BDC CH. 7 Flashcards
(93 cards)
When did the Scottsboro Affair begin?
March 23, 1931
- during downward plunge of Great Depression
- people began living in “Hoovervilles” (shantytowns) in run down parts of cities
- people began roaming land for food/work
- many traveled on foot/rode rails illegally (jumped on/off moving trains)
(DPPM)
What was the Scottsboro Boys case?
- black/white boys got into fight on train from Chattanooga to Memphis
- whites that were thrown off train went to nearest station saying they were attacked unprovoked
- sheriff searches train + hauls black boys off to Jackson County Jail
- white women on train falsely claimed black boys raped them
- punishment was typically death by either execution/lynching
(BWSWP)
What did Alabama Governor Benjamin Miller do to prevent a mass lynching of the Scottsboro Boys as they headed to Scottsboro?
dispatched militiamen units to Scottsboro
- this type of action had brought sharp decline in lynching since 1920
What was the result of the court trial for the Scottsboro Boys?
- all 9 except 13 year old found guilty
- sentenced the 8 boys to death
AS
What were some factors of the Scottsboro case that lent it to be an unfair trial?
- boys lawyers had no time to prepare a defense
- Judge showed obvious sympathy for girls
- trial concluded in only four days
- guilty verdicts flew in face of forensic evidence (no signs of rape on women)
(BJTG)
What was NAACP Secretary Walter White’s impression of the Scottsboro Boys case?
- was confused/pessimistic
- repelled by the status of the Scottsboro Boys
- NAACP liked to defend educated/well mannered blacks
- Scottsboro boys bad reputation prevented NAACP support
- made White cautious to support them
(WRNSM)
Who would rise to defend the Scottsboro Boys when the NAACP hesitated?
The Communist Party
- persuaded boys/their parents to let them/the Communist ILD represent them
- launched public agitation campaign to save boys
(PL)
What was Walter White’s feeling toward the Communist Party becoming involved in the Scottsboro Boys case?
appalled
- case became tug of war between two orgs.
- argued it would be suicidal to work w/ the Communists
- believed Communists were more concerned w/ discrediting “capitalist courts” than helping boys
- visited the boys/families saying not to work w/ Communists
(CABV)
What did the Scottsboro Boys decide to do after hearing White’s advice w/ the Communists?
stick w/ the Communists + ILD anyway
What were the immediate actions taken by the Communists when it came to the Scottsboro Boys?
- organized meetings + marches + petitions
- sent Scottsboro boys moms on national speaking tours
- messaged endlessly Alabama public officials
- movement spread internationally to Communist chapters (London, Berlin, Cuba, Johannesburg etc.)
(OSSM)
How did the complex nature of he Communist movement amplify its voice?
- controlled many labor unions + defense committees + cultural orgs.
- made Scottsboro campaign seem far more spontaneous than it actually was
- party directives controlled most of actions not spontaneous actions by individuals
(CMP)
Who else came in support of the Scottsboro boys besides the Communists?
- many ordinary citizens attended rallies + donated $$$ + wrote letters to officials
- artists + intellectuals + writers + scientists + politicians
(MA)
What was the result of the appeal of the Scottsboro Boys case in the Supreme Court?
Powell v. Alabama
- victorious
- Court ruled boys had been denied right to “due process” under 14th Amendment
- rescinded guilty verdicts + granted boys rights to new trials
(VCR)
Where was the second trial for the Scottsboro Boys supposed to be held?
Decatur
- Judge James Horton
- one of the most politicized trials in US history
- southern conservatism vs northern liberalism vs international communism
(JOS)
What did the Communist Party + the ILD represent to Southern whites?
everything that they hated
- culturally alien + revolutionary + militantly antiracist
- viewed their involvement as indirect attack on South’s political/economic order
(CV)
How did the Communists + ILD view the South?
- saw it as a hellhole for oppression
- dismissed the charges of black rape as a lie
- wanted black/white masses to overthrow capitalist exploiters
(SDW)
Besides the political/economic challenge brought by the Communists, what did many Southern Whites feel that the Scottsboro case represented?
defense of Southern white womanhood
- white juries rarely found blacks not guilty in rape of white women
- made the task for the defense doubly difficult
- head counsel Liebowitz didn’t help himself by questioning the testimony made by train women
(WMH)
What was the result of the Decatur trial?
found the first boy Haywood Patterson guilty
- sentenced to death
- surprisingly Judge Horton set aside conviction
- Horton deemed white woman’s testimony as unreliable + contradictory to evidence
- concluded rapes didn’t take place
(SSHC)
What was the response by Alabama authorities after Judge Horton decided not to uphold conviction of the Scottsboro Boys?
didn’t give up
- persuaded Horton to step down for other 8 trials
- replaced by Judge William Callahan
- was bias towards defense + looked for speedy conviction of boys
(PRW)
What was the result of the court cases handled by Judge Callahan?
- hostile towards Liebowitz
- didn’t allow questioning regarding train woman’s (Victoria Price) truth in testimony
- neglected to mention acquittal to jury until prompted by defense
- declared boys (Patterson + Norris) guilty + sentenced to death
(HDND)
What happened when the Supreme Court would review Judge Callahan case appeals?
Norris v. Alabama
- Liebowitz argued blacks had been purposely excluded from being on jury
- Court agreed citing clear evidence of racial discrimination
(LC)
What did Alabama prosecutors do even after the second ruling by the Supreme Court to drop the charges against four of the boys?
- still tried Patterson a fourth time
- tried Norris a third time
- tried three others a second time
- all found guilty (received different sentences)
(STTA)
How was the NAACP able to claim some credit for the limited victory of the Scottsboro boys case?
- two ILD lawyers caught trying to bribe Price
- Liebowitz insisted Communist Party bow out of case
- Scottsboro Defense Committee (SDC) thereafter organized boys defense (NAACP coalition)
(TLS)
What happened to the Scottsboro Boys once the SDC/NAACP took control of their case?
- failed to secure pardons for five of the boys
- were able to commute Norris sentence
FW