AC4.1- Criminological theories & policy development Flashcards
(54 cards)
what are the biological policy developments?
neurochemicals+diet
chemical castration
eugenics
death penalty
What is the neurochemicals + diet policy?
The Balance Of Good Health Model (Edwards Et Al 2001)
What did Virkkunen et al (1987) find?
(neurochemicals + diet)
found that violent offenders have lower serotonin levels and this can be treated by a diet that contains foods such as salmon, nuts and chocolate
What did Schoethaler (1982) find?
(neurochemicals + diet)
found that a reduced sugar diet reduced anti-social behaviour by 48%
What did Gesch Et Al (2002) find in support of the neurochemicals + diet policy?
231 young male prisoners agreed to daily supplements or placebo drugs and found a 35% reduction in disciplinary incidents per 1,000 person-days.
Violent incidents dropped by 37% and in the placebo group only 10%
A healthy diet is sufficient to change chemicals in the brain and significantly reduce violence and aggression due to boosted serotonin and dopamine levels
What is the link to theory for neurochemicals + diet policy?
Brain Chemistry
What is chemical castration?
Anti-androgens (cyproterone acetate, flutamide, bicalutamide) pills which block androgen hormones such as testosterone which is implicated in aggression
What is the link to theory for chemical castration?
Sex Hormones
do chemical castrations work?
Cyproterone acetate is usually administered in 2 or 3 daily dosages, flutamide 3x a day and bicalutamide is the most common 1x a day.
Volunteers were given a pill or anti-libidinal intervention to reduce their sex drive
but a reduced libido doesn’t mean reduced reoffending
once the treatment is stopped the effect will no longer work
Sweden, Denmark and Canada noticed a drop from 40% to 5%
What countries permit the use of chemical castration?
France
Poland
Australia
Belgium
Russia
Sweden
Turkey
UK
What are eugenics?
Breeding for strong qualities/characteristics but was previously misused for the purpose of eliminating certain ethnic groups
What is the link to theory for eugenics?
Genetic inheritence
Do eugenics work?
Nazis breeding Aryons & killing the “faulty”- Gays, Jews, Slavs, gypsies
What is the death penalty?
execution of person convicted for a serious crime
What is the history of the death penalty in the UK?
In 1965 there was a temporary abolition
as a result murder rate did not soar so there was a permanent abolition of it for murder in 1963
What it the Link to theory for the death penalty?
Genetics
Does the death penalty work?
Not really
In the USA statistics show that the murder rate is lower in states that don’t have the death penalty that those that do
In 2015, murder rate was 25% higher in death penalty states than in non-penalty.
There’s other influencing factors as to why people murder and people rarely make reasoned and rational decisions based on future consequences
What are the individualistic policy developments?
Psychoanalysis
Behaviour modification
training programmes
anger management
What is psychoanalysis?
A treatment where the patient verbalises their thoughts through a variety of methods to access unconscious thoughts/ memories where they talk about whatever comes to mind
What is the link to theory for psychoanalysis?
The psychodynamic theory
Does psychoanalysis work?
- might not work on prisoners with life sentences who have no hope of getting out so they don’t care
-A study in 2010 concluded cognitive behavioural therapy worked
-it’s time consuming, unlikely to provide answers
-Blackburn (1993) said there’s few positive evaluations as a method with offenders
-may evoke some painful memories and raises ethical concerns
-creates a power imbalance between therapist and patients
What is behaviour modification?
a method which extinguishes undesirable behaviours and promote desirable ones, criminal behaviour is punished in order to weaken the thought-process leading to the illegal behaviour
What is the link to theory for behaviour modification?
Operant conditioning
What is the policy introduced for behaviour modification?
The Token Economy- where a token is given for a desired action which is later exchanged for a ‘treat’ (money, family visits, televisions, phone calls)
Fo & O’Donnel ‘buddy system’ adult volunteers were assigned to a young offender as a positive role model