(Internal Factors) Ethnicity & Educational Achievement Flashcards
(14 cards)
Labelling & teacher racism
- Black pupils are often seen as aggressive & Asian pupils as passive
- Teachers may teach pupils from ethnic minorities differently
What did Gillborn & Youdell (2000) show
- Teachers quicker to discipline black pupils
- Teachers have ‘racialised expectations’
- Black pupils in turn feel teachers underestimate them & pick on them
- This may stem from teacher racism, rather than pupils’ actual behaviour
What did Bourne (1994) & Osler (2001) show
Black pupils more likely to be sent out of class; placed in PRUs; excluded/expelled
A- c economy & educational triage in action
- Black pupils more likely to be placed in lowest streams due to teacher labelling & racism
What did Foster (1990) find
Found that black pupils were in lower sets because of their perceived behaviour rather than their academic ability
What did Cecile Wright (1992) find
- Found that teachers held ethnocentric views: saw British culture & standard English to be superior
- Teachers tend to assume Asian pupils will have poor English
The 3 types of racist teachers that Heidi safia mirza (1992) showed
- Colour- blind: teachers who believe all pupils are equal but doesn’t challenge racism he/she witnesses
- Liberal chauvinists: teachers who believe Black pupils are culturally deprived & have low expectations of them
3.Overt racists: teachers who believe blacks are inferior & actively discriminate against them
The 3 student identities according to their ethnicity showed by Archer (2008)
- Ideal pupil ( white, M/C, ‘normal’ sexuality. Achieves the ‘right way’)
- Pathologised pupil ( Asian, ‘deserving poor’, asexual. The plodding conformist)
- Demonised pupil ( Black/white, W/C, hyper-sexualised. Unintelligent, culturally deprived)
Where do teachers generally place BAME pupils in archers 3 pupils identities
2/3; seeing black pupils as loud, challenging & excessively sexualised; seeing Asian pupils as docile, passive & quiet
Mary fuller (1984): Black girls in ldn comprehensive school study
- Untypical high achievers in high streams where most black girls were in low streams
- Instead of internalising negative stereotypes, they channelled their anger in to educational success
- did not seek approval of teachers ( who they saw as racist)
- maintained relationships with lower streamed pupils
- only conformed to school work, but not to school rules
-relied on their own efforts/abilities to pass exams
Tony Sewell (1992) 4 responses of black boys to teacher racism study
- Rebels ( small minority, reject goals & rules, anti-authority ‘black macho lad’, identify with hegemonic masculinity)
- Conformists ( largest group, accept goals & rules, keen to succeed, wish to avoid stereotype)
- Retreatists ( tiny minority, isolated individuals, disconnected from school & subcultures, despised by the rebels)
- Innovators ( 2nd to largest group, pro education but anti school, only conform to schoolwork, therefore friendly with the rebels)
Institutional racism
Discrimination is ‘built in’ to the way institutions such as schools & colleges operate
Individual racism
Results from the prejudiced views of 1 individual
Ethnocentrism
Describes an attitude or policy that gives priority to the culture & viewpoint of one particular ethnic group while disregarding others