Realty Contracts Flashcards
Statute of Frauds
Requires a writing signed by the party to be charged for a transfer of an interest in realty.
Exceptions to the Statute of Frauds
Include:
- The doctrine of part performance
- Equitable estoppel
- Promissory estoppel
Doctrine of Part Performance
A showing of at least two of the following three facts must be made:
- Payment of all or part of the purchase price
- Taking of possession
- Making substantial improvements
Equitable Estoppel
Based on an act or a representation
Promissory Estoppel
Based on a promise
Essential Terms for a K of sale (to Comply with SOF)
Include:
- Description of the property
- Description of the parties
- Price
- Any conditions of price or payment that have been agreed
Proper Description of the Property
To satisfy the SOF, a description of the property must involve an identifiable parcel. A land that allows a buyer to purchase any acres “chosen by buyer” is too indeterminate to satisfy the SOF.
Time for Performance of a Realty K
As with other contracts, if no time is stated, then performance is to occur within a reasonable time.
Time is of the Essence Clause
Means that nonperformance at the time specified in the K (the closing date) will be considered a material breach) and a party cannot enforce performance. But some courts will consider an acceptance of a late payment as a waiver of a time-is-of-the-essence clause.
Circumstances Where a Court will Still Enforce SP Despite Breach of Time-is-of-the-Essence Clause
- The breach was not due to gross negligence or deliberate or bad faith by breaching party
- The non-breaching party could be adequately compensated for the injury caused by the delay
- The forfeiture that would otherwise result would be harsh and unreasonable
Seller’s Remedies in Law for Buyer’s Breach
Include:
- Expectation Damages
- Foreseeable Consequential Damages
- Reasonable Reliance Damages
- Recovery of Down Payment
- Liquidated Damages
Seller’s Remedies: Expectation Damages
Measured by K price - the market price at time of breach (or K price - resale price in a minority of jurisdictions).
Seller’s Remedies: Foreseeable Consequential Damages
Can include mortgage interest payments that the seller is required to make after the buyer’s breach
Seller’s Remedies: Reasonable Reliance Damages
Can include repairs, costs of inspections, etc.
Seller’s Remedies: Recovery of Down Payment (in Absence of Liquidated Damages Clause)
(Traditional rule)- buyers could recovery the entire amount of the down payment
(Modern rule)- restricts recovery to a down payment that equals 10% or less of the purchase price (seller must return amount by which down payment exceeds damages caused by buyer’s breach)
Seller’s Remedies: Liquidated Damages
Clause in a realty K that states that the seller may retain the entire amount of down payment if the buyer breaches. Is generally enforceable if it is reasonable.
Important Factors for Determining if a Liquidated Damages Clause is Reasonable
- The injury caused by the breach is one that is difficult or incapable of accurate estimation (judged at time K was made or at time loss occurs)
- The liquidated damages are a reasonable forecast of the harm caused by the breach.
Liquidated Damages Clause v. Earnest $
Earnest $ is usually seen as a demonstration of a purchaser’s willingness and ability to carry out a K (therefore a K that accounts for earnest $ will not be seen as a liquidated damages provision).
Punitive Damages
Are only available if buyer’s breach was willful (same thing goes for the buyer’s damages)
Seller’s Remedies in Equity for a Buyer’s Breach
- Rescission of the K
- Mutuality of Remedy Rule (would allow seller to require SP (has fallen out of favor))
Buyer’s Remedies at Law for Seller’s Breach of K
- Include:
- Expectation Damages
- Foreseeable Consequential Damages (e.g. lost profits)
- Reliance Damages (e.g. cost of inspections)
- Restitution of the Down Payment
Buyer’s Remedies: Expectation Damages
Measured by K price - market price at time of breach (or K price - resale price in some jurisdictions).
Buyer’s Remedies: Restitution of Down Payment (English Rule)
Rule that claims that if the seller fails to deliver marketable title, the buyer may seek restitution + interest and reasonable expenses incurred in investigating title. However, restitution in excess of down payment are prohibited unless seller acted in bad faith or assumed the risk.
Buyer’s Remedies: Restitution of Down Payment (The American Rule)
If the seller fails to deliver marketable title, the buyer is not restricted to restitution of his down payment.