Walk into any designated study space — libraries, study halls, reading rooms — and you’ll find that they all have something in common: silence. Nice, quiet spaces are supposed to better facilitate studying… right?
Turns out, that’s not necessarily the case.
In reality, people hotly contest this assertion. Some people say music improves studying. Others like places like cafes with neutral ambient noise. However, there are always some people who look for silence when choosing a study location. So what’s the truth? Does quiet or “distracting” noise help you study better?
What is the Ideal Noise Level for Studying?
The Effect of Noise on the Brain While Studying
Many studies have been done to explore the relationship between what we’re listening to and our productivity. The most popular question involves music: is it helpful or hurtful while studying? The answer to that question isn’t crystal clear either.
On the one hand, music has been shown to improve both the quality and quantity of work output, especially when performing complex tasks. On the other hand, more recent studies have shown that music can sometimes have a negative effect on studying. Specifically, listening to music can impair your memorization skills, something you definitely want to avoid while cramming for a big test.
It seems that at this point, science can’t conclusively tell us whether or not listening to music helps us study better, although most people seem to agree that music with vocals is more distracting than instrumental music.
Other Types of Noise
What about other noises, though? According to some studies, silence really is golden when tackling the most difficult tasks. When learning or analyzing highly complicated material, our brains process information significantly more quickly without ambient noise. The extra brainpower required to interpret the noise input increases the amount of processing that your already overloaded brain has to deal with. When the ambient noise is particularly loud or grating during difficult tasks, it can even have a negative impact on your health, quickly raising your blood pressure and stress levels.
Still, noise can have its benefits. When doing routine or moderately difficult studying, low chatter and noise (such as the ambient noise at a coffee shop or in the student center) can actually help your brain filter material and spot the most important information more easily. When using tools for adaptive flashcards (like the ones designed by Brainscape), such noise may even allow you to remember each individual piece of information better. Even more interestingly, a moderate level of ambient noise actually is ideal for creative thinking. Apparently, moderate noise increases processing difficulty, which in turn promotes abstract processing. In other words, the extra work our brain has to do while processing a problem or task in a relatively noisy environment gives us the extra push we need to find more creative solutions.
Matching the Noise Level to the Task
Perhaps the question shouldn’t be, “Is noise good while studying?” but rather “How much noise is ideal when completing this particular task?”
When you are feeling overwhelmed by the workload, added stimuli of noise may not be ideal. When you need an extra boost of creativity, music or background noise may help. If you are getting bored by what you are studying, it’s a much more personal decision. Noise may be the filter you need to focus or just one more distraction holding you back.
It’s important to remember that music or people may simply be a helpful placebo to get you working well. If you really enjoy the music or the atmosphere of your favorite coffee shop, you are getting a boost in confidence and well-being, which ultimately have the most significant effect on your performance.
In the end, the ideal noise level depends on the situation, and on your preferences. While too much noise is always going to overload your system and impair studying, how much noise you need while studying is a fairly personal choice. If you like the noise, embrace it. If not, find yourself a nice quiet corner. Just remember, though, there are a lot of factors that will play into whether or not it helps you study better.
How much noise do you like while studying? Let us know in the comments!
Brainscape is a web & mobile education platform that
helps you learn anything faster, using cognitive science. Join the
millions of students, teachers, language learners, test-takers, and
corporate trainees who are doubling their learning results. Visit
brainscape.com or find us on the App Store