PTSD Treatments Flashcards

1
Q

NICE Assessment

A
  • initial assessment / meeting - determination of the ned for emergency medical or psychiatric assessment
  • assessment - needs to be comprehensive and conducted by a competent individual
  • physical, psychosocial, social needs and risk assessment
  • patient preference - important determinant for the choice of treatment
  • need to be given sufficient information about the nature of the treatments so that the P can make an informed choice
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

Potential difficulties with diagnosing PTSD?

A

PTSD P’s - tend to avoid a lot of situations

Under-diagnosed - need to find a way of attracting them to therapy

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

NICE treatment

A
  • if symptoms are mild (less than 4 weeks) - ‘watchful waiting’ and then a follow-up meeting
  • if severe - trauma focused CBT or EMDR can be used!
  • if P refuses therapy - drugs can be used e.g. paroxetine (WARNING!)
  • if co-morbidities exist, then treat them
  • suicidal = priority
  • therapy normally consists of 8 - 12 sessions of 90 minutes
  • if trauma focused therapy is unsuccessful then drugs can be added
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

Prolonged Exposure Therapy

A
  • psychotherapy got PTSD
  • gradually approaching trauma-related memories, feelings and situations that have been avoided since the trauma
  • by avoiding the feelings and situations associated with the trauma of PTSD, there is a halt in the recovery
  • talking about the details of the trauma and controlling the situations, the P has been avoiding, PTSD symptoms can decrease and P can gain more control over their life
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

Prolonged Exposure Therapy

- therapy

A
  • repeated exposure to trauma memory so that fear extinction can take place
  • P’s have to learn that the world is not a terrible place even though they have experienced trauma
  • assumption - traumatic events are represented differently in memory as they are contra to the P’s beliefs about safety

> challenge this - show them that this isn’t true
altering this negative view of the world = recovery?
behavioural training - show them that these stimuli/responses aren’t threatening etc

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

Acceptance and Commitment Therapy

A
  • behaviour based therapy
  • aim - to reduce avoidance and steer the P towards behavioural changes
  • PTSD P - trying to avoid the disturbing memories, nightmares associated
  • trying to get them to confront their behaviours, not avoid them!
  • P - may think they are damaged which can lead to co-morbidities
  • ACT helps P’s to face these traumatic memories, thoughts, feelings etc by using mindfulness, acceptance and by targeting experiential avoidance
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

Trauma Focused CBT

A
  • with support from a therapist, confronting traumatic memories
  • attempts to change negative thoughts and fears about self-blame and the event recurring
  • also encouragement for client to resume parts of life they have given up

> pretty much basics of CPT - changing your cognitions and behaviours
confront negative attitudes and behaviours (particularly avoidance?) and realise that the world is not a scary place so that symptoms can decrease

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

What is EMDR?

A

Eye Movement Desensitisation and Reprocessing

  • Shapiro (1995)
  • a form of psychotherapy aimed at reducing distress that has been caused by traumatic events

> multi-saccadic eye movements whilst focusing on disturbing thoughts
authors found that these thoughts were suddenly disappearing and not returning after realising that involuntarily, their eyes were moving whilst thinking of those thoughts

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

EMDR - Process

A
  • P is faced with emotionally disturbing material in small amounts (concentrating on a traumatic picture and words of a belief statement)
  • visually track the therapists finger or follow something on the end of a stick
  • moved rapidly back and forth across the line of vision from the extreme R to the extreme L
  • information processing is enhanced and associations are built between existing memories or information and the traumatic memory
  • emotional distress is eliminated and information processing is complete
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

How does EMDR work?

A

> somehow affects your working memory
kind of distracts you from the emotions associated with the traumatic event?
focusing on one thing whilst thinking about something else

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

Narrative Therapy

A
  • P’s need to be able to make sense of the trauma the experience
  • ‘telling the story’ of it is therapeutic
  • narratives are formed with a therapist’s guidance
  • can have structured exercises, homework as well as creative techniques
  • very long process
  • reduces stress and symptoms are managed, allowing the P to move on
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

What is IPT?

A

Interpersonal Psychotherapy

  • focus on feelings and relationships / social and interpersonal functions
  • alternative to exposure based therapies
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

IPT - Rafaeli and Markowitz (2011)

- background

A
  • has shown efficacy in treating MDD and other psychiatric conditions
  • focus on P’s current life events, social and interpersonal functioning for understanding and treating symptoms
  • case report - demonstrating the novel use of IPT as treatment for PTSD
  • preliminary evidence - IPT may relieve PTSD symptoms without focusing on exposure to trauma reminders

IPT - an alternative for P’s who refuse or don’t respond to exposure based therapies
- focuses on 2 problem areas specifically affecting PTSD P’s —> interpersonal difficulties and affect dysregulation

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

IPT - Rafaeli and Markowitz (2011)

- P and method

A

This specific case - demonstrates a viable alternative to exposure-based therapy for this disorder

  • Mr A - grappled for more than 20 years with the after effects of a personal trauma
  • numerous attempts at therapies and self-help - exposure or LT psychodynamic therapies didn’t help

IPT - gave him a chance to understand himself through his feelings and relationships subsequent to the trauma
- focus on current feelings in current interpersonal relationships through decision and communication analyses

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

IPT - Rafaeli and Markowitz (2011)

- results

A

Symptoms appeared to diminish through the processes of understanding feelings and relationship patterns and the slow building of social support

  • helps P’s explore problematic relationship patterns beyond the core PTSD symptoms
  • Mr A - struggled with his sexuality - the more he talked about it, the more he connected it to his relationships and PTSD symptoms
  • exclusive focus on re-exposure to trauma reminders may never have realised this issue
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

IPT - Rafaeli and Markowitz (2011)

- after thoughts

A

SO for this specific case - the interpersonal issues bordering this P’s daily functioning were paramount to his dilemma and progress

For Mr A:

  • this treatment worked very well
  • just focusing on PTSD symptoms - not very useful to him
  • other things that needed to be taken into account

KEY TO PTSD TREATMENT - careful individual consideration?

17
Q

Psychodynamic therapy

A
  • focus on childhood experience / current relationships
  • especially the unconscious - where thoughts and feelings that are painful are stored
  • therapist helps P to identify the defence mechanisms being employed and how these relate to the traumatic event
  • interpretation of behaviours which are then discussed
  • through insight, the P can then address the painful thoughts
  • trying to explore the psychological meaning rather than trying to reduce symptoms directly
  • LONG TERM - 2 to 7 years or can be a brief 12 sessions
  • do have some efficacy within them!
18
Q

Neurofeedback - Gapen et al (2016)

A

Pilot study of neuro-feedback for chronic PTSD

  • found significant decreases in PTSD symptoms and affect dysregualtion
  • may be a promising addition to existing treatments for PTSD
  • overall, found that P’s PTSD symptoms reduced significantly (69.14 –> 49.26)
  • reduction in PTSD symptoms were related to decreases in an individual’s affect dysregulation
  • 40x sessions did provide significant decreases in PTSD symptoms
19
Q

Neurofeedback - Gapen et al (2016)

- after thoughts

A

Some disagreement with other research

Did the NF protocol employed here target limbic structures associated with the maintenance of PTSD?
- as the limbic structures became more regulated, this may have allowed the PFC to better regulate affect

Examined a non-veteran sample - so hopefully can expect to see similar effects in NF with chronic PTSD

Potential to increase tolerability of treatment because clients aren’t asked to expose themselves to emotionally difficult traumatic material

20
Q

Flotation Therapy

A

Lying in a tank, allows mind to go into theta state
- very deep relaxation state

Changes brain chemistry?

21
Q

Acupuncture

A

Useful for anxiety and depression

Not a great deal of studies using PTSD

22
Q

Acupuncture - Kim et al (2012)

A

First systematic review and meta-analysis of acupuncture for the treatment of PTSD

One high quality RCT

  • acupuncture vs CBT and waitlist control
  • no statistical differences between acupuncture and CBT
  • acupuncture - statistically superior to waitlist control

Review overall
- acupuncture is effective for PTSD based on one high-quality RCT and a meta-analysis

Acupuncture
- statistically superior to waitlist control BUT no statistical difference was found between the effectiveness of acupuncture and CBT

23
Q

Acupuncture - Kim et al (2012)

- conclusion

A
  • evidence for effectiveness of acupuncture for PTSD is encouraging BUT not very convincing due to the few studies included in the meta-analysis
  • two studies - too small to verify its efficacy!
24
Q

Acupuncture - Feinstein (2010)

- background

A

Rapid treatment of PTSD - psychological exposure with acu-point tapping

  • preliminary evidence - acupoint stimulation with brief psychological exposure, PTSD symptoms and underlying neurological patterns may be targeted with unusual speed, power and lasting effects while minimising the likelihood of re-traumatization
25
Q

Acupuncture - Feinstein (2010)

- study

A

Acu-point stimulaiton - believed to send deactivating signals to the amygdala and other structures

  • rapidly reduces hyper-arousal and extinguishes threat responses to innocuous triggers

If clinical reports and early research evidence are confirmed, the combination of brief psychological exposure and acu-point stimulation may enhance the ability of psychotherapies to treat PTSD more rapidly and effectively

26
Q

Other therapies?

A
  • smaller treatments - may not get rid of all symptoms / help them fully recover
  • BUT if it can help tackle some of the symptoms then why not?
  • highly debated treatment option - acupuncture
    > western vs eastern medical practices
27
Q

Effectiveness of treatments?

A

CBT (CPT, Prolonged Exposure), EMDR - most effective
Drugs - not 100% sure about

PROBLEM

  • no one fits all therapy
  • some therapists aren’t comfortable using some forms of therapy, e.g. exposure therapy

–> depends on what is averrable in your area?

28
Q

Effect sizes of treatments?

A

CBT meta-analysis effect size = 1.11; EMDR = 1.43
Cognitive therapy - 85% recovery effect, effect size 7.20
IPT - several studies / effect sizes vary
EMDR - good RCT evidence
Psychodynmaic - 0.67
SSRI - most evidence says that they are the best drugs for PTSD

29
Q

Imel et al (2013)

A

Meta-analysis of dropout in treatments for PTSD

  • conducted a meta-analysis of dropout among active treatments in clinical trials for PTSD
  • average dropout rates was 18% - THIS VARIED SIGNIFICANTLY ACROSS STUDIES
  • group modality and greater number of sessions - NOT TRAUMA FOCUS - predicted increased drop out

Drop out varies between active interventions for PTSD across studies BUT differences are primarily driven by differences between studies

30
Q

Problem with number of sessions

A

Greater number of sessions being a problem?

Ehlers et al (2014)

  • controlled trial of 7-day intensive and standard weekly CT for PTSD and emotion focused-therapy
  • intensive therapy - better?
31
Q

Problems to consider with treating PTSD

A

BIG PROBLEM

  • people don’t go to get treated
  • drop outs?

Do we have to tailor treatment to the individual?!