Evaluate The Veiw That Devolution Has Veen Effective For Scotland, Ni And Wales But Not For England/

Question 1

Effective: Scotland (decentralisation of power)

Answer 1

1977 referendum 74% for devolution
Scotland act 1998 established Scottish parliament and many devolved powers like housing, education and health

Question 2

Not effective: Scotland (decentralisation of power)

Answer 2

Scotland lacks unequal power as its still centralised to wm
2016 brexit referendum many Scottish voters voted remain but the uks choice to leave was imposed onto Scotland

Question 3

Effective: Wales and Northern Ireland (modernised the system)

Answer 3

Wales: 1997 referendum 50.3% voted for devolution, able to vary income tax by 10p, health and eduction
Northern Ireland: 1922 partition in has own parliament, 2011-16 67 bills passed

Question 4

Not effective: wales and Northern Ireland (modernised the system)

Answer 4

Both Wales and Northern Ireland lack financial independence and are both highly dependant on the uk gov funding
Barnett formula diff areas get diff funding
Wales being the poorest 9.7k

Question 5

Effective: England (protected rights)

Answer 5

Devolution has led to England having better representation due to the establishment of regional voices within wm
Evel 2015 ensures that MPs representing England have a direct say on English legislation

Question 6

Not effective: England (protected rights)

Answer 6

Before 2015 the West Lothian question was unanswered
MPs from other devolved nations had the ability to vote on English issues but English MPs cannot make decisions ab Scotland