Primary sources. Flashcards
(46 cards)
What sources can be primary, secondary, or tertiary.
Popular and Scholarly sources.
What is a Primary Source?
Primary sources are texts that arise directly from a particular event or time period. can be popular (if published in newspapers, magazines or websites for the general public) or academic (if written by scholars and published in scholarly journals).
What type of research has not yet been critiqued, interpreted or analyzed by a second (or third, etc) party.
Primary research
Examples of primary sources:
journals, diaries
blog posts
a speech
data from surveys or polls
scholarly journal articles in which the author(s) discuss the methods and results from their own original research/experiments
photos, videos, sound recordings
interviews or transcripts
poems, paintings, sculptures, songs or other works of art
government documents (such as reports of legislative sessions, laws or court decisions, financial or economic reports, and more)
Newspaper and Magazine articles that report directly on current events (although these can also be considered Secondary)
Investigative journalism (sometimes considered Secondary as well)
What is a Secondary Source?
Secondary sources summarize, interpret, critique, analyze, or offer commentary on primary sources. The author of a secondary source may be speaking on information from someone else’s research or offering an interpretation or opinion on current events. Thus, the secondary source is one step away from that original, primary research
Secondary sources can be popular (if published in newspapers, magazines or websites for the general public) or academic (if written by scholars and published in scholarly journals).
Examples of secondary sources:
book, movie or art reviews
summaries of the findings from other people’s research
interpretations or analyses of primary source materials or other people’s research
histories or biographies
political commentary
Newspaper and Magazine articles that mainly synthesize others’ research or primary materials (remember, newspaper and magazine articles can also be considered primary, depending on the content)
What is a Tertiary Source?
Tertiary sources are syntheses of primary and secondary sources. The person/people who compose a tertiary text are summarizing, others’ work.
sometimes do not list an author. Can be hard to catagorize something as specifally tertiary. s
trive to only use tertiary sources to find more academic sources, Tertiary sources can be popular or academic depending on the content and publisher.
Examples of tertiary sources include:
encyclopedias fact books dictionaries guides handbooks Wikipedia
Thinking about Primary, Secondary and Tertiary Sources and your Research Strategy
What kinds of primary sources would be useful for your research project? Why? Where will you find them? Are you more interested in popular primary sources or scholarly primary sources — and why? Same for secondary and tertiary.
What is a Popular Source?
Popular does not equate to well liked. Popular sources are articles that are written for a general audience. (sometimes free, sometimes paid prescription.)
How should you approach Popular sources?
We should not be tempted to write off all popular sources as somehow “bad.” due to fake news/ media bias claims. We should evalute popular sources credibility before using for academic assignment.
How can we evaluate newspaper, magazine, and website sources?
Use rhetorical reading skills
Understand the Context
Publisher. Who published this article? Remember that a publisher is not always the same as the author of a particular text. Does the publishing source cater to a particular audience? Does the publisher have some sort of ideological identity or bias? A bit of research on who published the article you are looking at (which newspaper. magazine, website, or organization) can give you some insight into any purpose or agenda that may shape the content of the article.
Author. Is the author an expert on the topic? A journalist? Someone who has direct experience with the topic or someone who is offering second hand commentary or analysis?
Assess the Quality of the Text
Identify the author’s main claim. Pay attention to what the author uses to support his or her claim – do you see relevant, evidence-based support or just emotional examples?
Do you see statistics used consistently and fairly, with an explanation of where they came from?
Does the author consider opposing viewpoints, and if so, how thoroughly?
Do you see logical fallacies in the author’s argument?
Assess the Quality of the Explanation, if the article is explanatory
Identify the author’s thesis. Pay attention to how balanced the author’s explanation is – does he or she present all sides equally so as to avoid clear judgement? Does the author effectively summarize sources used? (Please note that magazine and newspaper writing style does not require the types of in-text citations that we use in our papers).
Currency
Depending on the information you are using, the currency of the site could be vital. Check for the date of publication or the date of the latest update. Most of the links on a website should also still work – if they no longer do, that may be a sign the site is too out of date to be useful.
Relevance
Perhaps the article is interesting or easy to read. But is there something about the text itself or its context that makes it useful for your assignment?
Academic sources (also called scholarly sources)
It is generally only in college that we get exposure and access to scholarly articles and books.
What are attributes to Academic sources
Authoritative: The article has been produced by an expert in his or her field
Peer-reviewed: The article has been rigorously read and reviewed by other experts or authorities in that same field.
Published in a Scholarly Research Journal: Academic articles are often published in special journals that focus on one academic discipline or one topic of study.These articles are published for an audience who is also highly involved in that academic disciplinemost scholarly research journals require a paid subscription.
Considerations for Evaluating Academic Sources
even scholarly sources contain embedded biases, we should still review them.
How prolific is the author in his or her field? Has he or she written extensively on the topic that is addressed in this paper? check wors cited for previous publications by topic. this indicts the author is commited,.
If your article seems rather short and does not follow the general structure of an academic article then you should spend time considering whether or not the article is a relevant or credible source for the purposes of your assignment? Is there a more thorough or detailed source that you could use?
How current is the article? If you are looking for a historical perspective on your topic, then an older article may be useful. But if you need current information and your article is 10 or 15 years old, is it as relevant and useful for your assignment?
f the article is not answering your research question or the assignment question in any meaningful way, perhaps the source is not relevant to you. is it relevent?
What is the structure of a scholarly resource?
abstract, which is a summary of the author’s research question, methodologies and results.
Works Cited (also called a List of References). This is generally quite long, and it details all of the work that the author considered or cited
Literature Reviews in the beginning section of the article. They are generally several paragraphs or pages long. Some articles are only Literature Reviews. These Literature Reviews generally do not constitute an author’s own work. Instead, they are summaries and syntheses of other scholars’ work that has previously been published on the topic that the author is addressing in his or her paper. (dont qoute)
Somewhere near the end of the Literature Review, authors may indicate what has not been said or not been examined by previous scholars. This has been called a “research gap” in the social sciences – a space out of which a scholar’s own research develops.
Then, and sometimes for the bulk of an academic article, the author discusses his or her original work and analysis.
Conclusion.
As you read scholarly sources, remember
to look for the author’s research question or hypothesis
to seek out the “research gap”: why did the author have this research question or hypothesis?
to identify the Literature Review
to identify the the point at which the author stops discussing previous research and begins to discuss his or her own
Most importantly: remember to always try to understand what new information this article brings to the scholarly “conversation” about this topic?
Conducting Your Own Primary Research
Research questions, hese questions should not be easily answered. Research Methods how you plan to conduct your study.qualitative, quantitative, and mixed.
Qualitative Methods
esearch questions focus on opinions, individual experiences, motivations, etc. and generate non-numerical data.
Qualitative methods are often used if:
You want to study a phenomena/occurrence in detail
Example research question: How does a freshman ENG 102 student describe their writing processes?
You want to focus on individual interpretations/experiences
Example research question: What are the experiences of 18-25 year old women using Fitbits for dieting?
To gather qualitative data, researchers often use research interviews, open-ended survey questions, or focus groups.