Explanations for Obedience Flashcards
(61 cards)
what is obedience
a type of social influence defined as complying with the demands of an authority figure
what is the difference between obedience and conformity in terms of response
obedience occurs in response to explicit order, whereas conformity occurs in response to implicit pressure
what is the difference between obedience and conformity in terms of occurrence
obedience occurs within a social hierarchy whereas conformity occurs between people of equal status
what are the three situational variables affecting obedience
proximity
location
uniform
how does proximity affect obedience
when an authority figure is in closer proximity, obedience is far higher than when they are not
give an example of how proximity affects obedience
in milgram’s original study 65% obedience rate, in variation where teacher gave the learner instructions over the phone 21% obedience rate
how does location affect obedience
there is a degree of status associated with different locations, higher status, more obedience
give an example of how location affects obedience
milgram’s original study took place in Yale University giving the participants confidence in the integrity of people involved, milgram’s variation took place in a rundown office building, obedience fell from 65% to 47.5%
how does uniform affect obedience
uniforms act as a symbol of authority, if someone wears one they are considered an authority figure
give an example of how uniform affects obedience
milgram’s original study - 65% obedience, teacher in grey lab coat
variation of the study - 20% obedience, teacher in everyday clothes
who studied how situational variables affect obedience
Milgram
which dispositional factors affected milgram’s study
participants were paid £4.50
personality of each participant
who formed the participants for milgram’s study
40 american males aged 20-50
how did milgram’s experiment involve deception
participants believed they were taking part in a study of memory and learning
what were the aims of the observation
to test the ‘germans are different’ hypothesis
what role did the participant play in the observation
‘teacher’
what role did the experimenter play
‘experimenter’
what role did the confederate play
‘leaner’ = victim
what phrases did the experimenter reply to the participant with
- please continue
- the experiment requires that you continue
- it is essential that you continue
- you have no other choice you must continue
- although painful, the shocks do no permanent damage
how did the observation have the issue of the right to withdraw
the experimenter told the participant they had ‘no other choice you must continue ‘
in milgram’s observation what was an obedient participant said to be
one who administered the 450 volts (the highest one 30/30 level)
what effort was made to make sure the participant left in a state of wellbeing
the participant and the learner met afterwards to resolve any tension that arose during the experiment
what were the findings of milgram’s original experiment
65% went all the way to 450 volts
100% went to 300 volts
participants showed signs of extreme tension
what conclusions were made from milgram’s original study
the ‘germans are different’ hypothesis is wrong
people obey those regarded as authority figures
we will obey orders that go against our moral code