Abnormal behaviour Flashcards
(247 cards)
Provide an overview on how mental illness was diagnosed and treated until now
• Mental illness was defined as madness or insanity
o Defined by gross distortion of external reality (hallucinations, delusions), or disorganisation of speech, affect, behaviour (confusion, memory loss, etc.)
o Similar to today’s diagnoses of psychosis, schizophrenia and dementia
• 18-19th centuries:
o Small number of patients treated in mental asylums (mental hospitals) by mad doctors or alienists
Anyone interested/able to treat disorders: no qualifications required
o Anxiety, sadness, angst, etc. not ‘mental illness’
o Priests, friends, family assisted with problems of living
• Today, 400+ categories of mental disorder
• Definitions defined by social influences and norms
What are the two handbooks currently being used today, who were they published by and where are they mainly used?
o Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (DSM-5)
Used in Australia and the US and published by APA
o International Classification of Diseases (ICD-10; ICD-11 in preview in 2022)
Published by world health organisation but used in Australia
How many Australians are identified to have a mild, moderate or severe mental disorder?
4 million
What are the DSM and ICD and which professionals do they help?
o Two publications contain descriptions of various mental disorders and reflect the consensus of mental health professions regarding the definition and classification of mental disorders at the time of their publication
o DSM and ICD describe symptoms clusters syndromes
E.g. Schizophrenia, major depression…
• Treated by psychiatrist, psychologists, clinical psychologists, social workers, counsellors
What is the DSM’s definition of a mental illness?
o A mental disorder is a syndrome characterized by clinically significant disturbance in an individual’s cognition, emotion regulation, or behaviour that reflects a dysfunction in the psychological, biological or developmental processes underlying mental functioning. Mental disorders are usually associated with significant stress or disability in social, occupational or other important activities
Is it easy to define mental disorder? Why/why not?
• But no definition of mental disorders is enough- hard to define as influenced by societal norms
What are the advantages of mental disorder diagnoses?
- Improve communication between health professionals (clinicians and researchers)
- May improve communication and understanding of mental illness in the community
- May reduce social stigma
- Helpful to the client-> normalising and validating
What are the disadvantages of mental disorder diagnoses?
o Mental disorders are being treated like physical afflictions, but mental illnesses are simply theoretical constructs and are not independent of changing social values
o Used as explanations rather than descriptive terms
o May sometimes be harmful to people- feel as if they have been stigmatised
Are ICD and DSM the same? Describe differences if there are any
No-• ICD and the DSM are comparable but not identical
o Problem as diagnosed differently according to where you live
English speaking countries- DSM
Europe- ICD
o Mixed Anxiety-Depression (ICD), Generalised Anxiety Disorder (DSM), Binge Eating Disorder (DSM)
What are examples of changes through the DSM editions?
Homosexuality removed from the DSM in 1973
Generalised anxiety disorder first introduced in DSM-III-R (1987)
Binge eating disorder first included in DSM-5 (2013)
Asperger’s disorder symptoms reclassified and included in the section of Autism Spectrum Disorders in DSM-5 (2013)
Gaming disorder added to the section on Addictive disorders in ICD-11 (2018)
Describe the main principles of DSM-I and DSM-II
DSM-I (1952) and DSM-II (1986)
• Strongly influenced by psychoanalytic theory
• Very concerned with causation
• Had two main sections:
o Biological causation diseases
o Psychological reactions to individual’s environment or internal processes
• Thought patient’s defense mechanisms were causes
What were the limitations of DSM-I and DSM-II?
o psychoanalysis is not proven and can’t be measured
o limited reliability
o Not a lot of detail on required length of disorder or required severity: line between normal and abnormal blurred
Which DSM’s were approached via the Kraepelin approach and what did they do?
- DSM-III (1980)
- DSM-III-R (1987)
- DSM-IV (1994)
- DSM-IV-TR (2000)
- Focus on observable symptoms
Talk about the DSM-V and its improvements
• DSM-V (2013)
o Reflects the medical/biological model
o No theoretical assumptions about causation
o Description of symptoms:
Patient report, direct observation, measurement
No assumptions about unconscious processes
Clear, explicit criteria and decision rules
• Improved reliability, but validity questionable
Focus on symptoms
o Clear guidelines for differential diagnosis
o Interrater reliability increased
What are problems of the DSM-V?
o Problems include comorbidity, diagnostic instability and lack of treatment specificity
Comorbidity questions the validity of separate, independent diagnostic categories
What is the difference between DSM-I and II, vs all the DSM’s that came after?
DSM-III, DSM-III-R, DSM-IV, DSM-IV-TR and DSM-5
Specific diagnostic criteria for each category
No explicit assumptions about causation
Polythetic format: a set of optional diagnostic criteria is provided: only a subset is needed for diagnosis
DSM-I and DSM-II
Unspeciffic, general descriptions of categories
Assuming causation from a psychoanalytic viewpoint
Monothetic format: general description of criteria without specifying which ones are necessary and which ones are optional
Who were the Rorschach inkblot tests developed by and what were they used for? Was there a lot of evidence suggesting they worked?
Rorschach in 1921 published psychodiagnostik
• Reflects psychoanalysis, psychodynamic principles
• Originally developed to diagnose schizophrenia
o Small amount of evidence that it works for schizophrenia
• Later further developed to become a personality test used in clinical settings
• Both reliability and validity highly disputed
• Rarely used in Australia
• Helped therapist to get to unconscious process, but not much evidence for it
What occurs in an unstructured clinical interview and why?
o For clinical assessment
o Forming a therapist-client therapeutic alliance
Client needs to trust you and feel you are open minded
o Diagnostic questioning:
To guide further assessment
To formulate diagnosis (DSM-5)
For treatment planning/delivery
o Presenting problem current symptoms
Try to figure out problem according to their symptoms
o Current living circumstances, relevant history
Dependent on the clinician’s theoretical orientation
• Behavioural vs psychoanalyst approach
o Case formulation
What is involved in case formulation?
What are the factors that predispose this individual to the development of this or these presenting problems?
What are the factors that act as precipitants in the presenting problems(s)?
What are the factors that serve to maintain the presenting problem(s)?
What are the factors that serve to predict the outcome?
Form hypothesis about what maintains problems, and what will promote and hinder change
What should happen at the end of a psychologist’s first session?
Explain and summarise this session
Provide direction to future plans of implementation
What is involved in a semi-structured assessment?
o Structured clinical interview for DSM-5
o Interview administered by trained clinicians
o Tailored: client’s response determines the next question
o Presence of symptoms+ severity diagnosis
o Highly reliable, valid assessment of DSM-based diagnosis
o Only as valid as the DSM is
What is involved in structured clinical interviews? What are they used for?
o Treatment evaluation studies, Research studies, Epidemiology
o Composited International Diagnostic Interview -CIDI (WHO)
Can be administered by not clinically trained interviews
• E.g. National Survey of Mental Health and Wellbeing Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS)
What are self-report diagnostic questionnaires used for?
o Often used to screen for possible diagnosable disorders
o Include DSM diagnostic criteria but less structured and more narrow than structured interviews
E.g. AUDIT (Alcohol Use Disorder Identification Test) and EDDS (Eating Disorders Diagnostic Scale)
o Based on scores
o Often used for:
Dimensional assessment of symptoms, emotions, behaviours relevant to mental health
• Varying degrees of severity to a mental disorder
• Bounday between normality and abnormality is indistinct: moves from the “you have it or you don’t” approach for one where there are varying degrees of having it or not.
Do all self-report questionaires reflect DSM-based diagnostic criteria? What are examples of this?
Some reflect DSM-based diagnostic criteria, others do not
• E.g. Narcissistic Personality Inventory (NPI)
o Developed on the basis of DSM-IIII diagnostic criteria for NPD
• Depression Anxiety Stress Scales (DASS)
o Developed independently of DSM criteria
o Focuses on emotion