Specific Crimes Flashcards
(65 cards)
Common Law Homicide Actus Reus
Killing a human being
Human being
born and alive
Alive
Not brain dead
Common Law Murder Mens Rea
Malice aforethought
- express malice
- implied malice
Express Malice
Intent to kill
Implied Malice
Intent to commit serious bodily injury
- depraved heart
- felony murder
Common Law Depraved Heart
- Mens Rea: abandoned and malignant heart, wantonness, extreme indifference to the value of human life
- D must have realized that his actions created a substantial and unjustifiable risk of death (typically gross negligence)
Common Law Felony Murder
Cause someone’s death while committing another felony
- Felony = crime that can result in imprisonment of a year or more
- Generally second degree but can be first degree if the felony was a listed felony under common law
Common Law First Degree Murder
- committed by a particular means specified by statute (torture, poison, lying in wait, etc.)
- committed during another crime specified by statute (Robbery, arson, kidnapping, burglary, etc.)
- committed with premeditation and deliberation
Premeditation
Reflected in advance
- can happen in the blink of an eye
Deliberation
With a cool head
Common Law Second Degree Murder
Any type of Murder that is not first degree
Common Law Implied Malice Murder
- Malice is implied by some circumstantial factor
- Generally second degree
- Depraved Heart
Limitations to Common Law Felony Murder
- Inherently dangerous felony limitation
- Res gestae requirement
- Merger Doctrine
- Agency Rule
Inherently Dangerous Limitation to Felony Murder
Underlying felony must be inherently dangerous
- inherently dangerous: high probability that death would result
Merger Doctrine limitation to Felony Murder
Felony murder rule does not apply to assaultive felonies (involving physical violence)
Agency Rule Limitation to Felony Murder
if a third party was proximate cause of death it is not felony murder
- not the felon or one of their agents
Approaches to Inherently Dangerous Felony Limit
- Abstract Approach
- Fact Intensive Approach
Abstract Approach to Inherently Dangerous Felony Limit
Look at the elements of the felony in the abstract and ask is it one with a high probability that death will result or cannot be committed without creating a substantial risk that someone will be killed
- consider only definition of offense and scientific data
Fact Intensive Approach to Inherently Dangerous Felony Limit
Evaluate whether the felony, as carried out, was inherently dangerous
Common Law Voluntary Manslaughter
Intentional killing but mitigated by the heat of passion
Test (reasonable person test)
- D acted in the heat of passion
- D was reasonably provoked into the heat of passion
- D did not have sufficient time to cool off
- A reasonable person would not have had time to cool off
Approaches to What is Reasonable in Voluntary Manslaughter Test
- Statistical
- Normative
Statistical Approach to Reasonableness in Voluntary Manslaughter Test
- Look at how most people actually behave
- Would an average person of average disposition acted rashly and without thinking under the circumstances
- Favored
Normative Approach to Reasonableness in Voluntary Manslaughter Test
Look at how people should behave