social influence Flashcards
(55 cards)
What is conformity?
A type of social influence, it is defined as yielding to group pressures
.
What THREE types of conformity did Kelman propose?
Internalisation
Identification
Compliance
What is internalisation?
Making the beliefs, values, attitudes and behaviour of a group, your own.
What is identification?
Temporary or short-term change of behaviour in the presence of a group.
What is compliance?
This means to follow other people’s ideas, even if you don’t agree.
WHAT IS THE TERM?
When someone conforms because they want to be right so they look to others by copying or obeying them
Informational Social Influence
What is the evidence for informational social influence?
Fein et al (2007)
What is Fein et al (2007) study?
Participants were asked to vote for a US president after they saw others voting for another candidate. Most of the P’s changed their mind, wanting to seem correct
, which implies the impact of informational social influence as a mechanism for conformity.
What is normative social influence?
When someone conforms because they want to be liked and be part of a group.
ASCH’S LINE STUDY:
How many participants were in the study?
What gender were they?
What was their nationality?
LImitations of this?
123 participants
Male
American
Lack of population validity, these results cannot be generalised to other nationalities or gender.
ASCH’S LINE STUDY:
What was the aim of the study?
To investigate conformity and majority influence.
ASCH’S LINE STUDY:
What was the procedure?
Participants and confederates were presented with 4 lines; 3 comparison lines and 1 standard line
• They asked to state which of three lines was the same length as a stimulus line
• The real participant always answered last or second to last
• Confederates would give the same incorrect answer for 12 out of 18 trials
• Asch observed how often the participant would give the same incorrect answer as the confederates versus the correct answer
ASCH’S LINE STUDY:
What did the study find?
36.8% conformed
25% never conformed
75% conformed atleast ONCE
TRUE OR FALSE?
The factors that affect the level of conformity are group size, task difficulty and unamity.
TRUE
ASCH’S LINE STUDY:
What were the strengths of the study?
High internal validity
Extraneous variables : LAB EXPERIMENT
Supports normative social influence
ASCH’S LINE STUDY:
What were the weaknessess of the study?
Lacks ecological validity
Lacks population validity
Lack of consent
Conformity to Social Rules: ZIMBARDO
Who were the participants?
24 American male undergraduate students
Conformity to Social Rules: ZIMBARDO
What was the aim of the experiment?
To investigate how readily people would conform to social roles in a simulated enviroment.
Conformity to Social Rules: ZIMBARDO
What was the procedure of the experiment?
The basement of the Stanford University psychology building was converted into a simulated prison. American student volunteers were paid to take part in the study.
They were randomly issued one of two roles; guard or prisoner.
Both prisoners and guards had to wear uniforms.
Prisoners were only referred to by their assigned number.
Guards were given props like handcuffs and sunglasses.
No one was allowed to leave the simulated prison.
The guards were allowed to control behaviour, in order to emphasise their complete power over the prisoners.
No physical violence was permitted, in line with ethical guidelines and to prevent complete overruling. The behaviour of the participants was observed.
Conformity to Social Rules: ZIMBARDO
What were the findings of the experiment?
Identification occurred very fast, as both the prisoners and guards adopted their new roles and played their part in a short amount of time.
Guards began to harass and torment prisoners in harsh and aggressive ways – they later reported to have enjoyed doing so and relished in their new-found power and control.
Prisoners would only talk about prison issues forgetting about their previous real life.
This is significant evidence to suggest that the prisoners believed that the prison was real, and were not acting simply due to demand characteristics.
They would even defend the guards when other prisoners broke the rules, reinforcing their social roles as prisoner and guard, despite it not being real.
The guards became more demanding of obedience and assertiveness towards the prisoners while the prisoners become more submissive.
This suggests that the respective social roles became increasingly internalised.
Conformity to Social Rules: ZIMBARDO
What were the strengths of the experiment?
Real life applications
Help was offered prior to the study.
Conformity to Social Rules: ZIMBARDO
What were the weaknessess of the experiment?
Lacks ecological validity
Lacks population validity
Ethical issues
EXPLANATIONS FOR OBEDIENCE:
What is the agentic state
?
This is when someone believes that someone else will take responsibility for their actions. People are more likely to conform in the agentic state as they do not believe there will be a consequence for their actions.
EXPLANATIONS FOR OBEDIENCE:
What is meant by legitimacy of authority
?
This describes how credible the figure of authority is. People are more likely to conform if they believe the figure is credible.