Religious typologies Flashcards
Weber & Troeltsch
First distinguished between churches and sects
Churches: feautures
Very structured hierarchy (pope, cardinals, archbishops, bishops, priests etc)
Regular place of worship and regular gatherings
Higher power
Holy text/scripture/guidebook
Believe in life after death
Believe they have the only truth
Wide open memberships (varied commitment)
Churches: examples
5 out of the 6 world religions Christianity Hinduism Sikhism Judaism Islamism
Sects: features
Tend to be very small, exclusive membership
Total commitment- sometimes vow of poverty
World rejecting
One, all powerful, charismatic leader (present themselves as the voice of God)
One belief in one truth- intolerance to other ‘truths’
Always a higher power
Sects: examples
Strong city
Jim Jones
Westboro Baptist Church
Becker
A denomination is a sect that has cooled down and is no longer a protest group
Neiebuhr
Long surviving sect will inevitably become a denomination (because once the leader dies, the structure must become more bureaucratic and organized)
Denominations: features
Scriptures/guidebooks Meeting place Higher power Low to medium commitment More tolerant of other truths More 'low church' - very plain and simple, not very ritual Less of a hierarchical structure Gradually less deviant and become offshoots of a mainstream religion
Denominations: examples
Mormons Methodists Hare Krishna Baptists Protestants Moonies
Cults: features
Least coherent form of religious organization
Focus on individual experience
Bringing people together for self improvement
No higher power/focus on inner power
Led by a teacher/instructor
Branch or businesslike structure (pay for sessions)
Completely open membership
Cults: examples
Crustal healing Reiki (hands on healing) Scientology Transcendental meditation Yoga
Stark and Bainbridge
Audience cults
Client cults
Cultic movements
Audience cults
Little to none face to face interaction (eg buying a crystal online with a guidebook)
eg astrology, belief in UFOs
Client cults
Particular service to followers
eg crystal healing, tarot readings, colour therapy
Cultic movements
Most organised and demand higher levels of commitment
eg Doomsday organisations, the People’s Temple
Bruce
Argues that in the 15th century there was one dominant church and one dominant conception of God
Freedom of the individual and freedom of thought had hardly developed at all
The reformation in the 16th and 17th centuries saw the growth of greater religious freedom
Through the process of industrialization competing belief systems arose including scientific ones- practice became more diverse
Belief have become a matter of personal choice
New Religious Movements and New Age Movements have developed
Classification of New Religious Movements
Many attempts to classify the wide variety of religious groups that have emerged
Some stem from particular religious traditions- Han Krishna (inspiration from Hinduism)
Others have no connection to other religions
Barker
Human Potential Movements- liberating human potential
eg transcendental meditation, spiritualism
Wallis
Divided new religious movements into 3 categories:
World Rejecting
World Accommodating
World Affirming
World Rejecting NRMs
Most like a sect Definite concept of God Highly critical of the outside world Total institutions controlling members' lives Limited contact to outside world Quite radical but can hold conservative views Communal lifestyle Can be millenerian
World Accommodating NRMs
Most like denominations
Offshoots of an existing church or denomination
Concerned with religious matters
Seek to restore spiritual purity
Usually lead normal and respectable lives
World Affirming NRMs
Lack some features normally thought to be central to religion
Access to spiritual or supernatural powers
Not exclusive
Tolerate other religions
Wallis Evaluation
Often still debated
Categories are sometimes difficult to apply- does he categorize according to movements teaching or member’s beliefs
Insufficient attention to diversity- many do not fit into his typology- some have features of all three
No group can afford to reject the world all together
Stark and Bainbridge believe that it is more useful to distinguish between religious organisations depending how much tension or conflict there is between the religious group and the wider society
Strong City
Type of Religion:
Sect