The Best is Yet To be, or Not to be? Flashcards
What are megaprojects?
Large-scale, complex projects often high-cost, involving significant investment, resources, and time, impacting the economy, environment, and society.
What is the National Broadband Network (NBN) in Australia?
A project declared ‘built and fully operational’ in December 2020, connecting over 11.86 million premises, though many still lack the minimum 25Mbps speed.
What were the initial plans for Australia’s NBN?
Initially planned as a fiber-to-the-premises (FTTP) network but shifted to a multi-technology mix approach to reduce costs.
What are some challenges faced by the NBN?
- High wholesale charges affecting retail prices
- Competition from emerging 5G networks
- Connectivity issues in remote areas
What is a significant issue with Canada’s high-speed rail?
Canada is the only G7 nation without high-speed rail, facing high costs and political inaction despite studies highlighting benefits.
What are some major barriers to high-speed rail in Canada?
- Freight-owned tracks limiting passenger train speeds
- Low population density affecting demand
- Political pressure from cities without stops
What is the ‘Iron Law’ by Bent Flyvbjerg?
Most megaprojects are over budget, over time, and 9 out of 10 face cost overruns and delays.
What are common pitfalls in megaprojects?
- Overestimation of benefits
- Underestimation of costs
- Vulnerability to economic and technological shifts
What is a psychological factor driving megaprojects?
Superlatives attract politicians, leading to continued support even during financial crises.
What alternative urban planning methods were suggested?
- Light rail expansion
- Bus service improvements
- Street reorganization
What is the Suramadu Bridge project in Indonesia?
A megaproject aimed at improving connectivity between Surabaya and Madura, opened in June 2009 after delays.
What were some community impacts of the Suramadu Bridge?
- Job creation was limited for locals
- Environmental concerns due to construction
- Unfulfilled compensation for affected fishermen
What factors influenced local perceptions of the Suramadu Bridge?
- Immaterial benefits (e.g., pride)
- Material benefits
- Specific job opportunities
What is the significance of immaterial benefits in megaprojects?
Immaterial benefits, such as pride and identity, often outweigh material benefits in shaping local perceptions.
What does the research suggest about local perceptions of megaprojects?
Understanding local perspectives is crucial for assessing the success and community satisfaction of megaprojects.
What is the relationship between megaprojects and urban identity?
Megaprojects can create a sense of pride and new identity for cities, influencing residents’ daily lives.
True or False: Most megaprojects are completed on time and within budget.
False
Fill in the blank: Megaprojects often lead to _______ due to unforeseen complications and bureaucratic inefficiencies.
cost overruns
What was a notable example of a megaproject failure?
The Bertha tunnel project in Seattle, which faced significant delays and cost overruns.
What is a consequence of political pressure in megaproject planning?
Cities left without stops may protest, complicating project designs and timelines.
What did the research on the Suramadu Bridge reveal about local sentiments?
Most respondents felt informed and recognized personal benefits despite some negative impacts.
What were the findings about public perception during different stages of megaprojects?
Perceptions often shift from optimism in planning to frustration during construction, and acceptance during usage.
What is a key takeaway regarding urban planning and megaprojects?
Smaller, well-planned alternatives are often overlooked in favor of larger megaprojects.
What is the significance of understanding local people’s perceptions in assessing megaproject impacts?
It highlights that urban identity and intangible benefits can be strongly felt despite tangible drawbacks.
This suggests that inclusive development should consider community sentiment.