Geopolitics Flashcards
(46 cards)
origins of geopol
late 19th century, geog intoduced to higher education
mao making, navigation, exploration, less intellectual discussion
imperialism
Ratzel
Created scientific basis for relationship between states, each state is an organism, engaged in struggle with one another to survive. (no peaceful coexistence, conflict is inevitable, legitimises and depoliticises conflict)
Rudolf Kjellen 1899
coined term geopol, strived for science of political procesess
Mackinder
use geopolitical ideas as mechanism for predicting future
heartland thesis (1904)
sea power waning, land power increasing
eurocentric
feared alliance between russia adn germ - threat to imperial power, fear based motivation
maybe strategic warning dressed up as theory
influence on global strategy - isiah bpwnam - treaty of versailles, pushed for yugoslav state as a buffer
Petr Kroptkin
argues Darwinism is as much about cooperation as conflict, pointed out colonial history of struggling nations
Nazi expansionism
Karl Haushofer - Lebensraum, states are like organisms, need space
Germany lacked land and potential
Newspaper for geopol
Post WWII politcal context
geopol as a practice diminished
geog as a discipline moved towards quantification and postivism
simplification of actual worldly functions - erases geographical differences
objective imagination, no cultural differentiation
Yves Lacoste 1973
geopol as a tool to serve military and political elites, not neutral nor scientific
criticise US militarism in Vietnam
how IS military used geographical date for bombing campaigns, targeting supply routes, controlling populations and resources
geog not a neutral discipline
O Tuathail 1986
laid foundation for critical geopol
critiqued deterministic approach - ignores political and ideological process shaping geopolitical decisions
how discorse, power and ideology shape understanding of global pol
1992 - U.S leaders using geopilitical narratives to create moral and strategic justification for cold war actions -
- framed it as ‘front line’,, us action needed to contain, vital to us interestss (domino theory)
- justified military regimes and counterinsurgency groups
- el salvador was a symbolic battleground, overlooking the real lives and peopl e
- reducing complex issues to vinaries
foucault on power
rejected traditional views of power, it operates across networks and institutions
shift from hard power to discourses and norms
“knowlegde is power”, geopolitical knowledge, maps, intelligence reports etc are not neutral, reflect interests of producers
how particular ideas are made meaningful and assumed to be ‘common sense’
orientalism and discourse
Siad (1978), production od discourse of the orient as backwart, deviant and submissive in european art, literature
legitimised and permitted colonialism
development and geopol
escobar (1995), int dev is a discourse produced after WWII
legitimises intervention in ‘underdeveloped states’
draws on foucault and said
popular geopolitics
explores how geopolitical ideas are conveyed through popular artefacts
top gun - military anxiety, masculinity
sites of geopolitical discourse
formal (academics, intellectuals)
practical (politicians)
popular (musicians, artists, film)
social media branches all three
political context of unipolar world
immediate post cold war
fall of berlin war, ideological struggle of history is over
liberal democracy has won
fragmentation of yugoslavia into 7 states
could be viewed as wars requiring intervention (bosnia - ethnic cleansing, genocide)
humanitarian crisis (refugee)
foreign interention risked involvement in unwinnable conflict (vietnam quagmire)
western militarism
9/11, localised with global impacts
‘war on terror’ 20th september, binary storyline
act of war, legitimising US freedom to respond
connected to attacks on afghanistan 2001 and iraq 2003
alternative discourses to militarism
Treat the act as a crime, rather than act of war. Seek international judicial response, involving a form of patience.
colonial/imperial legacies. A product of the ‘colonial present’
discursive interventions make certain policies appear feasible (Kuus, 2007)
Material manifestations only make sense in certain discursive frames
legacies of US militarism
Images and narratives glorify military power.
Continued currency of 9’11 comparison, October 7th compared (Biden, 2023)
Study of newspapers in arab world, cartoonists ridicule moral foundations of US, cartons did not create this view, it already existed
rise of feminist geopol
1960’s, critical geographies splintered, rise of feminist and marxist geog
masculinist rationality must be seperated from field of study to provide independent observation (Rose 1993)
all observations are embodied, therefore contain baises
Women and Geography studdy group (WGSG) in RGS
Interest in positionality, how our own identity shapes experience and topics of research
Concerned with transformation
Should not be thought as separate from mainstream geography
Challenges mainstream geographical accounts
Multiple scales, body, home, locality. How geopolitical ideas present themselves in everyday lives
Situated nature of critical geopolitics
Nioxiolo 2007
Significance of intersectionality, difference between races, class, disability, and how they compound marginalisation - shape unique vulnerabilities
auction block as site designed for commodification of black bodies, scales of plantation, region, and global slave trade.
Koopman 2011
‘alter-geopolitics’, examining grassroots struggles to build solidarity.
Examines protective accompaniment in Colombia, where US citizens accompany activists or threataned communities (foriegn, white, people, whose harm would draw more attention)
White saviour idea.
Intimate geopol
clark 2017 - focuses on refuge, belief, and peace as counterpoints to representations of the region (middle east) in popular geopolitics in terms such as displacement, religious radicalism or violence
neoclassical geopolitics
emphasises structure of international system, distribution of power
includes analysis of geography and resources (classical) , domestic factors, int system