Salem witch trials Flashcards

1
Q

What was the background to New England?

A

English colonists settled in North America, taking religion and beliefs with them.
Start of seventeenth century, approximately 40,000 people from British Isles crowded on packed ships, looking for fresh opportunity in America.
People leaving England at time of religious turmoil, Reformation and mini ice age.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

What problems did Britain bring into America?

A

1617, smallpox epidemic, which travelled to Atlantic from British isles, decimating Native American Indian population.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

What was the first ship to travel to America?

A

1620, The Mayflower set sail from port of Portsmouth, filled with around 100 passengers (puritans).

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

When was the Massachusetts Bay Colony established?

A

1629, on Puritan principles. Mindful that Devil was ever-present and trying to entice people into becoming witches.
Puritans in Massachusetts more militant than those in England, asserted religious liberties, whilst refusing to tolerate others.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

Who was the first official witch to be executed in English colonies?

A

Alice Young, hanged 1647 in Connecticut (new England state, founded by Puritan settlers).

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

How many were hanged in new England before Salem trials?

A

Around 17.
Around 80 accused.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

Were all the New England colonies established on Puritan beliefs?

A

No, Maryland was established on traditions of Church of England, with sacraments of the Catholic Church.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

What was the main conflict in New England?

A

Conflict between old and new settlers.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

When was a witchcraft law introduced to Massachusetts and what did it state?

A
  1. ‘If any man or woman be a witch (that hath consulted with a familiar spirit) they shall be put to death’.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

What was witch-hunting like prior to the Salem witch trials?

A

Most cases were routed in long-term suspicions, mainly women on the fringes of society. Most accusations for maleficia.
Influenced by judicial scepticism in England, wanted proof, not speculations.
Many people in Puritan Massachusetts believed Satan and agents were present.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

What was the Boston case?

A

1688, four of John Goodwin’s children started to behave strangely, as though they were in pain.
Cotton Mather, a Boston minister, concluded that they had been bewitched.
Mary Glover, washerwoman, had been found guilty and executed.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

What was the political situation in Massachusetts?

A

1684, the royal charter by which Massachusetts was governed by ran out, which allowed colonists freedom, enabling the Puritan church theocracy.
Unpopular dominion of New England replaced the charter.
1689, Sir Edward Andros, governor of the Dominion was ousted following the Glorious Revolution in England. Catholic King James II replaced by Protestant co-leaders William and Mary.
Simon Bradstreet and Thomas Danforth resumed their posts as governor and deputy governor. They lacked constitutional authority to rule until new charter introduced. Puritans feared they would lose their autonomy and God’s commonwealth in Massachusetts would be overthrown.
Fears not needed, new charter approved in October 1691, stated Massachusetts should conform to English Law and allow religious toleration.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

What was the impact of King William’s War?

A

1689, tensions erupted between English co
Colonists in Maine and French- supported Wabanaki Native Americans.
Over winter 1691-2, a stream of refugees fleeing Native American raids brought reports of massacres and predictions of savagery to come.
Children in particular fearful of what their parents were saying.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

How many residents did Salem village have?

A

600

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

What were the internal disputes about?

A

Mainly about property and Church privileges.
Feud between two most prosperous families, Putnams and Porters.
Putnams wanted to sever village from Salem Town, establishing institutions of local government and worship. Supporters mainly on Western side of village, contributing to subsistence farming.
Porters wanted closer ties to Salem Town. Porters supporters are entrepreneurial and commercial.
Families in Salem usually committed themselves to one side, loyalty became a large issue.
Church became a focal point of tension.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

What was the situation with ministers?

A

Putnams, anxious for the village to have its own congregation, appointed George Burroughs as minister 1681, lasted until 1682. Deodat Lawson replaced Burroughs, but appointment divided community.
1689, Samuel Parris became village minister. Parris had support of Putnam family, preached against those who opposed him, creating divisions.
Anti-Parris faction retaliated in October 1691 when Putnam- dominated rate committee was ousted and Porter dominated group took over.
Jan 1692, Parris worried, the rate committee controlled his salary.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

When did the initial events leading to the Salem witch hunt occur and what happened?

A

Salem village, Feb 1692, Betty Parris (daughter of reverend Parris) behaved oddly, having fits. Cousin, Abigail Williams followed suit.
Similar to the Boston case.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

Who was the local doctor in Salem village and what did he think of the two afflicted girls?

A

Illness not natural but the work of the Devil.
Reverend Parris not immediately convinced, continued to pray alongside minister John Hale. Prayer failed.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

Which other girls on top of Betty and Abigail became afflicted?

A

Ann Putnam, whose father was Sergeant Thomas Putnam.
Mercy Lewis, servant in Thomas Putnam’s house.
Mary Walcott, niece of the Putnam’s.
Elizabeth Hubbard, Dr Griggs niece.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

What were some of the explanations for Betty and Abigail’s behaviour?

A
  • Psychological hysteria from Native American attack, Satan and smallpox epidemic.
  • Possession neuroses, belief in Demons.
  • Eating rye bread infected with ergot, fungus drug LSD is derived.
  • Copying the behaviour of the Boston case.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

What was the witch cake?

A

Feb, 1692, Mary Sibley (neighbour of Parris), instructed John, one of ministers Native American slaves to make a witch cake.
Traditional English magic to discover the identity of the witch.
Made from rye meal and urine from afflicted girls, when dog ate, was meant to cause witch to scream in pain.
Tituba, John’s wife made the cake.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

What was the response to the witch cake?

A

Parris criticised Sibley, admonishing her for ‘going to the Devil for help against the Devil’.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

Who was accused by Betty, Ann, Abigail and Mercy?

A

Between 25 February (when Tituba fed the witch cake to a dog) and 29 February (when first arrest warrant was issued), named Sarah Good, Sarah Osborne and Tituba.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

Why did Betty, Ann, Abigail and Mercy accuse who they did?

A

Traits typical for ‘usual suspects’.
- Tituba, a slave, legally an outsider.
- Good a disreputable beggar.
- Osborne old and rarely attended church meetings.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
Q

Were the accusations seen as part of the Porter-Putnam quarrel?

A

The first denunciations, alongside many of the others do not suggest this.
Yet, Rebecca Nurse was accused (11 March), when her family had been part of a quarrel with the Putnams.
It may have been that it was A factor, not the main.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
26
Q

Where did the Putnam’s bring their suspicions?

A

Essex County
JPs Jonathon Corwin and John Hathorne issued warrants for the women accused by the girls, arranged for an inquest.

27
Q

When were the first hearings against Osborne, Tituba and Good?

A

1 March 1692
Initially began in a tavern, but so many neighbours intrigued that it was moved to the meeting house.

28
Q

How did the accused women react to the first hearing?

A

Good, defending herself decided to accuse Osborne.
Tituba originally denied, but JPs refused to believe so admitted she had been approached by tall man in Boston (Devil), Good and Osborne were witches and that many others in Massachusetts were involved in the ‘Devil’s Conspiracy’.
Over next days, more witnesses came forward, gave evidence of maleficium.
Three women imprisoned awaiting trial.

29
Q

Who was accused on the 11th March 1692?

A

Ann Putnam accused Martha Corey and Rebecca Nurse, which Abigail Williams supported.
Martha had drawn attention to herself by being sceptical about the girls.
Rebecca Nurse part of quarrel with Putnams.
Deeply troubled people, all substantial people, if they could be witches, so could anyone.
Ann Putnams mother (also named Ann) accused John Willard, saying he had caused the death of her daughter.

30
Q

Who did the girls accuse in April, 1692?

A

Abigail and Deliverance Hobbs, Sarah Wildes, Elizabeth Howe.

31
Q

Why can we infer that the girls were acting?

A

Examiners, mostly Hathorne prompted the girls into fits, asking them to identify the suspects.
If the suspect touched the girls and the fit stopped, they were guilty.

32
Q

Why was religion significant to the JPs, specifically Hathorne?

A

Strong Puritan conviction, the more witches accused, the more convinced they were that the Devil was at play.

33
Q

What was the deputy governors reaction to the Salem witch hunts?

A

11 April, Thomas Danforth visited Salem to witness the girls.
The girls performed, alongside the Native American John, who also started to have fits.
Danforth not convinced, travelled back to Boston with matter unresolved.

34
Q

What happened in Andover?

A

May, girls turned to Andover, accusing Martha Carrier of witchcraft.
June, Ann Putnam and Mary Walcott went to Andover, where blindfolded, were touched by parade of men and women suspected. Named four witches.
People in Andover started accusing one another.
May, accusations were increasing. John Alden, a Boston sea captain, and Phillip English, a merchant, fled fearing their lives over their property.

35
Q

When did Sarah Osborne pass away?

A

Died in gaol, 10 May.

36
Q

Who were the most vulnerable to accusations by May?

A

Adults around them inadvertently provided clues of people long suspected of witchcraft.
Quakers- refused to take oaths, opposed titles.
George Burroughs- Baptist (a branch of Protestantism).

37
Q

Which ‘witches’ started to confess in gaol?

A

Tituba had been first.
Next, Abigail Hobbs, confessed to seeing Devil and pinching Putnam and Lewis at his command. Hobbs then became an informer, obliged to JPs, saying George Burroughs was the head of Witches coven.
Mary Warren and Deliverance Hobbs also confessed, saying that there were over 300 witches in Massachusetts.
Periodically brought out of gaol to accuse more witches.
More arrests followed.

38
Q

What interestingly happened to Tituba?

A

Cleared by a grand jury in May, bill of indictment brought against her charged her with contacting devil, not actually harming anyone.

39
Q

How many were in custody by the end of May?

A

62
Most lived in Salem or nearby Andover.

40
Q

Who was the new governor of Massachusetts in May?
What did he do?

A

14 May, William Phips wanted to do something about crisis, but his main interest was defeating the Native Americans and French in Maine.
27 May, created Court of Oyer (to hear) and Terminer (to decide), to deal with the Salem situation.
William Stoughton was chief judge of the court.
Having created the court, Phips went off to fight Native Americans.

41
Q

How many times did the Court of Oyer and Terminer meet?

A

Five times, each for a brief span of days.
June- September 1692.

42
Q

What is the source evidence like for Salem?

A

Pre-trial examinations and eye witness statements have survived, yet records of the trials themselves have been lost.
Yet, some records made available to Cotton Mather, who wrote a defence of the trials ‘Wonders of the invisible world’.
Yet, not present at the trials.

43
Q

What was the use of spectral evidence?

A

Much, but not all of the evidence used was spectral (girls who claimed to have seen apparition of girls afflicting them).
Girls and women often claimed that they had seen witches familiar, rather than witch herself.
Opponents of this say that the devil was able to impersonate.
Yet, others say that the Devil could only take others form with their permission, indicating that there must have been some complacency.

44
Q

What do historians think of the use of spectral evidence?

A

Wendel Craker (1997), showed it was non-spectral charges that were crucial.
Judges, advised by Cotton Mather, followed directions of Puritan William Perkins.
By Perkins model, spectral evidence could be used to indict but not convict.
Confession or non-spectral evidence required.
Testimony concerning maleficium had to be done by at least two people of good character.
Court obeyed the ecclesiastical recommendations, seventy-nine people charged only with spectral appearance (half of total accused), but none of them called by court to answer charges.

45
Q

What happened in the first trial?

A

2 June, court convened in Salem Town, William Stoughton as chief magistrate.
Bridget Bishop first brought to grand jury, deeply mistrusted, girls writhed, many neighbours willing to give evidence against her, had been accused 10 years earlier.
Bishop sent to trial same day, found guilty, executed 10 June.

46
Q

What happened in the first trial?
Part 2

A

Rebecca Nurse and John Willard brought forward, but did not immediately go to trial.
Court adjourned until 30 June, allowing time to reflect on what had occurred. Not all impressed by what they had witnessed, Major Nathaniel Saltonstall resigned from bench.
Some ministers like John Hale and Samuel Willard condemned the girls writhing.
Court sought advice from Massachusetts most influential ministers, such as Cotton Mather.

47
Q

What was Cotton Mather’s influence?

A

Appeared to be best source of knowledge on witches:
- Written an account of the bewitching of the Goodwin children.
- Father, Increase Mather, hugely respected.
Mather wrote ministerial response, ‘The Return of Several Ministers to the Governor and Council in Boston’
Said to not rely on spectral evidence alone, but did not reject it.
Did not condemn the first trial, recommended the ‘speedy and vigorous prosecution’.

48
Q

What happened in the second court session?

A

30 June- early July, Sarah Good, Elizabeth Howe, Susannah Martin and others brought forward. Sarah Good, Elizabeth Howe, Susannah Martin, Sarah Wildes and also Rebecca Nurse went on trial.
Found guilty, executed 19 July.

49
Q

What happened in the third court session?

A

2 August, George Burroughs, Elizabeth Proctor and others brought forward.
All convicted and executed 19 August, other than Elizabeth Proctor, given a temporary stay of execution, as she was pregnant.

50
Q

What was the significance of confessions?

A

July, accusations began again.
A constable invited Salem girls to Andover to uncover cause of wife’s illness.
Ann Putnam and Mary Walcott named Ann Foster, her daughter Mary Lacey and her granddaughter Mary Lacey. All immediately confessed and implicated the five about to be hanged, Cotton Mather saw as vindicating the court’s judgment.
After this, 1/3 of those charged (50 out of 156) admitted. Seen as a way of escaping execution.
Robert Calef ‘not one of them that confessed their own guilt and abode by their confessions were put to death’.
Valid, only six confessors brought to trial and only one executed, Samuel Wardwell, who renounced his confession.

51
Q

What happened in the fourth and fifth court sessions?

A

September, 18 more people brought forward.
19 September, Giles Corey (71 year old farmer) refused to plead guilty or innocent. Pressed beneath a heavy load of stones to attempt to get a plea, died after two days. May have been so his property could not be confiscated or a method of protest against the courts methods.
22 September, eight more witches executed.

52
Q

What two factors ended the Salem witch hunt?

A

Opposition from Church leaders
Action by Governor Phips

53
Q

What was the main ministerial opposition to the Salem witch trials?

A

Samuel Willard, Boston Minister, ‘Some Miscellany Observations’. Increase Mather, head of Ministerial Association, ‘Cases of Conscience Concerning Evil Spirits’.

54
Q

What did Samuel Willard say opposing the Salem witch trials?

A

Stated objections to trials, specifically the ‘afflicted’ girls writhing.

55
Q

What did Increase Mather say opposing the Salem witch trials?

A

3 October, ‘Cases of Conscience Concerning Evil Spirits’.
‘it were better than ten suspected witches should escape than one innocent person should be condemned’.

56
Q

What were Governor Phips actions to prevent the Salem Witch hunts?

A

Realised the Court of Oyer and Terminer did not help, inflamed the situation.
Disbanded the court, reprieved five in gaol awaiting execution.
Jan 1693, new court, Superior Court of Judicature, Court of Assize and Gaol Delivery convened in Salem, headed by Stoughton.
Phips specifically prevented Stoughton from admitting spectral evidence.
First cases in January were of the five witches that had been reprieved. All found not guilty.
31 more people indicted in tried, only 3 found guilty.
Stoughton still obsessive in the pursuit of witchcraft, wrote warrants for the execution of the three, Phips pardoned them.
Stoughton resigned from the court.
Continued work on witchcraft, Feb- May 1693, none found guilty.

57
Q

What was the impact of the witch-hunt in Salem?

A

Serious economic impact, number of people involved in trials meant fields left unattended, farm work neglected, planting season interrupted.
Many with lands confiscated then had no home or money.
Local taxation was increased in 1693.
Hatreds and resentments arising, falsely imprisoned or friends and family executed.
Joseph Green, replaced Parris in 1696, attempted to settle this by sitting accused next to accusers at sermons.

58
Q

What did Robert Calef say about the Salem witch hunts?

A

A Boston cloth merchant, collected correspondence, court records and petitions, placing them against Mathers’ ‘Wonders of the Invisible World’, naming it ‘More Wonder of the Invisible World’, published 1700. Attack on Cotton Mather.

59
Q

What did John Hale say after the Salem witch hunts?

A

Published book ‘A Modest Enquiry into the Nature of Witchcraft’, 1697.
Expressed regret, ‘we walked in the clouds and could not see our way’.

60
Q

What did Parris say after the Salem witch hunts?

A

1694, ‘I may have been mistaken’.

61
Q

What did Cotton Mather say after the Salem witch hunts?

A

1697, in the privacy of his diary, recorded fears that God would punish his family for ‘not appearing with vigour enough to stop the proceedings’.

62
Q

What did Ann Putnam say after the Salem witch hunts?

A

1706, publicly asked for forgiveness. Said she had been fooled by the Devil.

63
Q

What did those accused do after the Salem witch hunts?

A

Petitioned to the General court, seeking:
-a declaration of the innocence of those individuals convicted.
-compensation for the families of those who had been executed.
1697, General Court declared a day of fasting and soul-searching for tragedy.
1802, declared the trials unlawful, but gave little compensation.
1703, another superstition put forward, requesting a better settlement.
1709, 22 people involved put a petition forward to the General Court, demanded a reversal of attainder and compensation for financial losses.
December 1711, £578.60 given to those affected to spread out.

64
Q
A