Chapter 9 Flashcards
Forfeiture
giving up property you gained from committing a crime
-Criminal vs Civil
Problem: does not consider the offenders ability to pay the fines—- many go unpaid
Selective incapacitation
Critiques?
- Wolfgang et al. (1972): 6% offenders represented 52% of all arrests
- RAND Corporation study
- Requires accurate identification of serious offenders
- did not commit only the same offense
- specific factors: juvenile arrests, substance abuse, etc- Critiques - specific factors does not guarantee that person will be a chronic offender (false positive) - trying to predict who is going to commit a crime - selective incapacitation suggest people never age out of crime ---- they do (age crime curve)
Civil Commitment
- 5th amendment
- sex offenders, offenders that are ill
- incarcerates people after there time in prison-treatment orientated not punishment orientated----- DOES NOT violate the 5th amendment
Indeterminate sentencing
- judge gets to decide time
- usually a minimum time and a maximum in which a judge as to decide between
Determinate sentencing
- no parole board
- fixed sentence
- sometimes the judge will still allow early release
Mandatory sentencing
Sentencing strategy that removes discretion from the judge
-legislature sets the sentence
- Judge has no discretion
- Ex: three strikes law
US sentencing reform eras
Indeterminate sentencing (1930-1975)
Sentencing Reform (1975-1984)
Tough on Crime (1984-1996)
Equlibrium (1996-2013)
Indeterminate sentencing era
1930-1975
- judicial discretion
- parole boards
- focus on rehabiliation — who is ready to join society now
Sentencing reform era
1975-1984
- equality and consistency
- judge had lots of discretion—- not fair to everyone (ex: race)— got rid of judge discretion and parole board
- wanted something more fair
Tough on Crime era
1984-1996
- severity
- ignore non legal aspects of an offender— focus on the crime
Equlibrium
1996-2013
- Ambivalence
- more prosecutorial discretion
- more focus on just punishing crime not offender
Mass imprisonment negative consequences
- Families
- children
- income- Communities
- formative of social bonds when people are cycling in and out of prison - Overcrowding
- no education programs
- health
- translate to mental health problems
- Communities
Supermax imprisonment
Critiques?
A prison with the most secure level of confinement available
Kept in single cells for 23 hours/ day
- meant for incapacitation and retribution - little to no contact with people
Critiques
- humanitarian issues - some keep people in solitary confinement for periods as long as 20 years - very expensive--- need lots of resources
Social learning theory in prisons
how to commit other offenses and to do it well
Hydraulic displacement of discretion
Evidence?
Taking discretion away from one criminal justice actor may just give it to someone else
Evidence?
- prosecutors did increase their discretion - hard to study