Topic 1 - Theories of Religion Flashcards
(78 cards)
What are the 3 main ways sociologists define religion?
- Substantive
- Functional
3.Social constructionist
What do substantive definitions focus on?
Content of religious belief
How did Weber define religion?
Belief in a superior/supernatural power that is above nature and cannot be explained scientifically
How are substantive definitions ‘exclusive’?
They draw a clear line between religious and non-religious beliefs. To classify, they must have belief in a higher power or supernatural
What is the strength of a substantive definition?
Conform to a widespread view of religion as belief in God
What is the limitation of the substantive definition?
Leaves no room for beliefs/practices that perform similar functions but do not involve belie in a high power.
Accused of Western bias, exclude Buddhism
What is a functional definition of religion?
Defining it in terms of social/psychological functions it performs for society or members
How does Durkheim define religion?
In terms of the contribution it makes to social integration
What function does functionalist Yinger identify?
Answers ‘ultimate questions’ about meaning of life and after death
What are some advantages of functional definitions?
Inclusive
No Western bias
What is the limitations for functional definitions?
Integration doesn’t constitute a religion.
What kind of approach of social constructionists take?
Interpretivist
What do social constructionists argue?
Not possible to produce single universal definition to cover all cases, since different people mean very different things by religio
What are social constructionists interested in?
How definitions are constructed, challenged, fought over
Aldridge
Scientology a religion for followers, but many gov’s denied it legal status and sought to ban it
Shows definitions can be contested + influenced by those who have power to define
What do SC NOT make assumptions about?
That religion always involves a belief in a higher power, or that it performs similar functions for all people in all societies
What is an advantage of SC approach to religion definition?
Allows them to get close to meanings given by people
What is a limitation of the SC approach to religion?
Impossible to generalise about religion’s nature, since people differ on what classifies as a religion
What central role do religious institutions play? Which sociologist first developed this idea?
Creates and maintains value consensus, order and solidarity. Durkheim
What did Durkheim believe was the key feature in religion?
Fundamental distinction between sacred and profane found in all religions
What is the ‘profane’?
Things that have no special significance, ordinary, mundane.
What is the ‘sacred’?
Things set apart/forbidden, inspire feelings of the sublime and are surrounded by taboos and prohibitions
Instead of simply being a set of beliefs, what does religion also include, according to Durkheim?
Definite collective rituals/practices in relations to the sacred.
Why does Durkheim think the sacred inspires such powerful feelings in believers?
Because they are symbols presenting something of great power