Contract 4 - Vitiating Elements Flashcards
What is misrepresentation?
Unambiguous false statement of fact inducing the claimant to enter into the contract.
The false statement does not need to be a term to give rise to rights on the claimant’s part.
What are the elements of an actionable misrepresentation?
- Representations need to be pre-contractual
- Make the contract voidable but not void
- Must be unambiguous, false, and a statement of fact
What is the test for actionability in misrepresentation?
- Unambiguous
- False
- Statement of fact
What does ‘unambiguous’ mean in the context of misrepresentation?
The representation must be clear with unambiguous meaning.
The representor will not be liable if the representee has placed its own unreasonable construction on the representation.
What is required for a statement to be considered ‘false’ in misrepresentation?
A statement must be false; it is not false if it is substantially correct.
Minor differences should not influence a reasonable person to enter into a contract.
What constitutes a ‘statement of fact’ in misrepresentation?
- Not a mere puff
- Made by words or conduct
- Statements of law can give rise to misrepresentation
What are examples of statements that do not constitute misrepresentation?
- Mere puff
- Statements of opinion
- Future intentions
- Silence
What is the significance of silence in misrepresentation?
Silence is not a statement of fact and usually does not result in misrepresentation.
There is generally no duty to disclose facts influencing the other party’s decision.
What are exceptions to the rule of silence in misrepresentation?
- Half-truths
- Continuing representations
- Contracts uberrimae fidei
- Addressed to the claimant
- Induces claimant to enter contract
What is required to establish inducement in misrepresentation?
The representation must have caused the representee to enter into the contract.
The test for materiality is objective.
What is the burden of proof in cases of fraudulent misrepresentation?
The burden of proof is on the claimant and it is a heavy burden to discharge.
What constitutes fraudulent misrepresentation?
- Proof of fraud
- False representation made knowingly, without belief in its truth, or recklessly
What is negligent misrepresentation?
A person is liable if another party suffers loss due to a misrepresentation made before entering a contract.
The defendant is liable unless they can prove reasonable grounds to believe the statement was true.
What defines innocent misrepresentation?
A statement made where the representor proves reasonable grounds for belief in its truth and believed it was true at the time of the contract.
What are the remedies available for misrepresentation?
- Rescission
- Damages
- Indemnity
What is rescission?
The effect of misrepresentation is to render the contract voidable, not void.
The contract remains valid until the representee rescinds it.
What are the grounds for denying rescission?
- Affirmation
- Lapse of Time
- Restitution Impossible
- Third-Party Rights
What is the purpose of indemnity in misrepresentation?
Covers expenses from obligations directly resulting from the contract.
Typically awarded when no right to damages exists.
How are damages calculated for fraudulent misrepresentation?
Calculated on a tortious basis to place the claimant in the position they would have been in without the misrepresentation.
What is the difference between damages for negligent and fraudulent misrepresentation?
No distinction in terms of damages; damages can be reduced for contributory negligence in negligent cases.
What is the significance of s 2(2) MA 1967 in relation to damages?
Only available at the discretion of the court for negligent and innocent misrepresentation, compensating where rescission is not awarded.
What is the requirement for exemption clauses regarding misrepresentation?
Must satisfy the requirement of reasonableness under UCTA 1977.
What are non-reliance clauses?
Exclude liability for misrepresentation, stating ‘no representations were made or relied upon.’
An ‘entire agreement’ clause will not exclude liability for misrepresentation.
What is the legal basis for fraudulent misrepresentation?
Tort of deceit.