Attachment Flashcards
Attachment definition
Infant and caregiver develop deep, lasting emotional Botha reciprocal
Both members feel secure when close to attachment figure
How is strength of bond seen
Caregiver interactions e.g reciprocity and international synchrony
What is reciprocity
Mutual turn taking form of interaction, both caregiver and infant contribute to interaction by responding to signals and cues
What is interactional synchrony
Simultaneous interaction between infant and caregiver acting rhythmically with matching coordinated behaviour and matching emotional states
Examples of caregiver infant interaction
- Imitation
- Sensitive responsiveness
- Child directed speech
- Body contact
Meaning of imitation and sensitive responsiveness
Imitation- infant directly copies caregivers expressions
SR- caregiver correctly interpreted infants communication and responds appropriately e.g feeding when distressed
What is child directed speech and body contact
Cds- adult modulates voice by slowing down and raising pitch to keep infants attention
Body contact - physical contact e.g skin to skin contact especially first few hours of life e.g breastfeeding
Why has the term child directed speech historically criticised
Historically referred to as ‘motherese’
Gender stereotyping
Both parents and other caretakers uses speech pattern
Strengths of caregiver interaction evaluation meltzoff and moore
Meltzoff & Moore 1977-
experimenter displayed facial expressions e.h sticking out tongue and opening mouth in shock to 12-21 day old infants.
Recording shown to people blind to experiment, found infant responses matched experimenter facial expresssions
Suggests ability to observe and reciprocate through imitation present from early age
Strength of caregiver interaction condon and sander
1974
Videotaped interactions between adults and neonates
Focus on movements of neonates I’m response to adult speech
Using detailed frame by frame analysis of video recording found evidence of international synchrony between neonates and rhythmic patterns of adult speech
Results suggests from birth innate ability for social interaction
Weakness of research for caregiver infant interactions
- Infants cannot directly communicate thoughts or emotions, research depends of inferences considered unscientific
Inferences are assumptions about infants internal mental state based on observed behaviour and could be mistaken e,g researcher claiming imitation is intentional however may be an unconscious reflex response - Social sensitivity - childrearimg techniques including norms around caregiver- infant interactions may find life choices criticised such as mothers returning to workplace shortly after birth and cannot develop high level of interaction al synchrony
What are the 4 stages of attachments
Identified by Schaffer
1. Asocial - 0-6 weeks
2. Indiscriminate attachment. 6w-7M
3. Specific attachment 7-9 months
4. Multiple attachments 9M+
What is first stage of attachment
A social stage
Babies display innate behaviours (crying,smiling) ensure proximity to any potential caregiver
Perceptual ability limited therefore can be comforted by anyone as no preferred
What is second stage of attachment
Indiscriminate attachment
Develop ability to differentiate objects and humans and familiar and unfamiliar adults
Smiling more at familiar
Do not develop stranger or separation anxiety yet
What is third stage of attachment
Specific attachment
Form strong attachment to primary caregiver,
Separation and stranger anxiety develop
What is fourth stage of attachment
Multiple attachment
Start to form attachment with other regular caregivers e.g grandparents, uncles
Stranger anxiety decreases
How did Schaffer and Emerson investigate stages of attachment
1964
Identified stages of attachments from longitudinal observation
60 WC babies and families from Glasgow studied
First year- data collected through monthly observations and interviews will additional follow up visits at 18 months
Stranger anxiety and separation anxiety assessed
Found separation anxiety occurred most babies 25-32 weeks
Stranger distress month later
87% 18 month follow up, multiple attachments
Strongest attachment was mothers with consistent caregiver infant interaction
What does Schaffer and Emerson results suggest
Development of attachment outlined by Schaffer
Also quality of caregiver infant interaction directly impacts strength of attachment for infants and mother s
General strength and weakness of Schaffer
S- high mundane realism, observed in own homes, experience for infants were normal
Strangers visiting family home and caregiver temporarily leaving normal occurrences suggests behaviour recorded were valid
W- not generalisable, WC mothers in 1960 Glasgow. Culture not representative of uk or rest of world.
Lack temporal validity as childrearing techniques and practises changed significantly over 60 years
Role of the father: importance of active play
Engage babies in active play activities more consistently than mothers
Fathers interactions emphasise stimulation and encourage risk taking behaviours compared to comforting style of mothers
Role of the father as primary caregiver
In modern western society, mothers more likely to be in workforce, evidence suggesting if men take on role of primary caregiver, interactional style changes to be more like mother increasing capacity for sensitive responsiveness
What did Schaffer find about attachment types between mother and father
Primary attachment type is 65% mother
30% both parents
3% father alone
However 18 months, 75% infants formed attachment with father showing separation anxiety suggesting important role in infants life
Strength of role of father research
Field- 1978. Observed primary caregiver mother, primary caretaker father and secondary caretaker father interacting with 4 month old infant. Found father focused more on game playing however primary caretaker father ability to show sensitive responsiveness behaviour similar to mothers e.g more smiling and child directed speech than secondary
vessimo 2011. Observed pre school children relationship with mother and fathers then conducted follow up assessment of social interactions when child started nursery. Strong attachment to father best predictor of ability to make friends in schools suggesting important role for socialisation
More AO3 of father research
Socially sensitive- research arguining role of mother cannot be replaced by father may lead to father led\2 father household feeling they cannot fully provide for needs of infants
Economic implication- research assessing importance of fathers role may lead to legislatiom ensuring equal paternity/maternity leave. May reduce males in workforce, economic activity and pressure on businesses. Equalising maternity and paternity help address gender pay gap
Animal studies ; Lorenz
Testing imprinting
1935
Greylag goose eggs randomly divided; half with incubator with Lorenz and other hatched with biological mother
Goslings imprinted on Lorenz following him. Those hatched with mother followed her. Found goslings had critical period of around 32 hours. If gosling did not see large object to imprint in first couple of hours , loses ability to imprint
Harlow animal studies
Testing cupboard love theory- babies love mother because feed
Monkeys removed from biological mother and placed in cage with surrogate mothers
One provided comfort no milk. Other made of wire mesh provided food
Spent time with cloth mother only went to other for food
Returned to cloth when frightened
Monkeys without access to cloth mother showed signs of stress related disease
Follow up studies, Harlow found maternal deprivation caused by studies resulted in permanent social disorders as adults E.g difficult raising offspring, mating
What does Harlow study suggests
Monkeys have a biological need for physical contact and will attach to whatever provided comfort over food
Evidence against cupboard love theory
Why shouldn’t animal studies be used
Harlow findings influential. Bowlby argues Similar critical period to humans 6-30 months. If attachment not formed , permanent social problems however later research on orphans show unlike geese, period is sensitive not critical however later care can help with recovery
Humans and animals have different biology. Humans have various social and cultural experiences forming behaviour
Strength of animal studies
Practical explanations
Knowledge gained from studies later developed by bowlby applied to early childcare e.g after both immediate physical contact between mother and baby encouraged . Social service actively investigate case of infant neglect understanding long term harm
Learning theory of attachment
Dolland and miller
Cupboard love theory based on learning theory that infant attach to caregiver due to food
Due to classical and operant conditioning
What is classical conditioning
Learning due to association
Food is unconditioned stimulus, pleasure unconditioned response . As mother is present when baby is fed mother becomes associated with pleasure of being fed. Neutral stimulus to conditioned stimulus