Week 1

Question 1

Medical humanism

Answer 1

The central tenets of humanism are:
-the human beings matter that their wellbeing or suffering represent real phenomena
-the goal of human societies is to promote human flourishing
-science reason and understanding are a central means of achieving human flourishing
-all human beings are equally valuable
Medicine and other healthcare professions are relentlessly humanist
Our specific bent is to promote human flourishing through improving health
Modern discourse is now steeped in humanist principles:
-individualism and individual rights
-wellbeing
-equality, equity and social justice
And of course the NHS is a profoundly humanist statement that all humans regardless of wealth or status are entitled to the same healthcare, based on need alone

Question 2

Competing worldviews

Answer 2

Humanism is not the only perspective prominent in modern societies: theism, ecocentrism, collectivism
Most societies endorse ideas of social or moral worth to promote prosocial behaviour but by a pure humanist reckoning, prosocial behaviours cannot alter your value
Other ethical perspectives disagree
- eg utilitarians might argue that having dependents makes one more valuable
Most of us are relatively reluctant to completely disown ideas of relative social worth eg criminals

Question 3

Humanity

Answer 3

There is something special about humans any human is worthy of our moral concern
These ideas have been around a long time
Aristotle de anima: human soul 5+ergon use reason, sensitive soul (animals) 3 ergon move perceive desire, vegetative soul (plants) 2 ergon reproduce assimilate
Thomas aquinas: believed in a similar soul hierarchy to Aristotle
Held that humans were important as “rational animals” and on this basis they were worthy of moral concern
However this basis does not guarantee equality for humans- aquinas believed women were less rational than men and therefore subject to their authority and less important
Applying this principle more broadly what is importance of: children, those with learning disabilities, those with brain injuries preventing rational activity

Question 4

Humanism and humanity

Answer 4

Humanism (15th century onwards)
-humans are important and valuable in their own right
-human fulfillment is of importance as is working towards the good of all
-the universe is material and may be understood through science
-human flourishing and happiness should be cultivated through study and application
-human lives are assumed to be of equal value

Question 5

Humanist discourse

Answer 5

Achieved dominance in the aftermath of WW2 and the atrocities of the holocaust. The evil inherent in identifying some groups as less human and less valuable than others was unmistakable
Significant progress was made in pursuit of civil rights of ethnic minorities in most western nations in the decades that followed
Many humanist institutions were created in the aftermath- eg UN declaration of human rights (1948); ECHR (1950); the NHS (1948)
However were still a long way from a humanist world:
-rights are often tied to citizenship, the handling of refugees has become a flashpoint
-our economic system openly exploits the developing world
-misogyny is engrained and endemic with 90% of the worlds population holding prejudices against women and double standards based on sex
-disability driscrimination is still prevalent and disabled people have many barriers to the access of goods and services (ONS 2022)
-capital punishment still exists in several countries including USA, Iran, Saudi Arabia, japan, Somalia, South Sudan, and the democratic republic of Congo

Question 6

Medicine is founded on values of humanism

Answer 6

But is uniquely confronted by marginal cases
-what is life
-how do we define what is human
—genomics, consciousness, social behaviours, empathy
Are all humans equally human

Question 7

Sanctity

Answer 7

Possibly the broadest of definitions
Approach adopted by several major world relations
A deity has created humans and given them souls
Human life is therefore sacred in a way animal life is not and all human life should be protected
The nature of the soul has never been comprehensively defined and cannot be materially measured or established
Not every religion holds to this model
-paganism holds that all life is sacred not just human life
-Hinduism holds a hierarchy over animals but advocates non violence towards them, and some animals have special significance eg cattle
-Jainism will not allow violence towards animals even in self defence
-Native American belief systems hold that the soul is the source of life and thought, an immaterial essence- animating humans, animals and even plants

Question 8

Sanctity limitations

Answer 8

Many humans do not believe this and linking moral status to religious beliefs is unlikely to be appealing to those who do not
Many of the same religions that advocate sanctity of life do not advocate for equality of humans eg believers> non believers, men>women priests> laity, faithful> sinners
Such belief systems have not protected from atrocities in the past

Question 9

Moral status

Answer 9

6 grounds for moral concern:
-sanctity
-autonomy
-sentience
-personhood
-potentiality
-patient

Question 10

Autonomy (kantian theory)

Answer 10

Kant believed that what made humans unique and important was their will- the ability to act according to the law rather than impulse or desire
The only thing with any intrinsic value is a good will- a will which acts according to a moral law
Since anything without a will (ie is not autonomous) cannot have a good will it follows that it has no intrinsic value
Therefore anything which is not autonomous has no intrinsic value

Question 11

Limitations of autonomy

Answer 11

Few are the human beings who act invariably according to a moral law, and in any case moral laws can differ significantly
Many are the ways for a human being to lose autonomy, permanently or temporarily does this mean we cease to have intrinsic value
No ones will is incorruptable- coercion, threat, even torture can force a person to behave in ways they would not choose
Rationality is now believed to be an enlightenment myth- human decision making is complex and much occurs at a subconscious level

Question 12

Sentience

Answer 12

What is a sentient being
“ the capacity to experience episodes of positively or negatively valenced awareness”
The ability to feel pleasure or pain
If a being is sentient then it has direct moral status, most animals are sentient
Therefore most animals have direct moral status

Question 13

Limitations of sentience

Answer 13

Most people accept that animals are sentient
But not all to the same degree eg pescetarians
Sentience is not the easiest thing to gauge
Few people would accept equal moral status for animals and humans regardless of the capacity for pleasure and pain
Concepts of sentience change with time they are cultural
Up until 1987 doctors didn’t believe newborns felt pain

Question 14

Personhood (or sapience)

Answer 14

It is being a person rather than being human that gives us moral worth
Related consciousness
Being a person is not just a biological matter
-ability to have certain continuous mental states- a prevailing consciousness, memories, a narrative of self and identity, desires for the future, rational thoughts etc
-if continuous mental states are no longer possible personhood can be lost

Question 15

Limitations personhood (or sapience)

Answer 15

This is a very high bar for achieving moral concern- most childhood development experts think personhood isn’t developed until around 2
On the other hand some other mammals display at least some signs of personhood- elephants remember events and individuals for prolonged periods of time and mourn death
Personhood is also difficult to evaluate especially in those with communication difficulties
The philosopher peter singer argued that there is no quality that makes humans uniquely deserving of moral concern distinct from animals
-any quality you might identify to distinguish them will not be held by all humans (marginal cases)
-any quality that does cover all humans will also cover some animals

Question 16

Personhood anthropologists

Answer 16

Anthropologists have pointed out that in societies where animals were not domesticated (farmed for meat or milk), animals are almost invariably considered to have spiritual worth, personalities and even intellect
Some have proposed that the denial of personhood to animals may be strategy to lessen the cognitive dissonance from the fact we are keeping them in conditions they would not choose and exploiting them
There are parallels with historical oppression of groups of humans who have been termed lesser in order to justify their control and exploitation

Question 17

Potentiality

Answer 17

A being can be worthy of moral concern even if it has no qualities that would make it worthy of concern at the moment- if it might achieve those qualities in the future
Eg not currently sentient but might become so, does not currently have personhood but might
This has some attractions eg young children would have the same quotient of moral concern as everyone else

Question 18

Potentiality limitations

Answer 18

But what about those who can expect no improvement in their condition does that mean we should be less concerned about them
What about those whose prognosis is to deteriorate
What role does the probability of attaining this status have in this approach
Almost everything would have some potential given long enough a lump of carbon could be sentient

Question 19

Patient

Answer 19

A specifically medical model
-all patients are of moral concern to clinicians
-the status of patient grants full moral concern
-this is the basis of our professionals duties and obligations

Question 20

Limitations patient

Answer 20

We cannot really believe that only people who are directly under our care are worthy of moral concern, so this is really a means of defining the scope of our professional responsibility rather than answering the question
At first glance offers little insight into cases where medics withdraw or withhold care

Question 21

Where does that leave us moral concern

Answer 21

Moral concern is not something that has to be digital- its not the case that we either have concern or we dont
The most effective way of looking at moral status is to consider the various claims an individual has to our concern
Eg we might have some moral concern for being with only potentiality as a claim on our concern but not as much as we might for a being with full sentience and personhood
The loss of personhood is an area of particular relevance for doctors

Question 22

Utilitarian approach

Answer 22

Would consider how to avoid the most possible suffering
How many dependents they have who’s loss leads to the most suffering

Question 23

Deontologists

Answer 23

Duty to save life equal duty to both
However if you’re a follower of Kant you might believe that your duty depends on whether they have a good will

Question 24

Rawlsian fairness

Answer 24

How old are you, what disadvantages have you had in life
Rawlsian fairness involves the equal distribution of privileges and burdens. A Rawlsian approach believes that inequalities should be rectified in the interests of fairness
Life buoy is a major privilege so want to give to person who so far had the least advantages in life. Might be in terms of their social status but also the years of life they have had the opportunity to experience

Question 25

Care ethics life buoy

Answer 25

Can you swim Care ethics orients around need- who needs this life buoy the most, in a storm swimming might not be such a advantage but can argue a non swimmer needs ring more

Question 26

Life buoy clinician

Answer 26

Do you have any preexsiting health conditions Clinicians in a context of limited resource tend to put those resources where they can do the most good A clinician would probably want to save the individual with the best odds of long term survival or at least a high quality of life

Question 27

Concepts of death

Answer 27

For the purposes of medicine death occurs when cardio-pulmonary arrest is irreversible A legally accepted definition is given by the academy of royal colleges: -the irreversible loss of the capacity for consciousness, combined with irreversible loss of the capacity to breathe… and therefore irreversible cessation of the integrative function of the brainstem In most cases death is clear cut. However there are some grey areas/important concepts to define: -brain stem death -permanent vegetative states -minimally conscious states

Question 28

Brain stem death

Answer 28

Academy of medical royal colleges working party: the irreversible loss of the capacity for gaining consciousness and the capacity to spontaneously breathe Following a brain injury leading to brain stem death, brain stem functions will not spontaneously occur unless supported by artificial means (eg mechanical ventilation), including; -breathing -temperature control -brain function -fluid balance The heart will keep beating for a time after but eventually will cease due to increasing physiologic derangement even with ventilation This is biological death legally even though the heart can continue beating for some time. Time of death is recorded as the time of conformation of brain stem death Organ donation is possible after brain stem death The legal status of brain stem death was challenged in 2015 The judge in the case confirmed the status of brain stem death as legal death “Brainstem death does not equate to the death of the whole brain. There are studies that demonstrate that you can have electrical activity in some areas of the brain after brainstem death is established the key point is that not patient has ever regained consciousness or awareness”

Question 29

Permanent vegetative state

Answer 29

Brian stem remains functional but mid brain and cortex are non functional Loss of all higher mental functions but basic biological functions remain “A clinical condition of wakefulness without awareness” Only reflexive motor activity, no purposeful response to stimuli If this lasts more than 4 weeks it is termed ‘continuous vegetative state’ if it lasts more than 6 months (from a non traumatic cause) or more than 12 months (from a traumatic cause) it is termed a permanent vegetative state Chance of recovery after this timeframe is almost zero- although there are isolated cases of partial recovery This is biological death- death of personhood there is no possibility of continuous mental states/consciousness Once the diagnosis is established withdrawal of nutritional support is often considered

Question 30

Minimally conscious states

Answer 30

A condition of severely altered consciousness in which minimal but definite behavioural evidence of self or environmental awareness is demonstrated More continuous improvement and significantly more favourable outcomes post injury when compared with vegetative state

Question 31

NHS principles

Answer 31

Free at the point of delivery Comprehensive service available to all Funded mainly through taxation

Question 32

NHS patient pathway

Answer 32

Social care—> patient<— social determinants of health —> clinician (provider: hospital/GP) Doctor patient not a usual exchange relationship compared to buying food or shoes etc

Question 33

NHS in England flow of money (mainly public, some private)

Answer 33

Public/patients—> taxation—> government Public—insurance premiums—> 3rd parties: CCGs (ICSs) and insurance Government—resource allocation—> 3rd parties: CCGs and insurance 3rd parties—funding—>providers—services—> public/patients

Question 34

NHS England flow of money

Answer 34

Government/ dept of health and social care -integrated care systems board —NHS trust 1 —NHS trust 2 —independent hospital Primary care different funding flow

Question 35

General tax England

Answer 35

High equity progressive tax Low transparency Low choice Macro efficiency: global; budget, cost control Micro efficiency: low running costs

Question 36

Social insurance Germany

Answer 36

Equity medium/high, near universal Medium transparency, hypothecation Medium choice: choice between providers, not insurers Macro efficiency: demand led or global budgets Micro efficiency: high running costs. Tax on work?

Question 37

Market America

Answer 37

Weak equity, risk based High transparency: payment and benefit linked High choice Macro efficiency: demand led, poor cost control Micro efficiency: high running costs, tax on work?

Question 38

Should patients be charged to see GP

Answer 38

Patients in most need are least able to pay. Key plank of NHS= universal health care Affluent patients may demand more (time/visits)- charge/fee makes healthcare a commodity Deters patients from seeing GP- late presentation, higher costs Admin costs of charging scheme: ironic as common complaint of NHS, chasing defaulters Charging £20 per visit only makes 4.8% NHS budget not helpful Major impact on health inequalities. NHS-social solidarity of universal service

Question 39

Is the NHS being privatised

Answer 39

Some aspects of NHS care involve the “private” sector GPs=independent contractors Pharmaceuticals NHS pay beds and private/independent sector treating NHS patients Debate about what privatisation means no consensus Privatisation debate linked to NHS internal market/commissioning, intrusion of private capital Eg: -mental health services -private finance initiative PFI -commercial income

Question 40

Can the NHS survive this 2023-24 crisis

Answer 40

NHS has been called a “burning platform” Richard’s 2017 NHS model might still be relevant- free at delivery, tax funded but organisation of care needs updating Hence new models of care are required kings fund etc: -better use of IT (digital first primary care) -virtual wards/hospital at home -better health and social care integration: risk stratification External and internal challenges

Question 41

External challenges

Answer 41

Need more attention to improving population health -health care accounts contributes 15-20% to health -poor population health ~ poor outcomes from NHS care

Question 42

Internal challenges

Answer 42

Workforce: Strong research evidence about the human resource management and patient outcomes: -appraisal systems= strongest association with lower patient mortality -higher % of staff working in teams within a hospital the lower the patient mortality Strategies: WHO 2006 -respond to need -prepare the workforce -making the most of existing workers -managing exits from the workforce ABC: autonomy, belonging, control

Question 43

Why are there too many mangers

Answer 43

NHS management only introduced in the 1980s NHS is complex, high risk organsiation NHS has low admin costs by international comparisons Paradox calls for better management to behave more like private sector, yet salaries and staffing not equivalent Key trend: clinical staff take on managerial roles: -eg medical director, clinical director, clinical services manager etc -evidence: hospitals with medical CEOs perform better -leadership no longer seen as betrayal of medicine, faculty of medical leadership and management NHS could be considered under managed

Question 44

We already spend too much on NHS

Answer 44

Criticism: NHS is a “bottomless pit” UK spend 12% of national income on health NHS spending reliant on economy Surprising if NHS spending had not increased due to inflation, population growth and COVID Governments have increased NHS budget but not enough 4% health care inflation ~2% ageing population; 2% technology

Question 45

Is more NHS spending the answer

Answer 45

Three policy solutions: -increase taxes to maintain level of spending needed to keep current level of NHS care -reduce spending on other services such as education and welfare to maintain level of spending needed to keep current levels of NHS care -reduce level of care and services provided by NHS