Risk Management Flashcards
Reasons to hedge
- Saving taxes
- Avoiding financial distress
- Capital needs
- Management compensation
- Strategic and investment decisions
- Climate change as new (financial risk)
MM Proposition I –> absence of market frictions, shareholder are indifferent between…
hedging on their own accounts and having their firms
do the hedging for them
If hedging choices do not affect cash flows from real assets, in
the absence of taxes and transaction costs, hedging decisions
do not affect …
firm value
Reasons to hedge – Avoiding financial distres
- Financial distress can be costly
- By hedging risks, a firm can increase its value through a reduction of the
probability of facing financial distress in the future
Reasons to hedge – Capital needs : definition
Investors may value the delay or change as a bad signal for firm’s future prospects and become overly
pessimistic
–> the firm does not get access to external finance (or not at attractive terms)
page 9 (Graph)
Capital needs : characteristic
- Internal resources are cheaper than external (e.g., because of information
asymmetries, taxes, and transaction costs) - capital expenditures (CAPEX) highly depend on internal cash flows
- Tendency of overinvestment or underinvestment according to firm’s cash flow
Problem with capital expenditures
Firms have to plan their CAPEX in advance but often face highly volatile cash flows.
–> They may not have enough cash in the future
- If a firm cannot undertake or has to alter its strategic investment plan due to changes in the exchange rate
–> investors could be much more pessimistic on the firm’s future prospects
Solution with capital expenditures
hedge cash flows in order to reduce the variability of
cash flows, thereby enhancing firm value
Reasons to hedge – Management compensation
The management is compensated based on the operating performance
–> Change of exchange rate not under the control of the management
Reasons to hedge – Management compensation: characteristic
- Managers should only be paid for their «real» performance
- Compensating or punishing the management for performance or risk outside their control is inefficient
- Hedging uncontrollable risks leaves the managers, especially risk-averse
managers, with a larger proportion of manageable risks for performance
evaluation - desirable from a corporate governance point of view as this reduces the “pay for luck” problem
very difficult to design a compensation package that eliminates a
manager’s exposure to all hedgeable risks, why ?
- Problem of evaluation how such risks affect the firm
- Problem to find benchmarks that account for multidimensional risks
Reasons to hedge – Strategic & investment decisions
- active risk management program can improve management’s decision making process by reducing the profit volatility of individual business unit
- Less volatile profits for a company’s business units provide management at the
firm’s central headquarters with better information about where to allocate capital and which managers are the most deserving of promotion - Less volatile profits / cash flows also increase debt capacity
A sophisticated risk management will have a better understanding of…
future market prices so that managers can allocate capital efficiently across the firm’s units, because investment decisions rely on future opportunities (e.g., scenarios) and not historical prices.
Insurance companies have better abilities to asses risk than industrial companies due to..
past experiences.
–> Insuring risks of a planned project enables the firm to better price this project.
Reasons to hedge – Climate change as new financial risk
- High carbon scenario
- Low carbon scenario
High-carbon scenario
Rising sea levels, severe storms, floods, and wildfires may disrupt business operations, damage property, and devalue assets
Low-carbon scenario
Transformation of the economy to new energy sources
and business models; associated with financial risk about the associated climate
outcomes and policy responses and the resulting economic and financial fallout
Measuring a firm’s risk exposure: Factor models (calculation)
CFj = aj + BiF1 + Bi2F2 + … + BikFk + 𝜀𝑖
Fk: macroeconomic factors (e.g interest rate movements)
Bik: cash flow’s sensitivity to these factors
𝜀𝑖: explanation of the risk not captured in the factors (firm specific risk)
A stock’s sensitivity to factor risk as well as firm-specific risk is determined
by…
the firm’s capital expenditures and operating and financial decisions
Factor risk is generally not…
diversifiable (e.g., exchange rates, oil price), but
often it can be hedged by taking off-setting positions in financial derivatives
Firm-specific risk is just the opposite (e.g., technical problems of a plant). It is..
diversifiable but not hedgeable. It is only possible to insure against these
risks using insurance contracts
Estimating factor models using regression analysis requires the use..
of historical data for the risk factors to obtain estimates of the risk factor exposures
The dependent variable in these regressions are..
the unhedged cash
flows of the firm
risk factor exposure estimates will only have..
predictive power, if the same risk factors affect the firm similarly in the future