Class 11: Brain training, transfer, limits of expertise, deliberate practice, mental representations, and chunking Flashcards
(255 cards)
In some fields, if you follow specific training methods with diligence, you can become an expert. What are the 4 characteristics that these fields have in common?
- There are always objective or semi-objective ways to win 2. These fields are competitive enough to create incentive for practice and improvement 3. These fields are generally well established 4. There are a subset of individuals who serve as teachers and coaches who develop sophisticated training techniques
According to “Peak: Secrets from the New Science of Expertise,” does deliberate practice: a) Depend solely on natural ability and genetics b) Involve only physical repetition of skills c) Both produce and depend on mental representations d) Require a fixed amount of time for each practice session
Answer: c) Both produce and depend on mental representations
Why did chess expert Patrick Wolff have difficulty recalling some configurations of chess pieces but not others?
His expertise is focused on patterns, so he remembers pieces in the context of an ongoing game. When the pieces are randomised, there is no pattern, and his expertise does not transfer to the task.
Q: What is deliberate practice? A) Mindlessly repeating a task B) Performing a task without any guidance C) Practicing with the goal of improving specific skills D) Practicing for a certain amount of time each day
A: C) Practicing with the goal of improving specific skills.
The ability to identify patterns in a collection of things that might appear random or confused to someone with less developed mental representations is a characteristic of experts performance in almost every field.Is this true or false?
TRUE
According to Chapter 4 of “Peak,” what are the three key characteristics that define the “Gold Standard” of expert performance?
The three key characteristics that define the “Gold Standard” of expert performance, as described in Chapter 4 of “Peak,” are deliberate practice, feedback, and the ability to perform under pressure.
According to “Peak: Secrets from the new science of expertise,” innate talent is the most important factor in achieving expertise.
FALSE
what is a mental representation?
a mental structure that correctly corresponds to an object, idea, or concept.
When shown chessboards with the chess pieces arranged randomly, how did the mid-range player and chess master do in remembering the positions of the pieces in regard to the novice chess player?
The same. They were only able to get two or three pieces right.
Fill in the Blanks: The ACTIVE trial demonstrates clearly the concept of _________ improvement, also referred to as _______ transfer.
Training specific, narrow.
mental representation
a mental structure that corresponds to an object, idea, collection of information, or anything else concrete or abstract that the brain is thinking about.
What is the name of the single largest brain-training intervention that Dan Simons mentioned?
The ACTIVE trial (involved about 3,000 older adults). The main result showed that brain training may improve training-specific tasks. E.g., if you trained on a reaction time task, you’ll likely improve on that reaction time task or something very similar (a.k.a., narrow transfer).
What is a mental representation?
A mental structure that corresponds to an object, idea, collection of information, or anything else concrete or abstract, that the brain is thinking about.
Fill in the blank. During class, a peer mentions burgers, and immediately you see an image of a burger in your mind. The image that appears is your ____ ____ of a burger.
Mental representation.
How is a book mentally represented when writing?
write well, develop a mental representation ahead of time to guide you, then monitor and evaluate being ready to modify if necessary.
True/False Both formal discipline theory and transfer by identical elements are based on modern research on transfer of training.
FALSE
Ericsson and Pool argue that expert performers develop mental representations that allow them to efficiently process and retrieve information relevant to their domain. These mental representations are often referred to as __________.
chunks.
True or False: There is substantial publication bias in the Brain Training literature
True: The authors of the systematic review of brain training programs highlighted the publication bias present in the literature.
True or False. One advantage of the brain training program is that it improves abilities to transfer skills into broader contexts.
False. Evidence demonstrated that brain training programs only affect narrow transfer and learning processes in specific tasks.
Q: According to Ericsson and Pool, what is the difference between deliberate practice and regular practice? A) Deliberate practice is only for experts B) Deliberate practice involves feedback and specific goals C) Regular practice is more enjoyable D) Regular practice requires less time and effort
A: B) Deliberate practice involves feedback and specific goals, while regular practice may lack those components.
What is the term used to describe the process by which experts in a given domain become so proficient that their performance becomes “automatic”? A) Mental modeling B) Skill acquisition C) Deliberate practice D) Proceduralization
D) Proceduralization
True or false: When shown random chess patterns for 5 seconds, professional chess players can almost perfectly re-create them.
False. Chess players outperform lay people only when there is “chess relevant meaning” in the patterns they were shown.
True or False. Brain games (such as Lumosity, CogMed, etc.) significantly improve broad cognitive abilities and aid general daily activities.
False.
does a mental representation have to be accurate?
no, mental representations can be inaccurate, and can vary in detail. however, accuracy may impact the quality of results when completing a task.