All theorists Flashcards
(16 cards)
Polanyi
Substantivist: Economy is embedded in social relations
James C. Scott
Moral economy: peasats are busier with just getting by, subsistence over profit.
Thompson
Uses an example for the moral economy, the food riots. People rebel for moral rights to fair prices.
Marcel Mauss
The gift: gift giving creates social ties. The gift giver becomes superior, creates a sense of imbalance.
Graeber
Value is how people represent the importance of their actions. Value is not just price or profit, it is symbolic.
Example: if you give a cup of coffee to a homeless person, how much value do you ascribe to that cup of coffee yourself?
Geertz:
- Religion is a symbolic system, embedded in life and makes life have meaning. It is subjective and personal.
Functionalism: Durkheim
Religion creates a sort of collective conscience and religion is social
Functionalism: Malinowski
Religion is psychological comfort, it helps people cope with uncertainty and misfortune
Functionalism: Radcliffe-Brown
Religion maintains social order
Misfortune: Malinowski
Witchcraft is there to comfort and explain. It explains misfortune and helps people cope. It is a rational and moral explanation for misfortune.
Turner
Liminality in ritual: being neither here nor there, betwixt and between two states of being. Spirit possession as a liminal space for transformation.
Applied anthropology debate
Applied anthropology: commercial side of anthropology
Academic anthropology: ivory tower
detachment versus intervention
purity versus practicality
can we apply anthropology without reinforcing existing power dynamics?
Applied anthropology debate examples
Malinowski, while being the founding father of anthropology, advised colonial authoroties
Hutton worked for the British Raj, anthropology used to manage empire
Sol Tax
Action Anthropology, anthropology must not only describe but serve
Critiques of academic anthropology
detachment from urgent problems, over-reliance on theory (that has colonial roots)
Scheper-Hughes: moral anthropology, anthropology should provoke moral and political responses
Guest
anthropology used in the tech industry: creating what people need