Chapter 4: Determining a Criminal Case Flashcards
Who is Victoria Legal Aid (VLA)?
A government agency that provides free legal advice to the community and low-cost or no-cost legal representation to some people who cannot afford a lawyer.
Why is there a need for government-funded institutions such as VLA?
If accused has no experience with criminal justice system and cannot understand their rights or the key concepts of criminal law, the principle of access and their right to a fair trial may be compromised.
Thus, VLA is needed to assist the accused - especially if they cannot afford legal assistance.
What is the VLA’s ‘vision’?
A fair and just society where rights and responsibilities are upheld; more focus on prevention and early resolution of legal problems.
What are the VLA’s objectives?
- provide legal aid efficiently
- manage its resources to make legal aid available at a reasonable cost to the community and on an equitable basis throughout Victoria
- improved access to justice and legal remedies
- minimise the need for individual legal services in the community.
What is legal aid?
Legal advice, education or information about the law and the provision of legal services (including legal assistance and representation)
How does the VLA assist accused persons?
- Publishing legal information to assist those who are charged with minor offences and will be required to represent themselves.
- Providing legal advice about the law and how it applies to a particular case
- Providing legal representation for accused persons charged with serious indictable offences
- Providing duty lawyers (lawyers based in the Magistrates’ and Children’s Court)
THIS LINKS TO THE 4 TYPES OF LEGAL AID!
What ‘other’ roles does VLA fulfil?
- Control and administer the Legal Aid Fund.
- In cooperation with government bodies and departments, meet the needs of the community for legal aid.
- Make recommendations about law reform.
- Design and implement education programs to promote
understanding by the public of their rights and responsibilities - Research legal aid issues.
Outline one criticism of the VLA
Funding often criticised for being insufficient to meet community’s demand for legal services.
Hence, VLA can only provide fee legal assistance to those who need it most (e.g. very poor, cannot afford solicitor, homeless, limited English skills etc.)
Thus, large part of community is ineligible for legal aid and people are forced to defend themselves in criminal cases.
Identify the different types of legal aid
- Free legal information
- Free legal advice
- Free duty lawyer services
- Grants of legal assistance (getting a lawyer to run a case)
Describe free legal information. Who is it available to?
Information about criminal justice system and cases which may assist those who are charged with minor offences and will represent themselves provided via website, public library or over the phone.
Everyone.
Describe free legal advice. Who is it available to?
Provided in person, by video conference or over the phone.
People who need it most.
Describe free duty lawyer services. Who are they available to?
Duty lawyer is a lawyer in the Magistrate’s or Children’s court on a particular day who can help people scheduled for a hearing on that day.
Can give fact sheets, offer legal advice, or represent the accused in court on that day.
Not available in indictable offence trials.
Fact sheets for everyone.
Legal advice for people who pass income test or people in custody.
Legal representation for people who pass income test, are facing a significant charge or be someone prioritised by VLA (e.g. homeless, disabled, Indigenous Australian etc.)
What is the income test?
Test applied by Victoria Legal Aid (VLA) to determine whether a duty lawyer can represent an accused.
The test is satisfied when the accused can show that they have limited income (e.g. their primary source of income is social welfare provided by government)
Describe grants of legal assistance (getting a lawyer to run a case). Who are they available to?
May include legal advice, helping the accused resolve matters in dispute, preparing legal documents and representing the accused in court.
Strict guidelines. Accused people must meet the means test. Other matters are considered, including whether the matter has merit and whether helping the accused can benefit them and the public.
Describe grants of legal assistance (getting a lawyer to run the case). Who is it available to?
May include legal advice, helping the accused resolve matters in dispute, preparing legal documents and representing the accused in court.
Strict guidelines. Accused people must meet the means test. Other matters are considered, including whether the matter has merit and whether helping the accused can benefit them and the public.
What is the means test?
The test applied by Victoria Legal Aid (VLA) to determine whether the accused qualifies for legal assistance or representation in court (beyond the services of the duty lawyer on the day). Accounts for the applicant’s income, assets and expenses.
True of False.
Courts can adjourn a trial until legal representation from VLA has been provided.
True.
Courts must be satisfied that the accused persons wouldn’t be able to receive a fair trial without legal representation, and the accused cannot afford to pay for legal representation.
True or False. The burden of proof is on the prosecution to establish that the accused can afford legal representation and thus does not require assistance from the VLA.
False.
The burden of proof is on the accused to establish that they cannot afford the full cost of obtaining legal representation.
Discuss how the VLA meets POJ Access
Strengths:
Free legal information. VlA publishes information about criminal proceedings and the court system, improving many accused persons’ understanding of the legal system.
Legal assistance. those provided with casework assistance by VlA better understand the criminal justice system and their rights in defending the charges alleged.
Weaknesses:
Limited information. information published by VlA about the legal system is general and limited to some disputes; as such it promotes understanding of the legal system for only some accused persons.
Strict eligibility criteria.
Limited availability of duty lawyers.
Discuss how the VLA meets POJ Fairness
Strengths:
Focus on most vulnerable.
VlA’s eligibility criteria
for a grant of legal assistance/legal representation ensure those most at risk of a serious sanction and least able to afford a private lawyer, are provided with legal representation – ensuring they are better able to present their defence in its best light, promoting fairness.
Weaknesses:
Strict eligibility requirements. VlA’s strict eligibility criteria (and very limited budget) mean it is only able to provide legal advice and representation to a small number of accused persons; many accused persons charged with criminal offences do not meet VlA’s eligibility criteria but cannot afford a private lawyer; as a result, VlA is limited in its ability to ensure fairness across the criminal justice system.
Limited availability of duty lawyers. duty lawyers are not available to all accused persons in the Magistrates’ court.
Discuss how the VLA meets POJ equality
Strengths:
No discrimination in eligibility. VlA’s eligibility criteria ensure legal support is provided to those in most need, regardless of their personal characteristics (such as race, religion, gender, etc); this promotes equality in the administration of justice.
Free information is available to everyone. All members of society (regardless of their personal characteristics such as religion, wealth, etc) can access VlA’s published legal information.
Weaknesses:
Assistance is limited. the strict eligibility criteria for legal assistance mean many accused persons are unable to access support from VlA and remain unrepresented; VlA is therefore unable to ensure equality of access
to legal representation for all in the community – it can represent only the very poor, the very rich can afford their own private lawyer, and the ‘forgotten middle’ may be required to self-represent.
What are community legal centre (CLCs)?
Indepedent, not-for-profit organisations that provide free legal services (including advice, information and representation) to people in their local communities who are unable to access other legal services.
What are the two types of community legal centres?
Generalist CLCs
Specialist CLCs
What is a generalist CLC?
A community legal centre that provides a broad range of legal services to people in a particular geographical area in Victoria.