T & E Study Cards Flashcards
(425 cards)
what is testamentary freedom?
the freedom to leave whatever you have to whoever you want. However, public policy often places limits on testamentary freedom.
what are gratuitous transfers?
The transfer of property to someone not in exchange for consideration…it is done out of the giftor’s intent for the other person to have the property.
Are transfers under a will or through a trust a form of gratuitous transfer?
Yes!
why are gratuitous transfers enforced?
we want the intent of the donor to be honored.
What is the guiding principle in estate planning? UPC 1-102(b)(2)
to effectuate the testator’s intent…this requires you to fully understand the client’s wishes when you are drafting the plan.
what are intestacy rules?
Default rules designed to approximate what the decedent would have wanted in the case that the decedent did not leave a will or left a document that failed to consider contingencies that later occurred. These rules establish who gets the entire probate estate when an individual dies without a will.
What are the takeaways from Feinberg v. Feinberg
court upheld a clause that stated that any descendant who married outside the jewish faith or whose non-jewish spouse did not convert within a year of marriage would be deemed deceased for all purposes of the instrument and that descendant’s share would revert back to the adult children of the decedents in question. Court said the statutes reveal a public policy in support of testamentary freedom and since the decedents were under no obligation to make any provision at all for their grandchildren and such grandchildren would have no greater claim under intestate the court said the decedents were free to distribute their bounty as they saw fit and favor grandchildren who made choices of which they approved. Court said they would not be allowed to convey a vested interest that was subject to divestment by a condition subsequent that tended to unreasonably restrict marriage or encourage divorce.
what are actions a disgruntled heir may take?
1) will contest
2) actions against attorney
what is a will contest
when a plaintiff may try to have all or part of an estate plan declared invalid. This usually involves issues of compliance with formalities, capacity, undue influence, fraud, duress or will interpretation. It also may involve attorney failure to draft consistent with the testator’s intent.
what actions may a disgruntled heir take against an attorney?
1) malpractice action
2) report to state bar association for disciplinary conduct contrary to MPRC
what is malpractice?
When the lawyer’s actions create a legal cause of injury that damages a person to whom the lawyer owes a duty of care, and the lawyer has no valid defense, a lawyer may be held liable for malpractice.
Who do lawyers owe a duty of care to?
generally only to their clients
Privity Bar to malpractice claims
Since third parties are not in privity to the attorney, lawyers do not have the same duty of care to them. Consequently, disappointed potential beneficiaries historically have been barred from suing the estate planning attorney for any possible malpractice committed toward the client, even if the attorney’s negligence was clear (this is because estate planning cases don’t arise until after the client is dead).
Have states relaxed or abolished the privity bar?
Yes! Numerous states have done so and have allowed a third party to sue which incentivizes lawyers to use greater care in estate planning. States have developed different approaches to the issue of when a third party can sue an attorney for malpractice. Since privity has eroded, the standard of liability is ill-defined and the specific duties are not well elucidated.
What does it mean to die testate?
it means you die with a will disposing of your property.
What does it mean to die intestate?
It means you die without a will.
can you die partially intestate/testate?
yes, this means that not all of your property is disposed of in the will so the rest of the property is disposed of through probate.
requirement of survival to inherit
whether property is distributed by intestacy or by will, the heir or beneficiary must survive the decedent in order to inherit.
Steps to implementing an intestacy statute
1) characterize the decedent’s property (community or separate? personal or real?)
2) what is the applicable law? (domicile/situs)
3) determine survivor situation & link to applicable statute
what jurisdiction’s law govern for real property…where the property is or where the person died?
Real property is governed by the jurisdiction where the real property is located. So if you own property in a state other than the state where you die, the state law of where the property is located would govern what happens to that real property.
what are the 3 types of statues that affect inheritance by family members?
1) Intestacy statutes: these govern who is entitled to inherit from a decedent who dies without a will. These typically favor close family members over more distant relatives or non-relatives.
2) Statutes of wills: these allow citizens to opt out of the default intestacy rules and draft a will. The will allows them to specify family members as well as non-family individuals or organizations as the recipients of their property upon death.
3) Rules of construction: statutes that help courts interpret wills and other instruments like trusts that transfer property gratuitously. These rules of construction favor family members over others.
What constitutes a family member for intestacy?
this is essentially a question of status…For example, in looking at who is a child, that answer depends on the child’s status as a biological or adopted child of their parent. However, there are a few behavior based exceptions like homicide, and in some states, abandonment of children or abuse of the elderly.
how are adopted children treated for purposes of intestacy?
Legally adopted children fall within the definition of child in the intestacy statutes of all states. Adopted children may inherit from and through their adoptive parents, and their adoptive parents may inherit from or through them.
What does it mean to inherit through someone?
This means that you do not inherit directly from them but have to establish a connection with them in order to inherit from someone else.