UNIT 3 AOS 1 - FINAL Flashcards
The distinction between summary offences and indictable offences
A summary offence is a minor criminal offence heard in the Magistrate’s court, whereas an indictable offence is a more serious offence, heard in the County and Supreme Court of Victoria. The difference between the two is the severity of the sanctions they attract and a jury is only used in the trials for indictable offences.
Key principles of the criminal justice system
Burden of proof, standard of proof, presumption of innocence
Burden of proof:
Party which has the obligation to prove their assertion in court.
burden of proof = prosecution, the party which initiates the criminal proceedings.
Standard of proof:
Degree/strength of the evidence required by the party bringing an action to prove their case.
beyond reasonable doubt, the individual should not have any rational doubt as to the guilt of the accused after assessing the evidence.
Presumption of Innocence:
Notion that a person accused of a criminal offence is considered to be not guilty of said offence, until they are proven guilty beyond reasonable doubt in the court of law.
The rights of an accused
The right to be tried without unreasonable delay, right to silence, right to trial by jury
The right to be tried without unreasonable delay:
To ensure both prosecution and defence have sufficient time to gather evidence and prepare cases for court.
- Accused is not remanded for long
Right to silence:
Have the right to refuse to answer questions by police and to refuse to give evidence during a trial; judges cannot draw “adverse inferences” if they use the right to silence.
(Protection against self-incrimination)
Right to trial by jury
Ensures that all accused persons have the opportunity to have their case heard unbiasedly by surrounding members of the Victorian community.
The rights of victims
Right to give evidence using alternative arrangements: Use of special provisions in place to enable witnesses to give evidence
The principles of justice during a criminal case
Fairness, equality, access
Justice:
The maintenance of what is just or right by the exercise of authority of power
FAIRNESS:
“All people can participate in the justice system, and its processes should be impartial and open”
To ensure innocent people are not found guilty of crimes they did not commit
Impartial processes:
Ensures court personnel are independent and impartial
Need to ensure there is no apprehended bias which is a situation where a fair-minded person, with knowledge of the key objective facts, might reasonably believe that a judge, magistrate or jury member, might not be impartial when deciding the case
Open processes:
Those who administer justice to be held accountable for their actions, decisions, etc. (open to public)
EQUALITY:
“All people be treated equally before the law, regardless of factors such as race, gender, disability, etc. If processes creates disparity, measures can be implemented to ensure all can participate in the justice system without disadvantage (substantive equality)
- Interpreters
- Changes for cultural differences (Koori Court, eye contact prohibited)
ACCESS:
“All people regardless of socio-economic status understand their legal rights, and requires that all people understand and have the ability to pursue their case.
The role of Victoria Legal Aid (VLA) and Victorian community legal centres (CLC) in assisting an accused and victims of crime
independent statutory authority set up to provide legal aid in the most effective, economic manner.
STRENGTHS OF VLA
Free legal information on VLA’s website (court processes, accused/victim’s rights, legal principles)
Free legal assistance (duty lawyers, legal assistance) to ELIGIBLE people, prioritize the most vulnerable
Interpreters are provided (30+ languages)
WEAKNESS OF VLA
May not be enough information
Does not have unlimited resources, must apply to criteria
Ability for VLA to meet demands for services, (rely on funding)
COMMUNITY LEGAL CENTRES (CLC):
Generalist CLC’s: broad legal services for people in a particular geographical area
Specialist CLC’s: focusses on a particular group of people/area of law
Role of CLC’s:
Provide accused with legal information, legal advice, ongoing assistance in a case to understand and be aware of rights.
Types of assistance for accused + victims people: CLC
Basic legal information
Legal advice and assistance
Duty lawyers (victims)
STRENGTHS OF CLCs
Free legal information (help educate the community about court processes/rights) on CLC’s website (different languages)