CLP Sentencing Flashcards
(66 cards)
What do courts refer to when considering sentencing?
The Sentencing Act 2020 and the sentencing guidelines published by the Sentencing Council
What are the two types of sentence?
Custodial and non-custodial
What are the five statutory purposes of sentencing for adults (s 57 SA 2020)?
Punishment
Reduction of crime (including deterrence)
Reform and rehabilitation
Protection of the public
Reparation to victims
(All equally weighted)
What is an exception to the rule that, where a defendant enters a guilty plea, there is no ‘trial’ phase to the process
Newton hearing
What is the deferral period for sentence?
Six months
When is the ONLY time a deferral period can be extended?
Mags’ Court defers sentence –> at the end of the period they commit to the Crown Court for sentence –> CC can then defer for a further six month period
Indications of sentence in the Mags’ Court
If a defendant proposes a basis of plea and the court considers the Defendant’s basis of plea and decides that the basis of plea is absurd. What happens next?
The court proceeds to sentence the defendant on the prosecution version on the facts.
What happens at a sentencing hearing?
a) Prosecution open facts, make
submissions and applications
b) Defence mitigate
c) Judge passes sentence
What is the maximum length of any community order?
Three years
What is the threshold for imposing a community order?
The court must not make a community order unless it is of the opinion that the offence, or combination of the offence and one or more offences associated with it was serious enough to warrant the making of such an order.
What must the court do to decide the type and length of any sentence?
Assess the seriousness of the case by reference to the sentencing guidelines
When does sentencing take place?
After a guilty plea or conviction following trial.
What is the difference between maximum sentence for an offence vs. by a court?
Statute sets max for offence; court’s powers may be more limited. E.g., Mags’ Court cannot exceed its sentencing limits even if statute allows more.
When is a pre-sentence report required under s 30 SA 2020?
Before passing a custodial or community sentence, unless the court considers it unnecessary.
Who prepares pre-sentence reports?
Probation Officers. Assess offence, attitude, and suitability for community orders.
What is a Newton hearing?
A hearing to determine factual basis for sentence when D pleads guilty but disputes facts that affect sentence.
What happens at a Newton hearing?
No jury
P opens case, calls evidence
D may give evidence
Court decides facts beyond reasonable doubt
Sentences on prosecution or defence basis accordingly
What are the four steps to determining sentence?
Apply category from sentencing guidelines (culpability/harm)
Adjust for aggravating/mitigating factors
Apply guilty plea discount
Apply totality principle across offences
What is required for a custodial sentence under s 230 SA 2020?
The offence (or combination with others) must be so serious that a fine or community order cannot be justified.
What is required for a community order under s 240 SA 2020?
Offence (or combined offences) must be serious enough to warrant it.
What must the court do when passing sentence?
Explain sentence in plain English
Refer to guidelines used (or why not)
Justify custody threshold
Show guilty plea discount
Set out aggravating/mitigating factors
What is the max sentence reduction for a guilty plea at:
– first stage?
– after first stage?
– day of trial?
First stage: 1/3
After first stage: 1/4
Day of trial: 1/10
What reduces the discount available at a Newton hearing?
If prosecution proves its case on facts, max reduction is halved. If witnesses are called, reduction may be further reduced.