Eugenics and Dalton Flashcards
(29 cards)
Anthropometric Library
Exhibition, by Galton, where visitors administered neurophysiologically based tests - prototypes for modern intelligence tests.
Social Darwinism
Political systems and societies, like animal species, evolve because of natural selection.
Herbert Spencer
Coined survival of the fittest. Promoted social darwinism.
Plato
“The best men must have intercourse with the best women as frequently as possible, and the opposite is true of the very inferior.” Book Plato’s Republic
Galton
Eugenics plus so many other things (regression, correlation and gobs of other good stuff. Was religious but then went full in on fit marrying fit.)
Positive eugenics
Promote the “best” breeding with the best
Negative eugenics
Cull or prevent the “worse” or least desirable from procreating
Difference between eugenicists and social Darwinism
Eugenicists argued that social policy required to improve the state. Social Darwinism argued that competition would result in optimal state. You could almost look at eugenics like artificial selection (dictated) and social darwinism is like natural selection (let the environment do it’s thing)
Supporters of Eugenics
Well, Bell, Keynes, Kellogg
Types of Eugenic social policies
Promoting differential birth rates
Compulsory sterilization (For even things like anxiety)
Mariage restrictions
Genetic screening
Immigration control
Segregation (racial as well as segregation of the mentally ill from the “normal”)
Extermination
List of pros of genetic engineering
Choose desired characteristics
Sex of baby can be chosen thous tis is arguably a negative as well
can prevent genetic disease
Will lower risk of disease overall in future generations
May increase life expectancy
Prevent some forms of discrimination
List of cons of genetic engineering
Unethical
Is the technology well developed
Can harm be caused to the embryo or mother
People with disabilities may feel devalued in society
Financial limitations can only the rich has a designer baby? Is that a problem?
Widening of societal gaps
Many genetic diseases not fully understood?
Is this a slipper slope.
Argued that IQ scores show that Causcasians outscore other ethnicities - may seem socially unacceptable, but white people are genetically superior in terms of intelligence. (Failed to consider the role of socioeconomic status, now recognized as an important influence on IQ scores)
Book called “The Bell Curve” by Herrnstein and Murray” Problematic book
IQ Tests
Problematic based on socioethics. Example tribes with no number systems. Education and socioeconomic status. Where you live matters. In USA, living in a poor city means poorer education. People of ethnic diversity are more likely to live in poorer communities.
Western race science professor or “race realism”. Sows impact of flawed science lingers on, even after qualified scholars have condemned it’s scientific integrity. Academic freedom is disrespected and abused when it is used to promote the dissemination of racist and discriminatory concepts. Scientists have an obligation to society to speak loudly and actively in opposition of such abuse
Statement by Wester about Dr. Philippe Rushton.
Danger of eugenics
Raise the possibility of corruption and atrocity towards fellow human beings.
The sight of a peacock makes me ill
Darwin quote
Cultural Determinism
The culture in which we are raised determines who we are at emotional and behavioural levels. (contrast to genetic determinism) ANY deterministic view that fails to respect individual rights are equally wrong. ex behaviourism
Genetic determinism
Biologically inherited traits and the environmental influences that affect those traits dominate who we are (opposed to cultural determinism) ANY deterministic view that fails to respect individual rights are equally wrong. Eugenics
Time period where Europeans move away from genetic determinism and North American focus on associative learning/ehaviurism
1940’s
Little Albert Father of Behaviourism Don’t coddle kids dude. Kids committed suicide. “Give me a dozen healthy infants, …I’ll guarantee to take any one at random and train him to become any type of specialist…”
Watson
Operant Conditioning
Skinner
Standard Social Science Model SSSM
After WW2. Rise of civil liberties for racial minorities and women. Theories developed to make racism and sexism as untenable as possible. Downplay or denial of inherent differences among individuals.
1Humans are BLANK SLATES. Tabula Rasa.
2Human behaviour is indefinitely malleable. No biological constraints.
3culture exists independently of people.
4Human behaviour is determined by a process of learning, socialization or indoctrination.
5Learning processes are general; can be applied to a variety of phenomena.
6NON_EVOLUTIONARY
Started Empirism, the mind as a Tabula Rasa
John Lock. What comes after nativism