Exam 2 Flashcards
(69 cards)
Why Linguistic Universals are a potential argument for the Innateness Hypothesis
- Universals are unique to a language (not shared with other mental modules)
- Hard to explain in any other way than to say that they are ‘built in’
What are the two steps of finding Universals of a language?
Description
Explanation
Define description as a step of finding universals of a language
Gathering data
Define explanation as a step of finding universals of a language
Formulating hypotheses, building theories
How many languages are in the world?
Around 7,000
Explain the logical status of a valid linguistic universal
True language universals must be language-specific universals
Why we cannot say that any linguistic universal supports the IH
- Something that is true of all communication systems is true of all languages… therefore it is not a language-specific universal
- If a property is innate, it is universal… however, every universal property is not innate
Criterial for a good universal
- One has to exclude other possible explanations
* The universal has to be language-specific (i.e. exclusive to language and not some broader class of cognitive systems)
List 4 possible alternative explanations for language specific universals
- Monogenesis
- Evolution
- Neural Architecture
- Other biological constraints
Alternative Explanations for language-specific universals: define monogenesis
All languages stem from one mother language
Alternative Explanations for language-specific universals: define evolution
all evolved things have hierarchical structure
Alternative Explanations for language-specific universals: define other biological constraints
Speech/hearing apparatus
Covert Universals
Regard the mental grammar which is ‘hidden’
Overt Universals
Regard properties of utterances which are observable
language-specific universal
The universal is specific to the cognitive domain that we call language. (specific does not mean a type of language ex. English & Russian)
What are the 3 types of language-specific universals
- Unconditional
- Implicational
- Disjunctive (Parameters)
Explain unconditional universals
X is (un)true of all languages
Explain implicational universals
If a language has property X it will have property Y. Or it cannot also have property Y
Explain disjunctive universals (AKA Parameters)
Each language has either X or Y
What do parameters capture?
That the differences between languages are limited.
Universals can be…
Absolute or statistical
Absolute Universal
All languages have X, meaning there is no language without X
Statistical universal
All languages have X, meaning there is a strong tendency for language to have X
What is typological studies? What universal is it related to?
Covers large numbers of languages. Focus on shallow, observable, measurable properties of utterances. Overt Universal