence people settled in Algeria (overseas France) and this reuslted in the systematization of knowledge to faciliate and perfect political control.
- Scholarship was used to understand religion, custsoms, language patetrns, geography, agornomy and economic functions.
Studying the Middle East
How is scholarly knowledge of power?
- Positivism and science can play an optimisticrolein our lives, and research findings according to positivism is objective “scientific fact”
- Knowledge is not relative but it is absolute according to positivism.
Studying the Middle East
What role does bias play when studying the Middle East?
- It plays an enormous role in shaping the findings.
Studying the Middle East
What is the benthamite panopticon?
- Proposed by Jeremy Bentham, it is a structure that allowed for the authority to see what the subjects are doing at all times.
- There is this idea that as we assemble knowledge that we can have a total view of these other (Oriental) peoplesso that no aspect of their lives is hidden, unseen, or unintelligible.
- This is done for the sake of the empire, exerting imperial control.
Studying the Middle East
What is geo-politics of knowledge?
Walter Mignolo
- In the colonial eyes, the First World possesses knowledge while the Third World possesses culture.
- The Third World however, is only suitable for builiding expertise by the First World.
- There is an intersection between colonization and knowledge production.
Studying the Middle East
What is epistemic silences?
- Dynamic between the knower and the known
Studying the Middle East
What is the myth of the detached observer?
Walter Mignolo
- It is the claim to have objective knowledge is completely undermined by wealthy industrialized countries.
- It is the idea that neutral and objective seekers simultaneously control the riles and put themselves in a place of priviledged when evaluating and dictating.
Studying the Middle East
How is western scholarly research baised to Islam?
- Just because you have access to various advances such as sociology and anthropology does not mean that you are unbaise.
- People with advanced qualitification are not above having these baises in fact they introduced and perpetuates these baises within their writings and scholar.
Studying the Middle East
In what sense are Western scholars of the Orient concealed?
- They conceal their feelings about Islam by using language and terms which are not understood, therefore making the jargon appear objective.
- They portray Islam and the Middle East inaccurately, similarly to the way information was constucted during colonization.
Studying the Middle East
How have Western “experts” domesticated the Middle East?
- The US has become a superpower, it found key interest in the Middle East and developed a “huge apparatus of university, government and business experts” who “study Islam and the Middle East” and have “domesticated” it for the US audience.
- Muslims and Arabs viewed as either oil-suppliers or potential terrorists
- This phenomenon has exploded post 9/11 especially since the US occupation of Iraq.
- This dominance is not reciprocal (except maybe for ultra-rich Gulf elites)
Studying the Middle East
What is the counterinsurgency theory and practice?
Jauregui, 2010
- After the US invasions of Afghanistan (2001) and Iraq (2003), “segments in the United States military have taken a new interest in culture and ethnography”
- Gain knowledge of the cultural ‘terrain’
- Social sciences scholars have advised governments on military operations in the Middle East and have used the spaces provided by military occupations to study those areas.