Quiz 2 Flashcards
(30 cards)
Heritage Planning Shift
- increased litigiousness
- rest on slides
Ontario Heritage Case Law Project
- origins of project
1. lack of heritage legislation based on
2. Salmoni Building
Are property rights enshrined in our constitution?
No
Tremblay V Lakeshore
Landmark Case
- Municipality of Lakeshore
- provisions of several catholic churches wanted to designate them
- parish didn’t want them to
- municipal passed by-law will not designate unless owner consent (created undue restriction)
- contrary to supreme court hearing
Viner Assets v Ottawa
- ambiguity Prov policy definition
- property may have heritage value but not designated yet
Andrew’s Jewelry Store
- municipality designated inside (cases)
- fixture vs channel
The Municipal Act
- at what point do we designate heritage?
- the legislation has been used to stop development, and in place of other legislation (Planning Act)
Ontario Heritage Act
- purpose: doesn’t have one
Heritage Conservation District
- helps manage change in neighbourhood
- enhances/complements community character
Top 10 Consistent Issues
- on slides
Robinson + Dale
Reflections of Sustainability (on slides)
Hawkes Four Pillars
- culture
- social
- econ
- env
quote of the year
the big picture is to think about the big picture
Adaption-Resilience
- Gatineau example
80/20 rule
- 80% comments that come from 20% of population
Conservation Review Board
- deals with designation and alteration
- deal with designate archaeological sites
- doesn’t deal with demolition (lpat)
- councils can choose to ignore them
Bill 108
- remove crb designation and alteration
- will create more things going through appeal
Expert’s Duty
- on slides
Ethics
Branch of philosophy that deal with moral principles
Ethics as it applies to heritage conservation
- conservation ethics as moral practice: acting responsibly to humanity
- ce as best conservation practice: acting responsibly to the historic place
- ce as best professional practice: acting responsibly to clients and colleagues
ICOMOS Ethical Statement
- provides tool to improve and clarify ethical conservation practice
Canada Association of Heritage Professionals ‘Code of Professional Conduct & Ethics’ Objectives
- guidelines for members to follow when doing work
- set of standards members must comply with
- ensure interests of public and clients will be properly served by members of the organization
Canada Association of Heritage Professionals ‘Code of Professional Conduct & Ethics’ Sections
- qualifications
- professionalism
- responsibility to colleagues, employers, clients
- proposals and fees
- disciplinary procedures
Ipperwash Inquiry Findings
- archeological master plans were a recommendation
- 1990s cadet camp on lake huron, taken from indigenous group for military purposes, was gonna be given back until they now longer needed it
- protests and death led to ipperwash inquiry
- if they had done archaeology they would have been aware of interests/history
