CPC 6 Flashcards

(153 cards)

1
Q

What are the 4 types of sections contained within the acts?

A
  1. Definition Sections
  2. Offence Creating Sections
  3. Procedural Sections
  4. Powers Sections
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

What is the Definition Section of an Act?

A

Early SECTION which provides a list of some terms that appear in the act and a definition of these terms. EXPLAINS WHAT SOMETHING MEANS

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

What is the Offence Creating Section?

A

Provide for certain actions to be an offence. EG Destroying or damaging property is an offence because s 195 of the Crimes Act 1900 NSW says that it is an offence or provides it as an offence.
THEY ARE ACTIONS THAT ARE UNLAWFUL and USUALLY LIST A PENALTY

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

How much is ONE penalty unit?

A

$110

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

What is a Procedural Section?

A

Section provides certain procedures are to be followed. Section 139(1) and (2) provide that it is a ‘required procedure’ for investigating officials, which includes police, to caution a person in certain circumstances, specifically when they are under arrest (subsection 1) or when police believe that there is sufficient evidence to establish that the person has committed an offence (subsection 2).
Section 139(1)(c) also informs the wording of the caution. THINGS IS NEEDED FOR COURT

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

What is the Power Section?

A

Provides Police with the power to do certain things.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

What is Removing Basic Human Rights?

A

The most prevalent example of this contravention of human rights involves the taking away a person’s liberty/freedom.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

What is Mens Rea?

A

This is the GUILTY MIND

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

What is Actus Reus?

A

Is the Guilty Act (physical element of a crime)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

When is a Crime (OFFENCE) committed?

A

Actus Reus + Mens Rea = Criminal Liability

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

Positive vs Negative Actus Rea?

A

Positive: John Kills Simon by shooting him
Negative: A parent does not feed a baby and the baby dies

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

Intentionally vs Recklessly Mens Rea?

A

Intentionally: Example, John intended to kill Simon by shooting him.
Recklessly: John didn’t intentionally shoot at Simon, but shot his firearm towards a group of people and the bullet hit and killed Simon.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

What is Standard of Proof?

A

refers to the level of certainty a judge or jury must have to decide in favor of one party in a case. BEYOND REASONABLE DOUBT in Criminal Matters and BALANCE OF PROBABILITIES in Civil Matters

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

What is Burden of Proof?

A

refers to the obligation in a legal case for a party to present evidence and demonstrate a fact to a court.
On the Prosecution need to Prove.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

What is the Age of Criminal Responsibility?

A

Age of criminal responsibility is 10 years old.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

What is the Doctrine of Doli Incapax?

A

Legal presumption in Australian Law that children aged 10 - 14 are presumed not to have the capacity to form the necessary criminal intent (mens rea) for a crime.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

What are Elements?

A

Essential Components or requirements that must be present to prove a claim / cause of action or a criminal offence. They are the things the court needs.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

What are the 4 elements of a Crime and where are they found?

A

The Elements of section 195 of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) are:
1. The Accused
2. Intentionally or Recklessly
3. Destroyed or Damaged Property
4. Belonging to Another (or that person and another)

If police can prove these four elements, then they prove that a person committed a guilty act with a guilty mind.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

What is Criminal Liability?

A

Refers to a persons legal responsibility for a criminal act. it is the degree of guilt or blame that is assigned to an individual for committing a crime. Need both actus rea and mens rea

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

What are Strict Liability Offence?

A

Not all offences require the proof of actus reus and mens rea. There are some offences where police are not required to prove mens rea (guilty mind). These offences are called strict liability offences.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

What are Statute of Limitations?

A

For SUMMARY offences 6 months from the date of the alleged offence. No limitations on indictable offence

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

What is a Summary Offence?

A

Less Serious in Nature and is heard in the lower court by a magistrate alone.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

What is an Indictable Offence?

A

More serious in nature, MAY proceed to trial (heard by judge and jury), in a higher court (district or supreme).

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

What are the 2 ways we can categorise offences?

A
  1. Offences categorised in terms of punishment (or penalty) applicable to the offence
  2. Offences categorised in terms of procedure, that is, which court (local, district or supreme) can hear the case.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
What is Categorisation 1: Punishment (or penalty)?
If we are considering the ‘punishment that can be imposed’ (that is the maximum jail term that can be imposed for the offence) then we will have: a. Summary offences (0 to 2 years punishment) b. Minor Indictable offences (>2 <5 years punishment) c. Serious Indictable offences (5 or more years punishment)
26
What is Categorisation 2: Procedure?
If we are considering ‘which court can hear the matter’ then we will have: a. Summary (only the local court) b. Table 2 Indictable (Local court unless prosecution elects to take matter to a higher court e.g., the district court) c. Table 1 Indictable (Local court unless prosecution or defence elects to take matter to a higher court e.g., the district court) d. Strictly indictable (Matter can only be heard in the higher courts; district or supreme)
27
What legislation outlines Indictable Offences?
Criminal Procedure Act 1986 (NSW).
28
Examples of Strictly Indictable, Table 1 Offences and Table 2 Offences?
Strictly: 1. Murder 2. Manslaughter 3. Dangerous Driving Occasioning Death 4. Kidnapping Table 1: 1. Possess Child Abuse Material 2. Assault Occasioning Grievous Bodily Harm (AOGBH) 3. Robbery 4. Destroy or damage property where the value of property exceeds $5000 Table 2: 1. Possessing an unregistered firearm in a public place 2. Assault Occasioning Actual Bodily Harm (AOABH) 3. Record intimate image without consent 4. Stealing/larceny where the value of property does not exceed $5000 5. Destroy or damage property where the value of property does not exceed $5000
29
Serious vs Minor Indictable?
Minor Indictable= more than 2 years, less than 5 years imprisonment Serious Indictable= 5 or more years imprisonment
30
Section 281 Criminal Procedure Act (1986) STATES:
Admissions relating to a Table 1 or higher offence MUST be electronically recorded unless there is a REASONABLE excuse for not doing so.
31
Table 2 vs Table 1?
All Table 2 offences such as lower-level assaults (common assault and (AOABH) and, property damages and stealings of $5000 or less are heard in the local court unless the prosecution decides to ask for the matter to be heard in a higher court All Table 1 offences such as higher-level assaults and, property damages and stealings of more than $5000 are heard in the local court unless the prosecution or defence decides to ask for the matter to be heard in a higher court
32
ORDER OF OFFENCES?
1. Summary 2. Table 2 3. Table 1 4. Strictly
33
What is Prima Facie?
it's the initial evidence presented to support a claim or accusation. In policing, to hold prima facie evidence means that at a minimum there is some evidence for each of the elements of the offence. HAVING ALL THE ELEMENTS OF A CRIME
34
When can a PROSECUTOR OR DEFENCE elect for district court vs ONLY PROSECUTION?
An offence listed in table 1 means that the PROSECUTOR or DEFENCE may elect for the matter to be heard in the District Court An offence listed in table 2 means that ONLY the PROSECUTOR may elect for the matter to be heard in the District Court
35
What should you inc in a Report of Incident?
you should always take a report of any incident including but not limited to: 1. when a criminal offence has occurred 2. use of a power (including arrest or search) 3. motor vehicle collisions 4. missing persons 5. located property.
36
What is Recording Particulars and what do you record?
is a term that is often used by police that refers to the recording of information What particulars do you record? - Time / Date / Place - Incident type - LOC: Location of incident (if different to place) - VIC/WIT: Victim/Witness details - TOI: (Time of Incident) = timeframe within which the incident occurred - DESC: Description of property lost, damaged or stolen - Value of any loss - Any other relevant information
37
When would you record particulars only and not take a statement?
- A person may not have witnessed or been able to give any information that provides you with ‘lines of enquiry’. - The offence is very minor in terms of seriousness, and it is unlikely that you will commence legal proceedings against the suspect. - All reasonable avenues of investigation have been explored but proved fruitless (for example, no suspect can be identified). - The incident reported does not amount to an offence.
38
What is Evidence?
Evidence is any relevant information used to prove or disprove the ‘facts’ surrounding the circumstances of a criminal offence (Lee v The Queen 1998 HCA).
39
What are the 4 Actions of Gathering Evidence?
- Identify Evidence - Preserve Evidence - Collect Evidence - Produce Evidence
40
Facts are a combination that include:
- the ELEMENTS of an offence - any relevant SUBSIDIARY FACTS - any DEFENCES to an offence
41
Inculpatory vs Exculpatory?
Inculpatory: Incriminates - goes towards the guilty Exculpatory: Exonerates - goes towards the innocence
42
What are the 3 Tests for admissibility?
Relevance Reliable Fair
43
What is Relevance?
Relevant evidence will also, always be considered by the court as to its reliability and fairness. Goes directly or indirectly towards one of the Facts and Issues (elements of the offence)
44
What is Reliability?
Is a measure of accuracy. It is the closest any of the principles come to the concept of truth
45
What is Fairness?
- Evidence gathered illegally - Evidence gathered improperly - Evidence which has less probative value than prejudicial effect (i.e., where the relevance of the evidence is outweighed by the improper effect the evidence may have on the jury) - Evidence which would result in a miscarriage of justice - Evidence that, because of public policy considerations should be excluded - Evidence that would operate against a person's rights and privileges
46
Why is there Testing of Evidence?
Legal system based on all persons are considered innocent until proven guilty.
47
What are the 3 Types / Sources of Evidence?
Original Real Documentary
48
What is Original Evidence?
Oral Testimony provided by an eyewitness to the crime. This evidence is recorded in a ‘statement’ format.
49
What is Real Evidence?
REAL Evidence: Physical evidence found at the scene of a crime or used in the commission of an offence.
50
What is Documentary Evidence?
A hard copy, electronic or audio record that provides evidence relating to the commission of an offence.
51
What is Direct vs Indirect Evidence?
DIRECT: facts which support the truth of an assertion (allegation), or INDIRECT: facts which support the drawing of an inference as to the truth of an assertion. This is sometimes referred to circumstantial evidence
52
What is meant by FACTS OF THE ISSUE?
also known as a Police Facts Sheet, is a crucial document used in criminal proceedings in NSW. It outlines the police version of events, based on their observations, statements from victims and witnesses, and other evidence gathered during the investigation.
53
What is Hearsay?
Telling the court what you heard someone else say about the incident is hearsay. Something written that provides evidence that has not been perceived by a witness’s own senses is also considered hearsay.
54
What is the Actual Hearsay Rule?
The basic understanding of the Hearsay Rule is that a witness is not permitted to tell the court any information that is considered hearsay. Each witness is to confine their evidence to what they perceived with their own senses.
55
What are Exceptions to the Hearsay Rule?
Common hearsay exceptions from the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW): 1. Hearsay for a non-hearsay purpose (s 60) 2. First-hand hearsay where the maker is unavailable (s 65) 3. The identity of a person, place or thing (s 66) (maker available) 4. Contemporaneous statements about a person’s health (s 66A) 5. Business records (s 69) 6. Tags and labels (s 70) 7. Telecommunications records (s 71) 8. Admissions (s 81)
56
Exception: Evidence relevant for a non-hearsay purpose, s 60:
A witness tells police that a person was dealing drugs. Police use this information to establish ‘reasonable grounds’ to apply the ‘power to search’ the person and they find the drugs.
57
Exception: Maker not available, s 65:
So, section 65 allows for another witness, in this example the police officer, who was told the information at the time to give the evidence even though it is hearsay. Unless the original witness is dead, the s 65 hearsay exception can be very difficult to use.
58
Exception: Maker available (identity of person, place or thing) s 66:
It would be hearsay for the police to tell the court what the son said, because police did not perceive with their own senses the ‘man stab the woman in the guts’. The s 66 exception to hearsay, provides that even though the witness is available to give original evidence at court, another witness (in this case police) can give certain hearsay evidence, as long as it only relates to the identity of a ‘person, place or thing’ (reference s 66(3)).
59
Admissibility of Hearsay?
The rules of law (such as the hearsay rule and exceptions to hearsay) concerning evidence, that the court is guided by, are contained in the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) and the associated regulations. As a rule, it is better to include evidence and have its admissibility argued in court rather than not include it and never be in a position to use it
60
Exception: Lay opinions, s 78:
The court will permit a person who is not testifying as an expert to testify in the form of an opinion if the opinion is both rationally based on the person’s perception and helps to explain the witness's testimony.
61
Exception: Expert opinions, s 79(1):
The court will permit a person to give an opinion on a subject where they have a, “...specialised knowledge based on the person’s training, study or experience,” and on which the opinion is, “...wholly or substantially based.” (Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) s 79).
62
What is Identifying Evidence?
Generally, the first step of an investigation is to identify sources of evidence. see whether it appears as though a crime/offence has actually been committed. You will do this by asking people what happened.
63
What is Preserving Evidence?
If there is any evidence which is of a nature that can be damaged or lost, then you will do what you can to preserve that evidence. One important aspect of evidence preservation is the limiting of witnesses from contaminating their memory.
64
What is the Collection of Evidence?
Some real and documentary evidence will be collected by general duties police and some evidence such as fingerprints and DNA will be collected by specialist police. The most common type of evidence that you will collect is original evidence, that is the oral testimony of a victim, witness, or suspect/offender. Note: The identification, preservation and collection of evidence all occurs outside the courtroom, prior to the court hearing.
65
What does Producing evidence mean?
From your perspective as a police officer it is much more useful to classify these witnesses into victims, witnesses, and offenders (also known as the accused). Once evidence is collected then that evidence is collated so that it is able to be produced into the court hearing (if the matter goes to hearing
66
What is the PEACE Model?
The PEACE Model of Investigative Interviewing is a structured approach used by the NSWPF to conduct interviews in a non-accusatory and ethical manner. The model is designed to gather accurate information while minimising the risk of false confessions.
67
What is the aim of the PEACE Model?
The aim of any interview is: to obtain the most amount of evidence possible from the interviewee, about the crime, and to identify any other possible lines of enquiry.
68
What are the 5 Stages of the PEACE Model?
Preparation and Planning Engage and Explain Account Closure Evaluation
69
What is in the Planning and Preparation Phase?
Create an interview plan which will include offence investigated elements subsidiary facts possible defences special/legal requirements (specifically for suspects) age- support person impairment- support person Interpreters legal support Interviewee considerations willingness to participate gender cultural background fitness for interview (mental, emotional, tiredness) Roles and other stakeholders Note taker primary and secondary interviewer Time and place Location/timing availability of interview rooms, recording devices etc exhibits attendance of interpreters and support person who is the most appropriate interviewer (usually as a junior officer you or your partner will conduct the lead and secondary interviewer roles. In more complex matters, sometimes the officer in charge of the case is not the best person to conduct the interview).
70
What is the Engage and Explain Phase?
Establish Rapport with the interviewee and explain the interview process to ensure they understand what to expect.
71
What is the Account Phase?
Allowing the interviewee (victim, witness or suspect) to give their account of events without interruption, then clarifying and challenging any inconsistencies.
72
What is Cognitive Interviewing?
Cognitive interviewing is used with willing participants, usually victims and witnesses whose accounts will typically be recorded in a ‘paragraph statement’ format - ask interviewee to give a brief overview of what happened (no record taken) - ask the interviewee to give a more detailed account and take notes of this account in the form of a dot point list, simple paragraph, or timeline. - identify the focal points from the list, paragraph, timeline. - probe the focal points, recording responses in the appropriate format. - Review
73
What is the Conversation Management?
It is designed for use when interviewing people who have a story to tell but do not want to tell it, whether they are suspects or hostile witnesses, and is centred upon the tactical use of evidence that police would have gathered during the course of their investigation. The model comprises three distinct stages each of which needs to be completed before progressing to the next stage. - suspect's agenda - police agenda (sometimes referred to as clarification) - Challenge
74
What is SUSPECTS Agenda?
The suspect is provided with an opportunity to respond to the allegation put to them. Any account offered by the suspect is accepted without challenge and recorded as it is given. If the suspect says nothing or indicates that they do not know what the interviewer is talking about, seek an account of their movements at the relevant time.
75
What is POLICE Agenda?
The suspect is afforded the opportunity to offer an innocent explanation (clarify) for the existence of evidence in the investigator’s possession, without the suspect being made aware of the existence or nature of this evidence.
76
What is Closure Phase?
Summarising the information gathered to ensure mutual understanding and addressing any remaining questions. ALWAYS Summarise info all customer service stuff Sign and witness statement - give copy to interviewee
77
What is the Evaluation Phase?
Assessing the interview’s effectiveness and reflecting on what could be improved for future interviews. Evaluate the Interview and your own performance.
78
What is CHALLENGE?
The suspect is afforded a final opportunity to account for the discrepancies between the evidence in the possession of the investigator and the account given by the suspect. In cases where you have more than one piece of evidence to base a challenge, it is good practice to present the suspect with the least compelling challenge first and build up to the more compelling challenge.
79
Taking a Statement in Notebook:
When taking a statement from a victim or witness you will use the PEACE model to guide you in the taking of that statement.
80
What are CLOSED questions?
Closed questions are typically questions to which the person answering the question has little option other than to provide a short and direct answer. Closed questions often start with ‘do’, ‘are’, ‘did’ or ‘is’ 1. Generally used to elicit a short answer 2. Often used to establish / address legal issues 3. Used when the interviewer is seeking a specific response
81
What are OPEN questions?
Open questions are typically questions to which the person answering the question is encouraged to provide an extended more detailed answer. They often start with ‘tell’, ‘explain’, ‘describe’ or ‘show’. Tell me Explain to me Describe to me Show me
82
What does TEDS stand for?
Tell me Explain to me Describe to me Show me
83
What are PROBING questions?
Probing questions sometimes even when you ask an open question the information supplied will not result in obtaining all of the information or evidence that the person is able to provide. It is very useful to learn how to ask probing questions in order to try and elicit further information. When asking a probing question, it may be appropriate to ask a closed or open question.
84
What are the 5WH?
Who What When Where Why How
85
What questions should you avoid asking?
Multi Part Questions and Leading Questions
86
What is the acronym ADVOKAT?
Amount of time under observation Distance from the incident / person when observing Visibility Obstruction to the line of sight Known or seen before Any reason to notice Time since
87
What is ADVOKAT?
ADVOKAT is a list of questions, asked by the [police] interviewer, to test the reliability of the eyewitness identification, knowing that the magistrate or jury will be considering these issues. It provides [police] investigators with a framework to ensure the evidence is relevant, reliable and fair and therefore, acceptable to the courts. (R v. Turnbull and others, 1976 and ADVOKAT).
88
Note taking entails:
Generally, an interview will begin with an open question similar to, “Tell me everything you can about what you saw happen at the bank today?” At this point in time the interviewer will let the interviewee give their ‘account’ (without interrupting). During this ‘account’ the interviewer (police) will use the skill of notetaking. The second paragraph emphasised by bold text, highlights an important attribute of taking notes. Notes provide the interviewer with a breakdown of the account into manageable sections which are often called focal points
89
What is a Statement?
A statement is a written record of the information (evidence) that a person (victim, witness: including police officer) can provide to a court. The statement itself is not evidence; it is a written record of the evidence the maker can provide (is likely to provide) to the court if required.
90
What does s283B of the Criminal Procedure Act 1986 (NSW) state?
Section 283B of the Criminal Procedure Act 1986 (NSW) tells us, that a statement must contain an endorsement and the age of the statement maker, for it to be accepted by the court. 1. can be question and answers 2. include age (paragraph 2 of statement) 3. endorsement (paragraph 1 of statement) 4. endorsement must be in language understood by maker 5. English version attached if written in other language
91
What is the Endorsement for a child?
The endorsement for a person under 18 years of age, or a person who is below-average intelligence can be modified. See subsection 1: it is sufficient if the endorsement includes: a. words to the effect that the statement is true, or b. words to the effect that the statement contains no lies.
92
What does Section 9J of the Criminal Procedure Regulation 2017 (NSW) state?
provides information relating to details that must not be disclosed to the defence: addresses, dates of birth and phone numbers.
93
What does Section 9J of the Criminal Procedure Regulation 2017 subsection 5 (NSW) state?
1. photocopy the statement 2. using a black Texta, black out the address/D.O.B./phone number from the statement and/or notebook 3. now photocopy the statement/notebook again.
94
What does Section 9J of the Criminal Procedure Regulation 2017 Subsection 9k (NSW) state?
ll statements must be signed on every page of the statement by the maker, whether it is a notebook or typed statement. It must also be signed on each page by the officer taking the statement, and on the final page of the statement the officer should also print their name, rank, station, date, and the time the statement was signed under the signature.
95
What are the 3 stages for interaction with suspects?
Stage 1 - Evidence gathered before interacting with the suspect Stage 2 - Interaction with the Suspect Stage 3 - Court
96
What is the Three Test Rule to commence proceedings?
If the evidence passes the three-test rule, then police should commence legal proceedings. If the evidence does not pass the three-test rule, then police should either continue the investigation, or consult with a senior officer.
97
What is the Prima Facie Test?
is there some evidence that related to each element of the offence if the evidence passes the prima facie test investigators should consider the next two tests
98
What is the Sufficiency Test?
Can it be said that there is no reasonable prospect of conviction at court It is very important that if you think that there is no prospect of conviction you consult with a more experienced senior officer to confirm your views. if, when you consider all of the evidence, there is no real prospect of conviction then you have not satisfied the sufficiency test and it is possible that you should not commence legal proceedings
99
What is the Public Interest Test?
Is it in the interest of the public to spend the courts time on this matter? There are a few occasions where it may not be in the public interest to commence legal proceedings. Police should use their discretion in these matters to consider other appropriate options which may include no formal action or the giving of a warning
100
What do you do When you attend the location and meet with a person?
introduction: Introduce yourself. Be professional and courteous. Advise the person that you are wearing/using a body worn video camera to record conversation and actions. Ask the suspect for their name. allegation: Tell them why you are speaking to them. caution: You MUST caution the suspect if: i. when a person is placed under arrest, or ii. when police believe there is sufficient evidence to establish a person has committed an offence and you intend to question them about that offence suspect ID: Confirm the actual identity of the suspect, obtain ID if possible interview: Interview suspect legal proceedings: If appropriate
101
What are the options for commencing proceedings?
No Formal Action option should be reserved for low-level issues, particularly where there may be no actual victim or when the victim does not wish for any legal action Warning issuing a 'warning’ should be reserved for low-level issues, where there may be no actual victim, or when the victim does not wish any legal action. A warning would be relevant when despite taking no formal action you wish to warn the person that their actions have brought them under notice and that if their actions are repeated then there could be a higher sanction imposed. Caution we mean cautions contained in legislation as a way of dealing with an offence Commencing legal proceedings by way of caution does not remove the obligation of police to investigate the matter fully Penalty Notice FCAN A ‘Court Attendance Notice’ (CAN) is what NSW Police call the official documentation which informs a defendant and court of the charge details/information. they eliminate parts of the 'arrest and charge' procedures as a Field CAN (FCAN)- in the field on the spot FSCAN A Future Service CAN (FSCAN) is another option that police have to commence legal proceedings. A FSCAN is similar to a summons and is particularly relevant when your investigation takes some time to complete and at the conclusion of your investigation it is not appropriate to ‘arrest and charge’ the suspect.
102
You must satisfy the below criteria before issuing an FCAN:
the offence will not continue after issuing the FCAN identity must be established you believe that the offender will appear in court there is no further investigation required in order to commence a criminal proceeding the accused will not interfere with evidence or hinder the police investigation the accused will not intimidate the victim or witnesses you do not need to impose bail conditions on the accused the offence is listed on the FCAN guide card (contained in FCAN book) Police cannot issue an FCAN in the following circumstances: when strictly indictable or domestic violence offences are committed for offences involving juveniles, except traffic offences when the juvenile is of licensable age. when suspects are under the influence of a drug or alcohol when the offender has outstanding warrants (must be returned to a station for a warrant to be executed). Practical considerations: you must have enough evidence to establish elements of the offence service copy (white) of FCAN given to the court (this copy informs the court that the FCAN was served) remember to complete BOTH sides of the Service Copy defendant copy (yellow) of FCAN given to the defendant handed to the offender, directing them to attend court on a certain date or risk having the matter heard in their absence ordinarily to be given at the time of interaction a blue copy is retained in the book
103
An FCAN (and FSCAN) are options for the issue of a Court Attendance Notice but they eliminate parts of the 'arrest and charge' procedures, including:
impingement on a person's right to freedom arrest search on arrest (section 27 LEPRA – you will learn about searches later in the program) transportation in police vehicle custody process at the police station possible further search at station (section 28A LEPRA) remaining in custody while ‘Court Attendance Notice’ is created and served
104
what is the time limit for a FSCAN?
There is a 22-week time limit in which the matter is to be mentioned in court. If the accused has not been served, police need to apply to the court for an arrest warrant.
105
What is an Arrest?
"Arrest is where an officer plainly conveys by words or actions that a suspect is not free to leave" (NSW Court of Criminal Appeal, 2022).
106
What are the 3 ways to effect an arrest?
Seizure or touching Submission Words or conduct Important note: These are the three ways in which an arrest can take place. If you as a police officer do any of these things, then you have arrested a person.
107
What are the 4 occasions for arrest?
Offence Warrant Breach of the Peace Other Specific Power
108
What is an offence?
(1) Offence: Arresting for an offence will be the most common arrest power that you will use. When a person is committing or has committed an offence, a power exists in section 99 of the Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002 (NSW) commonly referred to as LEPRA, for a police officer to arrest that person. There is significant legislation that is associated with this occasion to arrest.
109
What is a Warrant?
Arresting for a warrant occurs when a court issues a warrant for the arrest of a person. The power provided to police to arrest a person who is named in a warrant of arrest is found in section 101 of LEPRA.
110
What is Breach of Peace?
Arresting a person for a breach of the peace is a common law power (not LEPRA) that police have. Police have the common law power to arrest a person if in their opinion that person is likely to cause a breach of the peace.
111
What are Other Specific Powers?
Arresting a person by virtue of some other specific power occurs when a piece of legislation provides police with the power to arrest a person for some purpose other than for an offence.
112
What makes a Lawful Arrest?
99(1)(a) + 99(1)(b) + 99(3) + 202
113
What is 99 (1a)
Section 99(1) - A police officer may, without a warrant, arrest a person if (a) the police officer suspects on reasonable grounds that the person is committing or has committed an offence To satisfy 99(1)(a) you must have a reasonable suspicion that the person (suspect) has committed an offence.
114
What is 99 (1b)?
i. to stop the person committing or repeating the offence or committing another offence, ii. to stop the person fleeing from a police officer or from the location of the offence, iii. to enable inquiries to be made to establish the person's identity if it cannot be readily established or if the police officer suspects on reasonable grounds that the identity information provided is false, iv. to ensure that the person appears before the court in relation to the offence, v. to obtain property in the possession of the person that is connected with the offence, vi. to preserve evidence of the offence or prevent the fabrication of evidence, vii. to prevent the harassment of, or interference with, any person who may give evidence in relation to the offence, viii. to protect the safety or welfare of any person (including the person arrested), ix. because of the nature and seriousness of the offence.
115
What does CAN'T FIGHT IN A PALACE EVERYTHING IN HERE NICE mean?
i. to stop the person committing or repeating the offence or committing another offence, ii. to stop the person fleeing from a police officer or from the location of the offence, iii. to enable inquiries to be made to establish the person's identity if it cannot be readily established or if the police officer suspects on reasonable grounds that the identity information provided is false, iv. to ensure that the person appears before the court in relation to the offence, v. to obtain property in the possession of the person that is connected with the offence, vi. to preserve evidence of the offence or prevent the fabrication of evidence, vii. to prevent the harassment of, or interference with, any person who may give evidence in relation to the offence, viii. to protect the safety or welfare of any person (including the person arrested), ix. because of the nature and seriousness of the offence.
116
The FINECHAPS acronym is designed to help you recall the 99(1)(b) 'Reasons for arrest'. It stands for?
F - fleeing I - identity N - nature E - evidence C - committing H - harassment A - appearance P - property S - safety
117
What is Section 99 (3)?
The arresting police officer or another police officer must, as soon as is reasonably practicable, take the person who has been arrested under this section before an authorised officer to be dealt with according to law.
118
What is a safeguard?
A safeguard is a specific instruction that outlines the limits to, or responsibilities that go with a power. That safeguard is found in LEPRA s 202 and is entitled: "Police officers to provide information when exercising powers."
119
What is Section 202(1) LEPRA?
Section 202(1) LEPRA A police officer who exercises a power to which this Part applies must provide the following to the person subject to the exercise of the power: evidence that the police officer is a police officer (unless the police officer is in uniform), the name of the police officer and his or her place of duty, the reason for the exercise of the power.
120
What does IPE mean?
I- Inform reason for exercise of power P- Provide your name to the person and your place of duty E- Evidence you are an officer (UNLESS IN UNIFROM)
121
What is a Bail CAN?
A Bail CAN is simply a CAN whereby ‘bail’ has been considered during the charging process and a determination has been made whereby the accused person has either been: Unconditional Bail: Released from custody with no bail conditions Conditional Bail: Released from custody with bail conditions that the accused person must apply with Bail Refused: Not released from custody. In the circumstance the accused will stay in custody (usually corrective services) until the first court date
122
What is Section 105 of LEPRA?
Section 105 of LEPRA exists for circumstances similar to this, whereby, police MAY discontinue the arrest and either proceed by one of the other options for commencing legal proceedings or continue the investigation.
123
When must the official caution be given?
when a person is placed under arrest, or when police believe there is sufficient evidence to establish a person has committed an offence and you intend to question them about that offence
124
Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002 (NSW) s 109 s 109 Objects of Part States?
When a suspect is arrested and conveyed back to a police station, they will be taken immediately into the custody room and introduced to the custody manager. A custody manager must complete a form for each person who comes into their custody, which outlines the rights of these persons. The form is completed and read out by the custody manager to the person ensuring they understand their rights while in police custody. There are two different forms, one for a person who is arrested and not free to leave, and the other for a person who is not under arrest and is free to leave.
125
What is form 31 and 32?
form 31 for a detained person (arrested for an offence and not free to leave) form 32 for protected suspects (not under arrest and free to leave at any time)
126
What is to be in custody?
To be in custody is to be in the care and control of the police, at a police station or other place of detention.
127
What is Part 9 of LEPRA?
The period for which police may detain the person is ‘for a reasonable time’ but not more than six hours. Police may apply for a detention warrant to have those six hours extended if necessary. The Part applies to: persons who have been arrested, and persons who are in the company of police to assist in the investigation of an offence but are not under arrest (protected suspect)
128
What are LEPRA 112, 115, 118?
LEPRA s 112 outlines certain persons that the application of the part may be modified for LEPRA s 115 outlines the investigation period LEPRA s 118 states the requirements for a detention warrant to extend the investigation period
129
What is Section 117 of LEPRA?
Section 117 of LEPRA provides for certain activities to not be included in the six-hour investigation time for a person detained at a police station. If one of the activities listed in section 117 is occurring, (e.g., time taken to wait for an interpreter to attend station) then the time it takes to complete that activity is considered a time out and does not contribute to the six-hour time limitation
130
What is a field arrest?
When police arrest and convey someone to a police station, they must complete the field arrest report by accessing the Custody Application Icon on the computer desktop or Mobile Data Terminal (MDT).
131
What does Section 136 State?
Section 136 of LEPRA indicates that photographs and fingerprints should not be taken of a child under the age of 14, except where a court order exists. Section 136 also indicates that only a sergeant of police (or above) may apply for a court order to take photographs and fingerprints of a person under the age of 14.
132
What does Section 133 of LEPRA state?
The power to take fingerprints and photographs of a person over the age of 14 to identify a person who is in lawful custody for any offence comes from Section 133 of LEPRA.
133
What are the last 6 questions
Is there anything further you wish to say about the matter Have the answers you have given to my questions been made in your own free will Has any threat, promise or offer of advantage been held out to you to give the answers as recorded in this notebook interview. Will you now read aloud my record of our conversation Is this interview a correct record of our conversation Will you now sign the interview as a correct record of our conversation
134
What is a Charge Folder?
the investigating police will create a charge in the WebCOPS system. The system will allocate a charge number (beginning with H - e.g. H123456789). The system then generates all the relevant documents for inclusion in the charge/court folder.
135
What does the charge folder include?
he charge folder is provided to the court for the first court date (called the ‘plea or mention’) in order for the court to have the general information of the matter. The documents contained within the folder include information such as details of the offence, the accused person, proof that the accused was served with a CAN (defendant service copy) and an account of what the police are alleging in terms of how the offence was committed (Facts Sheet).
136
What is left out of the charge folder?
The charge folder does not include all statements and other pieces of evidence, which are produced in a brief of evidence at a later date if the accused pleads not guilty, or if the court orders for a brief of evidence to be served upon the defence (accused).
137
Charge Folder may Include?
covering sheet court Attendance Notice (FCAN, FSCAN or Bail CAN) the CAN contains details of the offence, accused and the court date copies for the prosecutor, informant (OIC), court, and the defendant the information contained in the CAN must comply with the Criminal Procedures Act 1986 (NSW) s 175 defendant service copy facts sheet contains the alleged actions of the accused copies for the prosecutor, informant (OIC), court, and the defendant criminal and/or traffic records of the defendant unavailable dates of all witnesses (including police) any bail papers (if applicable)
138
What is a Fact Sheet?
A Facts Sheet is one of the documents that a police officer creates in WebCOPS to be included as part of the charge/court folder. It is a very important document as it is: a comprehensive record, of the alleged actions, of the accused, set out in chronological order, which satisfy the elements of the offence for the court.
139
Are Facts Sheets Evidence?
Remember, Facts Sheets are NOT evidence. Facts Sheets are not subject to the Oath and are not cross-examined or tested.
140
What are antecendents?
Antecedents are included in the Facts Sheet to provide the court with information on the accused person to assist in determining bail or penalties upon conviction. Antecedents do not refer to the person’s criminal history, but rather their personal circumstances, especially as they impact on bail. Include any police concerns as to lack of community ties, being a flight risk and/or intimidation of witnesses. Antecedents should include personal details such as marital status, dependents, community ties, employment, earnings, and expenses in dollar value. NEVER INCLUDE THE ACCUSED’S CRIMINAL HISTORY IN THE ANTECEDENTS.
141
What are the body of facts?
It is important to remember that the Facts Sheet focuses upon the actions of the accused, not the victim or police. first relevant act of the offence chronological account of the acts relevant to the offence what happened to the victim? what did the police do? extra details the Magistrate/Judge may need to assist in sentencing
142
What did Police Do Section Body of Facts?
locations police visited compliance with legislative requirements (Part 15 safeguards, official caution etc). obtaining of statements and any other evidence any search and property located any admissions, relevant to the offence, provided by the accused (in first person) how admissions were recorded information relating to custody and interviews
143
Facts sheets for penalty notices:
When a penalty notice is issued, such as a traffic infringement notice or a criminal infringement notice, the accused person may elect to have the matter heard at court, in effect this is a plead of ‘not guilty’. In these instances, the penalty notice is by its design a replacement for a Facts Sheet.
144
What is a police statement?
A police statement will provide a truthful, accurate and chronological written account of the police officer’s response, observations and actions in relation to the investigation. The content of the police statement must comply with legislation, policy, and procedure. This will ensure the admissibility of evidence and assist in proving the alleged offence(s) or establishing some elements of the offence(s). Police statements are completed by all officers that have some evidence to provide to the court in relation to the investigation including: The Officer in Charge (OIC) and officer who is Second in Charge (2IC), police who convey suspect to police station, exhibit officers, Scene of Crime Officers (SOCO’s), Custody Manager, etc… Evidence Act s33 ALLOWS FOR POLICE TO READ STATEMENT INTO EVIDENCE MSG - MADE SIGNED GIVEN
145
What are Paragraph 1-5 of a police statement?
Paragraph 1 All Police Statements must start with an Endorsement. This is contained in Paragraph 1 of the statement. Reference: Criminal Procedure Act 1986 (NSW) s 283B(3) Criminal Procedure regulation 2017 (NSW) s 9I Paragraph 2 The second paragraph of your police statement must contain the age of the person making the statement. Write a sentence as 'I am 40 years old'. Reference Criminal Procedure Act 1986 (NSW) s 283B(2) Paragraph 3 In paragraph three, make a record of any material that you may have used to refresh your memory. For example, COPS entries, your official police notebook, CAD, Mobipol, Body Worn Video. Paragraph 4 Outline the duties you were performing at the time. Include the fact you were in a police uniform and wearing body-worn video. Paragraph 5 Outline how you came to attend the job. This may have been dispatched via the Computerised Aided Dispatch (CAD) System during the course of your duties, or from patrolling. Times should be written in 12-hour format e.g., 7:00am, 7:00pm. Dates are written in the following format. e.g., 1 February 2021.
146
Do the main body of your police statement need to be in chronological order?
Your police statement should be written in chronological order, meaning the order in which events occurred during the investigation should be recorded, in that same order, within your statement.
147
What is needed at completion of police statement?
Upon completion of your police statement, you will need to sign the statement on the line above your name on the bottom right-hand side of each page. You will need a witness who is another police officer, preferably independent of the investigation, to witness your signing of the statement. The officer who witnesses your signature will need to sign on the line above their name on the bottom left-hand side of each page. Information contained underneath your signature needs to include the following: Full name Rank Station Date statement made The police statement must be signed on the date it was completed. It should never be backdated. The requirement of signatures from the maker of a statement and a witness of their signature is legislated. Reference Local Court Rules 2009 (NSW), Regulation 3.13(2)(d) Criminal Procedure Regulation 2017 (NSW), section 9K
148
Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) s 33 States?
For a police statement to be read out loud in court, the police statement must meet the following criteria: Made at the time or soon after the event Signed when it was made Given to the accused person or their legal representative a reasonable time prior to the hearing If the above requirements are not met, you will not be able to read your police statement out loud in court when giving evidence and will be required to recall the contents of your police statement without referring to it. A good police statement is indicative of a thorough Police investigation.
149
What is a Brief of Evidence?
A brief of evidence is a collection of documents that have been obtained throughout an investigation which provides the evidence that is likely to be adduced during the relevant court hearing. s 183 Brief of evidence to be served on accused person where not guilty plea
150
What is the Purpose of a Brief of Evidence?
A brief of evidence should: Establish to the Court all the elements of the offences charged Negate possible defences that may be raised by the defendant Identify the defendant as the person who committed the offence
151
What does a Brief of Evidence Inc?
Covering sheet (summary or indictable) Contents list (including reference to any outstanding statements, certificates, or items) Summary of evidence form Court Attendance Notice/s Facts sheet As well as the following evidentiary documents: Statements from police and other witnesses including victims Any statement obtained in a notebook should be photocopied and annexed to a typed version of that statement Any interview with a suspect in a notebook should be photocopied and annexed, with a typed version, to the statement of the police officer who conducted the interview. Exhibits and/or photographs ERISP DVD and transcript (the OIC must arrange for the ERISP to be transcribed) CCTV footage and/or Body Worn Video footage Any additional attachments (e.g., warrants or ADVOs) which, taken together, form the basis of the prosecution case Any documents such as criminal and/or traffic records, unavailable dates etc. (These are technically administration documents but sit at the end of the brief of evidence)
152
What makes a good brief?
Attention to detail Orderly Exhaustive Compliant Administration
153