Attachment Flashcards
What is the definition for attachment
A two way, enduring, emotional bond to a specific person
What is reciprocity
This means two way, or something that is mutual. Infant and caregiver are both active contributors in the interaction and are responding to each other.
What is interactional synchrony
This means a simultaneous action or occurrence. The infant and caregiver’s behaviours and emotions are synchronised because they are moving in the same, or similar, pattern
Evidence supporting reciprocity and interactional synchrony
Isabella et al
Observed 30 mothers and infants together in their homes during the first year and assessed the degree of synchrony. They found that mothers and infants who had more interactional synchrony were significantly more likely to be securely-attached.
Reciprocity and interactional synchrony
Evaluation
Strengths
- Practical application, Musical therapists who have worked with parents and infants who have experienced disruption in their attachment formation have recognised the importance of reciprocity and interactional synchrony.
Reciprocity and interactional synchrony
Evaluation
Limitations x2
- difficulty interpreting what is taking place from the infant’s perception. The observations don’t tell us their purpose.
- The fact interactional synchrony is not found in all cultures weakens support for the idea that it is necessary for attachment formation.
Stages of attachment by Schaffer
Stage 1
Pre-attachment stage - Birth to 3 months
From 6 weeks, infants become attracted to humans rather than objects. This is shown through smiling at people’s faces.
Stages of attachment by Schaffer
Stage 2
Indiscriminate attachment stage - 3 to 7/8 months
Infants discriminate between familiar and unfamiliar people. they smile more at known people, but still allow strangers to handle them
Stages of attachment by Schaffer
Stage 3
Discriminate attachment stage - 7/8 months onwards
Infants develop specific attachments, stay close to particular people and become distressed when they are separated. Avoid unfamiliar people and protest if strangers handle them
Stages of attachment by Schaffer
Stage 4
Multiple attachment stage - 9 months onwards
Infants form strong emotional ties with other major caregivers like grandparents. the fear of strangers weakens.
Fathers as playmates
X2
- Hardy reported that fathers are less able than mothers to detect low levels of infant distress
- Geiger found that fathers play interactions are more excitable and pleasurable than mothers while mothers are more nurturing
Fathers as caregivers
- Lamb found that fathers who become main care providers seem able to develop greater sensitivity to children’s needs
How does the amount of sensitivity shown by fathers influence attachments?
the more sensitive the father is to the infant’s needs, the more secure the father-infant attachment
Single-parent fathers’ attachments with their children are most influenced by what?
Found to be similar to the attachments the fathers had with their parents. this was not found in married fathers
Married fathers’ attachments with their children are strongly influenced by what two factors?
higher levels of marital intimacy and more supportive co-parenting have both been linked to more secure attachments between married fathers and their infants
Fathers play a role in children’s healthy psychological development
x3
- Children with secure attachments to their fathers have better relationships with peers and less problem behaviours
- Children who grow up without fathers often perform less well in school and higher levels of aggression especially boys
- Supportive fathers provide mothers much needed time away from childcare. this can help reduce stress in mothers
research into the development of attachment
Procedure
Schaffer and Emerson 60 new-borns and their mothers from working-class Glasgow. This is a longitudinal study which is carried out over a long period of time, often several years. Participants were studied in their homes, each month for the first year of their lives and again at 18 months
research into the development of attachment
What two research methods were used?
What two ways was attachment measured?
1- Naturalistic observation and self report
2- Separation protest and stranger anxiety
research into the development of attachment
Findings
x5
- separation protest was first shown at 6-8 months and stranger anxiety one month later
- strongly attached infants had caregivers who were quicker to respond and interacted with the infants more
- at 18 months, 87% of infants had at least two attachments and 31% had 5 or more
- Attachments to different adults were of similar quality
- for 39% of the infants, the attachment that they formed first was not to the main caregiver
research into the development of attachment
Conclusion
x3
- there is a pattern of attachment formation common to all infants, which suggests the process is biologically controlled
- attachments are more easily made with those who display sensitive responsiveness, recognising and responding to an infants needs
- Multiple attachments are the norm and of similar quality which contradicts Bowlby’s idea that attachments are a hierarchy of one prime attachment.
research into the development of attachment
Strength and weakness of naturalistic observation
Strength - ecological validity
weakness - Lack of control
research into the development of attachment
Strength and weakness of overt observation
Strength - More ethical
weakness - demand characteristics
1 Animal studies of attachment
Procedure
Lorenz
newly hatched birds imprint on the first large moving object. Lorenz divided a group of gosling eggs into two. One group was left with the mother, the other was kept in an incubator and Lorenz made sure that he was the first large moving object they saw.
1 Findings for the animal study x4
- The control group followed the mother goose and the other group followed Lorenz.
- Occurred within a few hours of hatching
- If they weren’t exposed with 25hours they would struggle to imprint
- Imprinting has long term effects on their behaviour
1 Conclusion/ evaluation for the animal study
- It is biological
- They are a different animal to humans so its hard to generalise
- Ducklings were able to imprint within 5 days,
2 Animal studies of attachment
Procedure x4
Harlow
1- Wire mother with milk and cloth mother without milk
2- Wire mother without milk and cloth mother with milk
3- Wire mother with milk
4- Cloth mother with milk
2 Findings for the animal study x3
- Spent 17 hours a day on the cloth mother
- Spent less than 1 hour on the wire mother
- When stressed and scared the monkey went to the cloth mother
2 Conclusion for the animal study
- contact comfort is associated with lower levels of stress and willingness to explore and so it is assumed that contact comfort provides emotional security. Emotional security more than food
Evaluation for animal study 2
- It is difficult to generalise and the results may be hard to apply to humans.
- They weren’t good mothers when they grew up as they chewed their babies fingers
- Monkeys would harm themselves
- Female monkeys were raped because they couldn’t form relationships
Explanations of attachment
Nurture + Strength 1
- Learning theory (Classical conditioning)
- the theory suggests that attachment behaviours are learnt through the association of the mother with food.
Strength - babies are fed about 2000 times generally by their main caregiver, so it would seem likely that an association would be formed between the carer and food.
Explanations of attachment
Nurture 2
- Learning theory (Operant conditioning)
- Positive and negative reinforcement.
Explanations of attachment
Operant conditioning x5
- Dollard and Miller
- Suggests hunger is unpleasant for the infant.
- The mother responds by feeding the child which removes the discomfort
- Therefore, for the infant, being with the caregiver is associated with the removal of discomfort.
- This is negative reinforcement
Explanations of attachment
Learning Theory
Evaluation
Limitation x2
- Schaffer and Emerson found that 39% of infants, the attachment they formed first was not with the main caregiver.
- Fox found that in cultures such as Israeli where feeding of infants is carried out by full-time carers whilst mothers could work. Children were more attached to their mothers than the carers
Explanations of attachment
Nature x5
- Bowlby’s monotropic theory
- Believed that attachment behaviour is innate
- Suggests instinctive behaviours such as smiling, crying, clinging and crawling help encourage attachments.
- A critical period of 2 1/2 years
- Suggested that for short term its for survival
Explanations of attachment
evaluation for Nature
Strengths x4
- Lorenz
- Innate - imprinting is immediate after hatching and irreversible
- Critical period - 25 hours
- Monotropy - One imprint was made