4C Equality, equity and policy Flashcards
What is social justice?
the term social, justice embodies a notion of fairness that extends beyond individual rights to achieve a just society
Give examples of:
Need that is normative and felt but not expressed
conditions with stigma
Give examples of:
Need that is expressed and normative but not felt
screening, immunisations
Give examples of:
Need that is felt and expressed but not normative
GP appointment for common cold
Consultation for cosmetic surgery
How might need for healthcare be defined
- bradshaws normative need is sometimes described as ‘need for healthcare’
Culyer and wagstaff defined need for healthcare as a need which is equal to a persons capacity to benefit (ie need for healthcare only exists if their is an effective treatment)
Bradshaws needs: what is comparative need?
- AKA relative need
- this is need identified by comparing the services of one group of individuals compared with the services received by a similar group
- comparators may be neighbouring boroughs or countries
MEASURES: deprival measures may be helpful in indicating need for health (nut not necessarily need for healthcare)
Bradhaws needs: what is normative need?
- AKA demand for healthcare
- Normative need is need as assessed by an expert
- a professionals opinion as to whether a person has a normative need is dependent on severalr factors (symptoms, whether an effective treatment exists, whether that treatment is available, whether the patient is suitable for the treatment)
- normative need therefore often depends on the state of health systems and the availability of technology
MEASURMENT: needs assessment
Bradshaws needs: what is expressed need?
- AKA Demand
- expressed need is felt need turned into action
- when a person seeks healthcare for a felt need
MEASUREMENT: can be measured using waiting lists as a proxy
Bradshaws need: What is felt need
- AKA demand
- relates to an individuals subjective experience of need
- felt need does not necessarily translate to expressed need ie someone may have a headache but not seek healthcare
MEASUREMENT: suverys
what are bradshaws 4 types of need?
- Felt need
- expressed need
- normative need
- comparative need
Who defined 5 major theories around social justice and what are they?
- Kay and Just
- DRRIP
- DISTRIBUTIVE JUSTICE
means of ensuring fair distribution of goods - RETRIBUTIVE JUSTICE
how society punishes acts of injustice - RESTORATIVE JUSTICE
bringing together of victims and perpetrators of injustice to restore justice after a harm has taken place - INTERACTIONAL JUSTICE
fairness in how people interact with each other - PROCEDURAL JUSTICE
fairness in the way decisions or agreements are made
Social justice: distributive justice, what is it and list 3 different ways it can be interpreted
- focuses on means of ensuring fairness of distribution of goods
- term that is sometimes used synomonously with social justice
- fair distribution can be interpreted in different ways:
- UTILITARIANISM
- JUSTICE AS FAIRNESS (AKA RAWLSIANISM)
- MAXIMSING INDIVIDUAL CAPABITILITIES
Distributive justice: what is utilitarianism
- societies should make decisions that achieve the GREATEST GOOD FOR THE GREATEST NUMBER
- benefits should be redistributed form the rich to the poor (additional benefits to the poor may achieve greater good that additional benefits to the rich)
-there should be equal allocation of benefits to all - however it risks marginalising and disadvantaging vulnerable and minority groups
- an example of this application is housing people with serious mental illness in institutions for the ‘greater good of society’
Distributive justice: what is justice as fairness
- proposed by rawls
- 2 key principles of achieving a fair society
- BASIC LIEBRTIES ARE A LEGAL RIGHT FOR EVERYONE (restricting the individual liberties of some members of society is not justified even if it could lead to the greater good of society)
- DIFFERENCE PRINCIPLE (resources do not need to be distributed equally, they should be allocated so the benefits for the poorest are maximised)
- Rawls also proposed a model for societal decision making termed ‘THE VEIL OF IGNORANCE’
- No one knows where they will end up on the social spectrum and policy makers should consider society form the perspective of all members including the most advantaged and disadvantaged
Distributive justice: what is maximising individual capabilities
- built on Rawls proposal with a focus on making society less unjust (rather than trying to obtain perfect justness which is unlikely)
- a persons individual capabilities should the primary method of achieving optimal wellbeing as opposed to focusing on the possession of goods
Social justice: what is procedural justice
- whereas distributive justice focusses on outcomes, procedural justice focuses on fairness in how those outcomes are achieved
- useful when it is not possible to know the outcomes of a policy
social justice: what factors are important for procedural justice
- Thibaut and Walker argued the most important requirement for procedural justice was VOICE (ie the opportunity for communities and individuals to express views about a decision)
- 6 other criteria proposed for procedural justice are (ACE CAN)
A- be based on ACCURATE information
C- Be CONSISTANT
E- be made ETHICALLY
C- have the potential to be CORRECTED
A- take account of ALL PARTIES
N- be neutral (ie not be biased by preconceptions or self interest)
why is rationing necessary in healthcare
- in health care resources will always be scarce (ie resources will be finite)
- however demand for healthcare is potentially infinite so rationing will be necessary
- a system of decision making is therefore needed to decide which services to provide and which to not
what is explicit rationing
- rationing which uses transparent, consistent criteria to make entitlement decisions about who gets care and who does not
- ie NICE health technology assessments or IVF criteria
What is implicit rationing?
rationing done behind the scenes without clear criteria
ie GP receptionist deciding whether to allocate urgent GP appointment or not
Rationing decisions at different levels: macro (give an example and advantages and disadvantages of rationing at this level)
- national level rationing
- government or state level
- eg NICE ‘do not do’ guidance which specifies procedures which have little or no clinical effectiveness
- Advantages: avoids unnecessary duplication of work locally
- disadvantages: no scope for local decision making
Rationing decisions at different levels: meso (give an example and advantages and disadvantages of rationing at this level)
- organisational level ie hospital
-eg. referral review boards to reduce unnecessary hospital use - advantages: can respond to local circumstances
- disadvantages: risk of unnecessary duplication of work if similar reviews are happening at other hospitals
Rationing decisions at different levels: micro (give an example and advantages and disadvantages of rationing at this level)
- rationing at the level of the individual clinician (ie frequency and duration of consultations, intensity and scope of interventions offered)
- advantages: can respond to individual circumstances
- disadvantages: vulnerable to inconsistencies. little accountability in decision making
How does procedural justice effect rationing?
- rationing decisions are influenced by the views and experiences of decision makers. For this reasons the VOICE of stakeholders is massively important in the decision making process
What 3 criteria do rationing decisions in healthcare normally take into account?
1 NEED
- need can be considered on 2 levels
individual capacity to benefit (ie do not given treatments that individuals will not benefit from)
Society (ie a society with a high birth rate may have greater rationing of IVF than one with a low birth rate)
- COST EFFECTIVENESS
ie NICE usually considers treatments about a threshold cost per QALY as not being cost effective - FAIRNESS
-people in similar circumstances should have similar access to care (ie no postcode lottery)
- the process of allocating resources should also be fair (should follow principles of procedural justice)
define equity in 1 word
Fairness
Define equality in 3 words
same for all
Define efficiency
Greatest benefit achievable for a given resource
Definitions of efficiency generally relate to a utilitarian philosophical position- achieving the greatest aggregated goods across the the greatest number in the whole community
define efficiency in healthcare
- achieving the greatest improvements in wellbeing from the available resources
what is pareto optimal
- economists describe the ultimate state of efficiency as being pareto optimal
-a system is pareto optimal when no further improvements can be made in one part of the system without disadvantaging another part
what is vertical equity in healthcare
unequal healthcare for unequal need
what is horizontal equity in healthcare
equal health care for equal need
describe how equity and efficiency can be in conflict
- for an intervention to be efficient it should achieve the greatest net health cains for a given budget
- for an intervention to be equitable it should be fairly distributed within the population (this may not be equal distribution)
- an efficient intervention may risk widening gaps in health outcomes between groups in society as some groups may require a lot more resource to achieve small health gains
- what is efficient may not be equitable
describe how equity and efficiency can align
- some people argue that equity and efficiency are mutually exclusive
- considering externalities can help them align
- externalities are by-products of the production/consumption of goods which are enjoyed by society in general
- equitable care can provide externalities which improve the wellbeing of society and make the intervention more efficient
ie targeting groups with low vaccination rates can take a lot more resource but society benefits from herd immunity
when did the concepts of ‘patients as consumers’ and ‘healthcare as a product’ emerge?
- the biomedical model of healthcare traditionally had connotations of patients being passive recipients of care
- in the 1980s the concepts of ‘patients as consumers’ and ‘health care as a product’ were set out