Quiz 1 Flashcards
(45 cards)
What is an objective (realist) perspective?
“judgey”
believe that morality exists independent of our individual judgements
“there is right and wrong, and our opinion of it doesn’t change it”
example: hardcore religions (a higher power makes the judgement)
What is a subjective perspective?
a subset of the non-realist perspective
believe that morality is indexed by the individual
only you can make judgements about yourself
What is a relativist perspective?
“right and wrong are determined by CONTEXT”
ie) culture, politics, religion
only an in-group can make judgements or evaluations about their own members
How is morality distinct from law?
both have norms that are intended to guide conduct
but
legality is made legitimate by the government/constitution
morality is legitmated by God/rationality/society
How is morality distinct from religion?
most religions have morality built into them but not all moral theories are based in religion
explain obligatory action
an action that is required. you receive no praise when it is done, an blame if not done
DUTY
going to practice
explain permissible action
okay to do, but no blame or praise
not going to an optional practice
explain supererogatory action
really good to do, praise if dont, no blame if not done
volunteering every day at a soup kitchen
what is is a moral theory?
a moral theory is just any framework used to morally evaluate action
what is argumentation
can be formal or informal, ways to justify things
how do we structure arguments?
informal argumentation is done using paragraphs and dialogue
formal arguments are structured using premises and ending with a conclusion
how do we decide if an argument is valid?
an argument is valid if the conclusion follows from the premise(s) which make the conclusion true
how do we decide if an argument is sound?
an argument is sound if it is valid and if all the premises are true
what are counterexamples used for (what are other forms of critiquing an argument?)
a counterexample is a reason against a premise or piece of evidence
another way to critique an argument would be to find an inconsistency in a persons beliefs or argument
a bad argument would be just disagreeing or an ad hominem argument ie saying youre stupid
what is the difference between descriptive and normative arguments?
descriptive- claims to tell us something about the world and is based in fac, empirical, and observable things
normative- makes claims about “what is good/how things should be.” Contain “ought” statements and value judgements
formal normative arguments must have a normative conclusion and at least one normative premise
what is empiricism? What is rationalism?
both are justifications of judgements:
empiricism: begins from lived experience to figure out what people value (more consequence driven)
rationalism: begin from thought (values are reached through reflection)
**this is what socrates is doing
what is an argument from authority?
justification is made based on the power a person possesses or their positionality
what is agent centered vs. act centered theories?
act centered: focuses on actions (what is accomplished or what are the consequences?
agent centered: focuses on the person, their intention, type of person they are, etc.
examples of each:
act centered: utilitarianism
agent centered: virtue/character ethics
what is egoism?
the idea that people should act in a way that benefits their own self interest
what is intuition and the role of intuition?
**I think:
it goes against a lot of utilitarianism as sometimes our intuitions to do good or do things do align with what produces the most utility but we do them anyways
what are platos overall aims in the euthyphro? Hat is the structure?
Euthyphro is a high priest and a teacher to socrates. Euthyphro is attempting to try his father for murder and justify his actions as being pious. Socrates then wants Euthyphro to explain what piety really is and they debate this using elenchus.
But also they are trying to debate a moral theory through debate and conversation and then redebating
the euthyphro is structured using stephanus numbers which allows us to number lines
what is the socratic method and what is the other word it is called?
elenchus
Follows the basic structure of:
- definition
- critique
- redefinition
- critique
what is the euthyphro dilemma?
“is the pious loved by the gods because it is pious or is it pious because it is loved by the gods?”
2 horns of the dilemma:
- if being loved by god makes something good then goodness seems arbitrary (random/without reason)
- if things are good independently of what god thinks, then god isn’t omnipotent (why do we need god then)
what is the divine command theory?
the theory that all morality and commands are derived from what god wants