Theorists Flashcards
(15 cards)
Theory of Geoffrey Beattie
Found that women and men interrupted with more or less equal frequency
Recorded 10 hours of tutorial discussions and some 557 interruptions
Theory of Jennifer Coates(1998)
Female talk is cooperative (helpful)
Argues that these patterns are not found in mixed talk- evidence of differing socio-cultural expectations
Women use more epistemic modal forms- perhaps, sort-of
Theory of Jane pilkington(1992)
Found that women all female talk were more collaborative then men in all male talk
Women aimed for more positive, politeness WHEREAS men tended to be less complementary , supportive
Strategies include juxtaposing criticism with compliments , establishing common ground
Theory of koenrad kuipe (1991)
All male talk of rugby team were likely to pay less attention to the need to save face and instead used insults as a way of expressing solidarity
Theory of Deborah tanned(1990)
Explains male-female miscommunication by claiming that male- female speech was ‘cross-cultural communication’
Prof tannen
Example of women asking permission from husband so her friend can come over, HOWEVER man does not ask for permission
Deborah tanned 2
Claims that to many men a complaint is a challenge to find a solution
Robin Lakoff(1975)
Believes female language is deficient compared to mens lang
Women’s lack real authority
Weaknesses of Lakoffs study : all American white, middle class
Lakoff knew the women , dated study, victims of domestic violence
Janet Holmes (1992)
Said tag questions function are used to help maintain discussion or to be polite
Betty Dubois ,n, Isobel crouch(1975)
Men use more tag questions then women, never said they were less confident
William o’Barr and bowman Atkins (1980)
Suggested features did occur in women’s speech, but also found that they also were found in lower class men’s speech
Found that they were more dependent on power relations then gender
Deborah Cameron
Criticised the idea that there are innate differences in male and female speech. Cameron argues: The idea that men and women use language in very different ways and for very different reasons is one of the great myths of all time
Challenges Lakoffs and Tannens research
Julia Stanley (1973)
26 nouns for promiscuous men which were approving
220 nouns for promiscuous women which were disapproving
Women exist in a negative semantic field
Hines(1994)
Discusses terms of address for women as metaphors for desserts ( sweetie, honeybun, cupcake
Geoffrey leech
A term used to refer makes is taken and a suffix is added
Actor- actress