Improving intergroup relations Flashcards
What was the Rwandan genocide?
- 100-day civil war in 1994 between Hutu & Tutsi
- mass slaughter of Tutsi & moderate Hutu by Hutu majority (500,000-1,000,000 Tutsi deaths)
What is the Israel-Palestine conflict about?
- borders, water rights, control of Jerusalem
- since 2000, 1,000+ Israel deaths & 9,000+ Palestinian deaths
Negative intergroup relations are a destructive force of extreme prejudice & conflict.
What are some less extreme but more pervasive effects of prejudice?
- hate crimes
- discrimination towards low-power groups in society
What are some negative effects of prejudice on target groups?
- self-fulfilling prophecies
- stereotype threat
- self-esteem
What did Jussim & Harber (2005) find about SFPs & prejudice?
Jussim & Harber (2005) – SFPs occur in classrooms but effects are usually small; powerful SFPs may occur amongst students from stigmatised groups
What did Steele & Aronson (1995) find about stereotype threat & prejudice?
Steele & Aronson (1995) - culturally-shared stereotypes that suggest poor performance of certain groups can disrupt the performance of a person who identifies with that group
African Americans did worse on a verbal exam than Whites in the stereotype threat condition (told that the test indicated their underlying intellectual abilities) but performance was the same in the non-threat condition (not diagnostic of ability)
What did Hogg (1985) find out about self-esteem & prejudice?
Hogg (1985) - women generally share men’s negative stereotypes of women & evaluate themselves in terms of such stereotypes
Under circumstances where gender is the salient bias of self-perception, women report a reduction in self-esteem
What are the models of categorisation?
- Decategorisation
- Cross categorisation
- Recategorisation
What component is essential in the formation of prejudice?
Categorisation (group distinctions)
Who proposed the model of decategorisation?
Brewer & Miller (1988)
What is the basis of decategorisation?
Group categories are abandoned & people are encouraged to think of others in an interpersonal context (rather than intergroup)
There is a focus on personal/individual features
Bettencourt et al. (1992) separated pps into 2 groups (each wore different badges)
- decategorisation group focused on the personal features of the task (interpersonal)
- control group focused on the task (intergroup)
Groups worked together on the task, what did they find?
Bettencourt et al. (1992) - the decategorisation group showed reduced intergroup bias
What are the limitations of the decategorisation model?
X not possible for visibly distinct groups (e.g. race, gender) (Simon, Aufderheide & Kampmeier, 2001)
X real-life social identities are important for our self-definition –> people are usually unwilling to relinquish them (Tajfel & Turner, 1979)
X positive effects towards individual members aren’t likely to be generalised to the who out-group (individual isn’t viewed as an out-group member) = subtyping
Wilder (1984) studied subtyping. What is it?
Subtyping is when perceivers respond to members of a target group who disconfirm their stereotypes by seeing them as exceptions to the rule & placing them in a separate subcategory away from members who confirm the stereotype
What did Hewstone & Brown (1986) say is necessary for the generalisation of positive effects (from the individual to the whole group)?
Hewstone & Brown (1986) – some level of category salience/awareness is necessary for generalisation of the positive effects to the whole out-group
What is the basis of cross categorisation?
Our social identities are made of many group memberships
People are encouraged to think of out-group members in terms of how similar they are to us on other category dimensions
Give an example of cross categorisation
Female / male
Psychology / business
If you are FP = double in-group
If you are MB = double out-group
–> simple categorisation
FB & MP = one in-group dimension
–> cross categorisation
Which researcher/s studied boys & girls given red & blue pens?
What did they do/find?
Deschamps & Doise (1978)
Boys & girls sat around a table
Half were given red pens, half given blue pens (crossed gender & pen-colour categories)
Pps rated in-group & out-group (gender) performance
Found that simple categorisation = intergroup bias; cross categorisation = reduced intergroup bias
What is a limitation of cross categorisation?
Potentially problematic for the double out-group
Who proposed recategorisation as a way of reducing prejudice?
Gaertner et al. (1993)
What is the basis of recategorisation (Gaertner et al., 1993)?
The model seeks to alter which categorisations are used & replace subordinate (‘us’ ‘them’) categorisations with superordinate (‘we’) categorisations
How does the recategorisation model say we can reduce intergroup bias?
Bias is reduced by improving attitudes towards former out-group members, owing to their recategorisation from out-group to in-group
How is intergroup bias often expressed, according to Gaertner et al. (1993)?
Intergroup bias is often expressed as in-group favouritism rather than out-group derogation
How can out-group members be viewed more positively, according to the recategorisation model?
If out-group members are perceived as in-group members, they will be viewed more positively