2. YEAR 2 EXTRAS FROM BLOCK LEARNING OUTCOMES Flashcards
why is there a rising demand for healthcare?
due to the ageing population and elderly people being more at risk of more serious acute threats to health but also have more difficulty recovering from what younger people would regard as minor injuries
If a condition is incurable, should we offer the treatment to someone else?
just become a condition isnt curable doesnt mean it is untreatable.
Its important to stop viewing cure as the criterion of benefit and instead think about people’s health related QOL
what is macro level resource allocation?
Macroallocation decisions are made in government and policy arenas to allocate resources among competing needs
what is microlevel resource allocation?
decisions made about a particular patient or clinician
argue some reasons why age should be relevant to resource allocation decision making?
treatment and the care of older people is very costly
older people have lived a full life already unlike younger people
older people have been paying their taxes to finance the healthcare system all their life
older people are likely to be less responsive to treatment
a younger person will have a longer ‘rest of life’ than older people
argue some reasons why age should not be relevant to resource allocation decision making?
Just because older people have paid taxes does not make the NHS a savings club for healthcare - the NHS is part of a social insurance team
the costly bit is not the age but the end of life treatment
some elderly people will have suffered a lifetime of pain and disability so will not have had a ‘fair innings’
palliative care can be more expensive than therapeutic care
even though older people will have a shorter ‘rest of life’, you could argue that as you have less years left, each year of life becomes more precious
age along is not a good predictor of prognosis and decisions should be made based on biological not chronological age
making treatment decisions on the basis of age is discrimination which is against the law
what is the fair innings argument?
older people have has a full life already and younger people have not so its much fairer to divert resources from older to younger patients.
what did the Equality Act 2010 say?
protection must be offered for age, sex, race, gender reassignment status, disability, sexual orientation, marriage status and pregnancy
the relevance: it banned age discrimination against adults in the provision of services and public functions
what is direct age discrimination?
when a direct difference in treatment based on age cannot be justified. Is/was/could be treated in an infavourable way because of age
what is indirect age discrimination?
when a seemingly neutral provision/measure/practice has harmful repercussions on a person or group of persons
outline how you could argue that medical practice is age discriminating?
Doctors can withhold treatment that is likely to do more harm than good. The prevalence of impairments increases with age so older people are more likely to be excluded than younger people.
Nevertheless, wide individual variation exists in aging and many people in later life function physiologically within the normal range for people much younger.
what are the arguments for the use of QUALYs?
they provide the net benefit as they adress the primary purpose of healthcare which is about maximising healthcare - utilitarian theory
patients often say quantity and quality of life is what matters most
they are used widely by NICE
what are the arguments against the use of QUALYs?
• Measurements of output in units based on life years puts different values on individuals according to their life ecpectancy and thus citizens are no longer equal and older people are particularly disadvantaged
• It assumes that the value of life is determined by its length but the only person who can put a true value on life, is the person living it.
- They presume that given the choice a patient would prefer a shorter healthier life to a longer period of survival in a state of severe discomfort.
- Double jeopardy objection - those patients with pre-existing medical conditions will be treated much worse as it will reduce their overall quality of life
what are some relative measures of risk?
risk ratios and odds ratios (chances compared to another group)
what are some absolute measures of risk?
risks, odds, risk differences (the actual chances)
what did Benjamin Franklin say?
nothing can be certain except for death, taxes and scarcity of resources
what causes the scarcity in healthcare?
NHS budgetary restrictions
public expectations
ageing population = increasing demand
staffing levels
what is distributive justice?
distributing resources in a way that is fair and just
what is health economics?
the study of how society uses and allocates its limited resources to produce, distribute and consume health and healthcare
what is clinical and cost effectiveness?
when deciding a treatment it must permit the greatest health gain for the patient at the lowest cost possible
what is utilitarianisms view of rationing healthcare resources?
aims to maximise overall benefits at a societal lovel e.g. QUALYs
what is egalitarianisms view of rationing healthcare resources?
emphasises the equal moral status of individuals by trying to provide equal opportunity to have the basic goods in life e.g. using a lottery
what is prioritarianisms view of rationing healthcare resources?
attempts to help those considered worst off
what is the problem with utilitarianisms view of rationing healthcare resources?
there are unanswered questions on how best to quantify the QOL