Topic 7 - Lease Covenants and Requirements Flashcards
(87 cards)
What is a lease?
A lease is created when a Landlord grants the temporary right to a Tenant to use and enjoy land exclusively for a specified duration.
The lease can be in a residential or commercial context.
What is a ‘term of years absolute’?
A ‘term of years absolute’ is the technical name for a lease as defined in LPA 1925, s 205 (1)(xxvii).
What terminology can describe a lease?
- Tenancy
- Leasehold
- Sublease
- Underlease
- Lessor (for landlord)
- Lessee (for tenant)
These terms help clarify the type of lease agreement.
How is a lease different from a licence?
A lease is a proprietary right to land, whereas a licence is personal permission to be on someone’s land.
What are the key differences between leases and licences?
- Lease is enforceable against third parties
- Licence is enforceable only against the grantor
- Tenant can sue for nuisance or trespass, whereas a licensee cannot
- Lease confers security of tenure; licence does not
- Lease is enforceable in rem; licence is enforceable in personam
- Tenants have statutory protection; licensees do not.
What was the significance of Street v Mountford [1985] AC 809?
The court ruled that the substance of an agreement determines if it is a lease or licence, not the label given by the parties.
What are the essential requirements for a lease to exist?
- Certainty of term
- Exclusive possession
- Correct formalities used to create the lease.
What does ‘certainty of term’ mean?
It means the tenancy must be granted for a certain duration, allowing the arrangement’s end date to be known.
What is a fixed term lease?
A fixed term lease has a maximum duration known from the outset, and neither party can end it early unless a break clause is present.
What is a periodic tenancy?
A periodic tenancy is a lease for one period (weekly, monthly, quarterly, or yearly) that automatically extends until notice to terminate is given.
What is exclusive possession?
Exclusive possession means the right to exclude all others from the property, including the landlord.
What factors may indicate a lack of exclusive possession?
- Landlord retains a key
- Landlord provides services
- Sharing clause.
How does retaining a key affect exclusive possession?
It depends on the purpose of retaining the key; if used only in emergencies, exclusive possession may still exist.
What happens if a landlord provides services?
If the landlord provides services, it may indicate a licence rather than a tenancy.
What is the significance of sharing clauses in determining exclusive possession?
If a landlord reserves the right to introduce others, it may indicate a lack of exclusive possession, depending on the circumstances.
What is a key case that addresses exclusivity in leases?
A G Securities v Vaughan highlights how sharing arrangements can affect exclusive possession.
What did the House of Lords conclude in Antoniades v Villiers about exclusive possession?
The court ruled that the clauses in the agreements were sham and did not genuinely intend to defeat exclusive possession.
What factors determine if a sharing clause is genuine or a sham?
- The size and nature of the accommodation
- The relationship between the occupiers
- The wording of the clause
- Whether the clause has ever been exercised
Consideration of these factors helps in assessing the legitimacy of sharing clauses in tenancy agreements.
What must a business tenant show to establish tenancy rather than a license?
- A certain term
- Exclusive possession of the premises
Establishing these criteria is crucial for security of tenure under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954.
What is the significance of the case Street v Mountford [1985] AC 809?
It applies to both residential and non-residential tenancies regarding exclusive possession.
In the business context, how do courts assess the arrangement between landlord and tenant?
By construing the document as a whole to determine if the landlord retains control over the property.
What was the outcome of Esso Petroleum Co Ltd v Fumegrange Ltd [1994] 2 EGLR 90 regarding exclusive possession?
The court held that Esso’s control over the premises was inconsistent with exclusive possession being vested in Fumegrange.
If an occupation agreement allows the landlord to relocate the tenant, what does this imply?
It will not be considered a lease.
What is required for multiple occupiers to have a lease rather than a license?
They must have exclusive possession and meet the essential requirements of a lease.